'להגיד כי ישר ה - An Explanation to all our Hardships
Added insights on מזמור שיר
Catalog entry: TEFILA (English) no. 4 Pocket Guide p. 78 English 44 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains how Mizmor Shir l'Yom haShabbos, culminating in 'lehagid ki yashar Hashem', teaches that in the Yom shekulo Shabbos every hardship, even the harshest Midas haDin, will be seen as chesed.
The Rav opens with the question of tzaddik v'ra lo that Yirmiyahu raised, and answers that the world was meant to be run by Midas haDin, which today we cannot bear; in the Yom shekulo Shabbos we will see that it was all chesed. He explains the psalm's contrast between the wicked, who sprout like grass and wither, and the tzaddik, who grows slowly like the date palm and the cedar, and shows how the Jewish people outlived Egypt, Bavel, Rome and Greece. He brings the Hafla'ah's reading of the palm and the cedar, Chanoch and Avraham Avinu, and a tangent on good company. Returning to the psalm, he concludes that Hashem is straight. Through the Arizal's combinations of the Shem Havaya for each month, the order of male and female, right and left, he shows that even Tammuz, the Shem backwards, will be revealed as chesed.
Topics: Hester Panim and Suffering · Kabbalas Shabbos and Shabbos Night · Rosh Chodesh and the Months · The Holy Names of Hashem
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why tzaddikim suffer: Midas haDin listed in the guide
The Rav recalls that the psalm's theme is the Yom shekulo Shabbos and brings Yirmiyahu's complaint about tzaddik v'ra lo. He explains that the world was meant to be run by Midas haDin, that today we cannot bear it, and that later we will understand all past suffering as chesed.
-
8:03 Grass and the date palm listed in the guide
The Rav explains why the wicked bloom like grass, quickly and briefly, while the tzaddik grows like the date palm and the cedar. He applies it to the Jewish people, who outlived Egypt, Bavel, Rome, England's ancient people and Greece, and mentions Jews in the camps singing that they would outlive their murderers.
-
14:42 The palm, the cedar, Chanoch and Avraham listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Hafla'ah: the palm gives its strength to its fruit and stays short, while the cedar bears none and grows tall. He contrasts Chanoch, who isolated himself and became a malach, with Avraham Avinu, who taught others, and explains the promise that one who gives his time to talmidim will still grow like the cedar.
-
19:34 Planted in Hashem's house: good company
On 'shesulim b'veis Hashem' the Rav asks why Yaakov struggled to leave the womb when a malach was teaching him Torah, and answers that being with Esav outweighed having such a rebbe, since friends matter more than the rebbe. He brings the Rambam on how strongly one's surroundings shape a person.
-
23:18 Lehagid ki yashar Hashem listed in the guide
Returning to the psalm, the Rav explains that tzaddikim bear fruit even in old age and will live forever in the Yom shekulo Shabbos. The psalm tells us not to look at the present: then we will see that every trouble was for our good, and its purpose is to proclaim that Hashem is straight.
-
26:37 The month's combination of the Shem Havaya listed in the guide
Turning to Musaf of Rosh Chodesh, the Rav explains the Arizal's teaching that each month has its own combination of the Shem Havaya, drawn from a passuk, as with Nisan and Iyar. He explains that male is chesed and the giver, female is din and the receiver, and that Yaakov's sons came before the daughters while by Esav the reverse.
-
31:09 Right over left, chesed over din listed in the guide
The Rav explains that a Jew places right over left, chesed over din, as in putting on the right sleeve first, while Esav is din. He brings the Zohar that Avraham had Yishmael and Yitzchak had Esav first to purge bad chesed and bad din, and contrasts the European way of left first, 'ladies first' and writing from the left.
-
36:31 Tammuz too is chesed listed in the guide
The Rav shows how each month's combination fits its climate: Nisan's straight Shem is chesed, Tammuz's reversed Shem is harsh din, and Tishrei and Teves fall in between. Tammuz is the peak of din, the Shem backwards and at the ends of the words, yet 'lehagid ki yashar Hashem' means that even it will be seen as chesed, and what we see now is an optical illusion.
The shiur, written up
Why tzaddikim suffer: Midas haDin
The Rav recalls that the theme of Mizmor Shir l'Yom haShabbos is the Yom shekulo Shabbos. In this world there is hester panim, and tzaddikim suffer, as Yirmiyahu complained to Hashem in Yirmiyahu 12:1. To explain, the Rav brings Rashi on Bereishis 1:1 that the world was first meant to be created with Midas haDin. Such language, he adds, like Hashem's regret before the Mabul in Bereishis 6:6, is written in human terms, since above there is no time. a,b,c
Grass and the date palm
The psalm answers why the wicked succeed: in Tehillim 92:8 they bloom like grass, which sprouts at once and withers within a season. The tzaddik, in Tehillim 92:13, is like the date palm and the cedar, which take years to grow and then stand for centuries. e,f
So the Jewish people outlive their oppressors. The Rav mentions Jews in the camps who sang to the Nazis that they would outlive them, and asks who knows today of Egypt, Bavel, ancient Rome or the Greeks.
The palm, the cedar, Chanoch and Avraham
The Rav brings the Hafla'ah: the palm puts its strength into fruit and stays short, while the cedar bears none and grows tall. Chanoch isolated himself until he became a malach, yet Hashem chose Avraham, as Nechemiah 9:7 says, because Avraham lowered himself to draw others close. The promise is that one who gives himself to talmidim will still grow like the cedar. g
Planted in Hashem's house
On Tehillim 92:14 the Rav asks why Yaakov struggled to leave the womb, as Rashi on Bereishis 25:22 says, when the Gemara in Niddah 30b says a malach teaches the child the whole Torah. He answers that sharing a classroom with Esav was worse than losing such a rebbe; friends matter more. He brings the Rambam in Hilchos De'os that a person must leave bad surroundings, even for the desert. h,i,j,k
Lehagid ki yashar Hashem
Returning to the theme, the Rav reads Tehillim 92:15: tzaddikim bear fruit even in old age, and in the Yom shekulo Shabbos they will live forever. The psalm says not to look at the present; then we will see that every trouble was for our good. Its purpose, in Tehillim 92:16, is to proclaim that Hashem is straight, as Devarim 32:4 says. l,m,n
The month's combination of the Shem Havaya
Right over left, chesed over din
A Jew places right over left, chesed over din, so the right sleeve goes on first. Esav, as Bereishis 27:40 shows, lives by the sword, the height of din. The Rav brings the Zohar that Avraham, chesed, first had Yishmael, and Yitzchak, din, first had Esav, purging the bad side before holy children came. s,t
European culture, Esav's, puts the left first: buttoning left over right, ladies first, writing from the left. A Jew writes from the right.
Tammuz too is chesed
The combination fits the climate. Nisan, spring, has the Shem straight: chesed. Tammuz, burning hot, when the churban began, has it backwards: din. Tishrei is mixed, with the Days of Judgment and then Sukkos; Teves, the coldest month, is din.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
- d Koheles 7:20 text index In the write-up: 4:58
- e Tehillim 92:8 text index In the write-up: 8:11
- f Tehillim 92:13 text index In the write-up: 8:11
- g Nechemiah 9:7 text index In the write-up: 14:42
- h Tehillim 92:14 text index In the write-up: 20:00
- l Tehillim 92:15 text index In the write-up: 23:39
- n Tehillim 92:16 text index In the write-up: 23:39, 41:55
- o Tehillim 96:11 text index In the write-up: 27:10
- u Esther 5:13 text index In the write-up: 41:55
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Key points
- 4:43 The Rav explains that the world was meant to run by Midas haDin, which people cannot bear today because everyone sins, but in the Yom shekulo Shabbos it will be revealed as chesed.
- 9:15 The wicked flourish quickly like grass and wither, while the tzaddik grows slowly like the date palm and the cedar and endures.
- 12:10 The Jewish people, like the date palm, have outlived all their oppressors: Egypt, Bavel, Rome and Greece.
- 25:53 'Lehagid ki yashar Hashem' means that one day it will be seen that everything Hashem did was straight and for our good.
- 27:30 Each month has its own combination of the Shem Havaya; where the male letters come first it is chesed, and where the order is reversed it is din.
- 42:11 Even Tammuz, where the Shem Havaya is completely backwards and at the ends of the words, will be revealed as straight and chesed.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 0:48 Why do tzaddikim suffer while the wicked prosper?
Answer: 4:54 The world is meant to run by Midas haDin, which we cannot bear now; in the Yom shekulo Shabbos we will see that everything was chesed.
-
Question: 3:19 How can the Torah say Hashem regretted creating man, when He knows the future?
Answer: 3:54 The Torah speaks in human terms, as if in time; above there is no time.
-
Question: 15:57 Who is more important before Hashem, Chanoch or Avraham Avinu?
Answer: 16:03 Avraham, whom Hashem chose, because he gave of himself to bring others close even though it kept him from rising as high as Chanoch.
-
Question: 20:45 Why did Yaakov struggle to leave the womb when a malach was teaching him Torah?
Answer: 21:02 Because he was together with Esav, and friends matter more than the rebbe.
Stories
-
11:12 Singing 'we will outlive you' in the camps
The Rav mentions an account from one who survived the Holocaust. When Jews in the concentration camps knew they were about to be taken into the gas chamber, they all began to sing, facing the Nazis, that they would outlive them.
Insights
- 5:45 The Rav explains that in the future Midas haDin itself will dictate chesed: the Jewish people will be on such a level that they will be comfortable being judged strictly.
- 14:51 Following the Hafla'ah, the date palm stays short because it puts its strength into fruit; so a tzaddik who spends himself on talmidim is promised that he will still grow tall like the cedar.
- 16:21 Hashem chose Avraham Avinu over Chanoch, even though Chanoch rose to the level of a malach, because Avraham lowered himself to reach and draw close other people.
- 20:48 Yaakov wanted to leave the womb despite having a malach as his rebbe, because sharing a classroom with Esav was worse than losing such a rebbe; friends count for more than the rebbe.
- 33:25 Avraham had Yishmael and Yitzchak had Esav first, because each had to discharge the bad side of his attribute, bad chesed and bad din, before giving rise to holy offspring.
- 34:53 The European habit of putting the left first, buttoning left over right, 'ladies first', and writing from the left, reflects Esav's attribute of din, female before male.
- 41:55 In Tammuz the Shem Havaya appears backwards and at the ends of the words of 'zeh einenu shoveh li', the harshest din; 'lehagid ki yashar Hashem' teaches that even this will be revealed as the Shem straight, chesed.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 24:29 The Rav says the psalm teaches not to look at what is happening now; what matters is what will be revealed later.
- 22:45 The Rav says nothing influences a person as much as the company he keeps.
- 32:23 The Rav explains that a Jew aims to place chesed over din, right over left, for example by putting on the right sleeve first.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Chanoch, Dovid HaMelech, Esav, Rashi, Rivka Imeinu, the Arizal, the Haflaah (Rabbi Pinchas Horowitz), the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu, Yirmiyahu HaNavi, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu
Terms הסתר פנים, זכר ונקבה, יום שכולו שבת, לעתיד לבוא, מדת הדין, מדת החסד, מזמור שיר ליום השבת, משפיע ומקבל, סופי תיבות, צדיק ורע לו, צירוף, רבונו של עולם, שם הוי"ה