החוק של פרה אדומה - אהבת הקב"ה אלינו
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע חקת no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 12 תשל"ג (1972–73) Yiddish 55 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that the parah adumah is a chok because it rests on Hashem's love for Klal Yisrael, which is beyond reason, and that Moshe Rabbeinu's humility was itself a chok, which leads into the sin at Mei Merivah and the lesson of believing in oneself.
The Rav opens with the Midrash that Hashem revealed the reason of the parah adumah to Moshe alone, so that all who perform it do so on Moshe's intention. He asks how the parah can atone for the golden calf and answers that a will has no reason: just as a mother's love for her child is beyond logic, Hashem's love for Klal Yisrael comes from the souls being a part of G-d. Moshe, who became one with the Torah, could sense this; Shlomo HaMelech sought it and found it far from him. The parah is also teshuvah through humbling oneself. Moshe's root was in anavah, and he explained his own greatness as a chok. Distinguishing leadership by gevurah from leadership by malchus, the Rav explains why Moshe hit the rock in Miriam's merit but was told to speak to it in his own merit, which clashed with his humility. He concludes that Chukas teaches belief in oneself, and applies it to the bochurim's task of instilling Yiddishkeit.
Topics: The Reasons and Power of the Mitzvos · Hashem's Love for Klal Yisroel · Tumah, Taharah and Mikveh · Moshe Rabbeinu
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Moshe alone was told the reason of the parah listed in the guide
The Rav surveys the parsha and links the weeks of Tammuz to strengthening emunah. He brings the Midrash that Hashem revealed the reason of the parah adumah to Moshe alone, and explains that this way everyone who performs it does so on the intention of the tzaddik who understood it.
-
4:53 A will has no reason: Hashem's love listed in the guide
The Rav brings Rashi's mashal that the parah atones for the golden calf and asks how any offering can wipe away a sin entirely. He answers with the principle that a will has no reason, illustrated by a mother's love for her child, and explains that Hashem's love for Klal Yisrael is of this kind because every Jewish soul is a part of G-d.
-
10:48 Moshe became Torah; every Jew a palace listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the root of the will is in heaven, and only Moshe, who became one with the Torah, could sense it; Shlomo HaMelech wished to become wisdom itself and found it far from him, while Doeg's Torah stayed outside him. He then explains Rashi's mashal: every Jew is the King's palace, a sin defiles it, and teshuvah through humbling oneself cleans it.
-
16:41 A chok demands humility; Moshe's greatness listed in the guide
The Rav adds that a chok is understood only by doing it, bringing Rav Samson Raphael Hirsch on 'sechel tov l'chol oseihem', and that the parah demands humbling oneself, the opposite of the root of the golden calf. He asks how Moshe, the greatest man, could see himself as the lowest, and answers that Moshe treated his own greatness as a chok.
-
22:26 Moshe's root in the mitzvah of humility
The Rav explains that every Jew has a root in a particular mitzvah, and that Moshe's root was in humility, which is bound up with the parah adumah. He then turns to Moshe's sin at Mei Merivah, noting that the meforshim, Rashi and the Ramban among them, struggle to define it, since Moshe was too great for us to grasp his sin.
-
26:58 Gevurah and malchus: two kinds of leadership
The Rav asks why Moshe was told to hit the rock in Beshalach but to speak to it here, and how a chillul Hashem became a kiddush Hashem. He distinguishes leadership by gevurah, through strength and fear, from malchus, where people follow out of attachment, brings the Bnei Yissaschar on the Girgashi and malchus, and tells how a word of the Gerrer Rebbe was followed by many bochurim. A king's messenger carries the king's power.
-
34:01 The well in Miriam's merit; Moshe as a staff
The Rav explains that the well came in Miriam's merit, so Moshe hit the rock as a messenger, like a policeman acting in the king's name. He asks why Moshe needed a staff for his miracles and answers by way of remez that Moshe saw himself as nothing more than a staff in Hashem's hand. After Miriam's death the water had to come in Moshe's own merit.
-
38:45 Speaking to the rock: a test beyond Moshe
The Rav explains that malchus works through speech, as Moshiach will act through the breath of his lips, and that Hashem told Moshe to speak to the rock because the water now came in his own merit. This contradicted Moshe's humility, which saw no merit in himself, so it was a test beyond his powers, and the Rav says it was Hashem's plan that Moshe remain with his generation in the desert.
-
43:22 Believing in oneself; the parsha's flow to shirah
The Rav shows a sequence of emunah: Shlach teaches emunah in Hashem, Korach emunah in the tzaddik, and Chukas emunah in oneself, including in one's own chiddushei Torah. He traces the parsha's order, from the chok of the parah through Miriam's death, Mei Merivah and the messengers to Edom, to the shirah, explaining that emunah leads to shirah, as at the Yam Suf and before the coming geulah.
-
48:02 The bochurim's task: engraving Torah in hearts
The Rav applies the lesson to the bochurim of the beis medrash: like Yiftach, each must fulfill the role Hashem gave him and not say he is too small. Their task is to bring Yiddishkeit and warmth to children exposed to many influences, to be a living example, and to engrave Torah into Jewish hearts, as the word 'chukas' implies; he closes with a tefillah for kiddush Hashem.
The shiur, written up
Moshe alone was told the reason of the parah
The Rav opens by noting that in the weeks beginning with Rosh Chodesh Tammuz one must strengthen oneself in emunah, since the Midrash teaches that shirah comes from emunah, and the coming redemption will bring Jews to that emunah. aa
He then brings the Midrash that Hashem told Moshe: to you I reveal the reason of the parah, for others it is a chok. Every mitzvah has deep kavanos known to tzaddikim, and simple Jews perform it relying on their intention. Since the parah's reason was revealed only to Moshe, all who perform it do so on his intention. b
A will has no reason: Hashem's love
The Rav brings Rashi's mashal from Rabbi Moshe HaDarshan: a maidservant's son soiled the king's palace, so let his mother come and clean it; so the parah comes to atone for the golden calf, which brought death back into the world. He asks how any offering can wipe away a sin so completely. c
He answers with the principle that a will has no reason. One person craves one food and another a different one; one can philosophize about it, but not grasp it. A mother's love for her child likewise has no logical explanation; it comes from the child stemming from her. So too Hashem's love for Klal Yisrael comes from every Jewish soul being a part of G-d above. d
Moshe became Torah; every Jew a palace
The root of every matter lies above this world and can be understood only in heaven. Moshe, who walked in heaven and learned until he became Torah itself, could sense the supernal will. On this the Rav explains Shlomo HaMelech's words, 'I said I will become wise, and it is far from me': Shlomo wanted to become wisdom itself, as Moshe had, and it remained apart from him. Doeg, by contrast, had Torah only on his lips. e,f
A chok demands humility
The Rav adds another aspect. Every mitzvah is understood only by doing it, as Rav Samson Raphael Hirsch explains 'sechel tov l'chol oseihem': the understanding belongs to those who perform it. The parah, a chok, demands that a person humble himself, the opposite of what lay at the root of the golden calf. h
Moshe's root in humility
Gevurah and malchus
The Rav asks why in Beshalach Moshe was told to strike the rock but here to speak to it, and why the pasuk faults him for not sanctifying Hashem yet ends that Hashem was sanctified, a kiddush Hashem emerging from a failing. o,p,q,r
He distinguishes two forces of leadership. Gevurah rules through physical or spiritual strength, and people obey out of fear. Malchus is rare: people follow because they are drawn and wish to be nullified to the leader. The Bnei Yissaschar says the seven nations match seven kelipos, but the Girgashi matched malchus, which bows to Hashem, so it did not fight Yehoshua. s
The Gerrer Rebbe, a calm man, remarked that peyos should hang long, and soon many bochurim did so, not from fear but from attachment. A king's messenger carries the king's power, like a policeman who knocks and says to open in the king's name.
The well in Miriam's merit; Moshe as a staff
The manna came in Moshe's merit, the clouds of glory in Aharon's, and the well in Miriam's. While Miriam lived, Moshe knew the water came in her merit, so he struck the rock as a messenger, like the policeman acting in the king's name. t
Why did he need a staff at all? By way of remez, the Rav explains, Moshe saw himself as nothing more than a staff in Hashem's hand, and Hashem let him act with that feeling. After Miriam died, however, the water had to come in Moshe's own merit.
A test beyond Moshe's powers
Malchus works through speech: Moshiach will remove wickedness with the breath of his lips, not by force. So Hashem told Moshe to speak to the rock, since the water now came in his own merit. u
This contradicted Moshe's whole self-view, which saw no merit in himself; the Rav cites the Smak that one may not think something comes through one's own righteousness. It was a test beyond his powers, and it was Hashem's plan that Moshe remain with his generation in the desert to bring them back at techiyas hameisim. v
Believing in oneself
The sin concerned emunah, and the Rav finds a sequence: Shlach teaches emunah in Hashem, Korach emunah in the tzaddik, and Chukas emunah in oneself. When a person sees he has been placed where he can act for kedushah, he must believe in himself, even in his own chiddushei Torah.
The bochurim's task
The Rav applies this to the bochurim. Like Yiftach, who was small yet had to carry out his task, each must fulfill the role Hashem gave him. Hashem brought them together to bring Yiddishkeit and warmth to children from many homes, exposed to television and movies. He applies to their beis medrash what the Chasam Sofer said of his own yeshivah.
Their task is to light up the darkness before the geulah by being an example in learning, davening, eating and speaking, so children dream of becoming like them, and to give them a taste of Shabbos. 'Chukas' means engraving: Torah must be engraved in Jewish hearts. He closes with a tefillah for kiddush Hashem.
Sources
Torah
- a Bamidbar 19:2 2:23 text index
- g Shemos 25:8 text index In the write-up: 14:51
- i Bamidbar 12:3 text index In the write-up: 20:47
- j apparently Bereishis 18:27 index In the write-up: 22:54
- o Shemos 17:6 text index In the write-up: 27:00
- p Bamidbar 20:8 text index In the write-up: 27:00
- q Bamidbar 20:12 text index In the write-up: 27:00
- r Bamidbar 20:13 text index In the write-up: 27:00
- w apparently Devarim 9:4 40:33 index
- y Shemos 14:31 44:03 text index
- ab Bamidbar 20:14 text index In the write-up: 45:19
- ac apparently Shemos 15:1 47:09 index
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
Key points
- 2:28 Hashem revealed the reason of the parah adumah only to Moshe, so that whoever performs it does so on Moshe's intention.
- 7:27 The parah is a chok because it rests on Hashem's will and love for Klal Yisrael, and a will has no reason, like a mother's love for her child.
- 11:15 Moshe Rabbeinu, who became one with the Torah itself, could sense the reason of the parah.
- 21:51 Moshe's root was in the mitzvah of humility, and he explained to himself his own greatness as a chok he could not understand.
- 37:13 Hitting the rock was leadership as the king's messenger in Miriam's merit; speaking to it was malchus in Moshe's own merit, which clashed with his humility.
- 44:09 Parshas Chukas teaches a person to believe in himself and in the hidden powers of his soul when he is placed in a position to do something for kedushah.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 6:57 How can the parah adumah, or any offering, wipe away the sin of the golden calf entirely?
Answer: 7:27 A will has no reason: Hashem's love for Klal Yisrael is beyond logic, like a mother's love for her child, because Jewish souls are part of G-d.
-
Question: 12:05 Why does Shlomo HaMelech say the wisdom of the parah was 'far from me' instead of simply that he did not know it?
Answer: 12:11 He hoped to become wisdom itself, as Moshe became Torah itself, and this stayed apart from him.
-
Question: 21:40 How could Moshe, the greatest man in the world, consider himself the lowest of all?
Answer: 21:51 He treated his own greatness as a chok: he did not understand why Hashem made him great and did not try to.
-
Question: 34:58 Why did Moshe need a staff to perform his miracles?
Answer: 35:49 By way of remez, Moshe saw himself as no more than a staff, and Hashem let him act with that feeling.
-
Question: 27:33 Why was Moshe told to hit the rock in Beshalach but to speak to it in Chukas?
Answer: 37:13 The first time the water came in Miriam's merit and Moshe acted as a messenger; after her death it had to come in his own merit, through malchus, which works by speech.
-
Question: 40:11 How could Moshe Rabbeinu have failed in such a matter?
Answer: 40:14 Speaking to the rock in his own merit contradicted his humility; it was a test beyond his powers, and it was Hashem's plan.
Stories
-
31:52 The Gerrer Rebbe and the peyos
The Rav tells that the earlier Gerrer Rebbe was a calm person who did not go around stirring things up. In Poland it was customary to tuck the peyos away, a practice going back to an old decree from the Russian period. When Poland was independent, the Rebbe remarked to a bochur that it would be fitting for the peyos to be worn openly and long. The bochur went out and told the others, and within a short time a great many bochurim were going with their peyos showing. The Rav brings this to illustrate midas hamalchus: people follow such a word not out of fear, but because they are drawn to the one who said it.
In the story: the Gerrer Rebbe
Insights
- 9:30 The parah adumah is a chok because it rests on Hashem's will, and Hashem's love for Klal Yisrael is likewise a will without reason, flowing from the souls being part of Him, as a mother's love flows from the child coming from her.
- 12:05 Shlomo HaMelech's 'and it is far from me' means that he wanted to become wisdom itself, as Moshe had become Torah itself, and this remained apart from him.
- 21:51 Moshe's humility was itself a chok: he did not try to understand why Hashem made him great, and so his root lay in the mitzvah of the parah adumah.
- 35:49 The staff with which Moshe performed his miracles hints that he saw himself as nothing more than a staff in Hashem's hand.
- 37:17 Hitting the rock is leadership as the king's messenger, in another's merit; speaking to it is malchus, ruling through speech in one's own merit, like Moshiach who will act through the breath of his lips.
- 43:53 Three consecutive parshiyos teach three levels of emunah: Shlach in Hashem, Korach in the tzaddik, and Chukas in oneself.
- 46:56 The parsha moves from the chok of the parah to the shirah because the lessons of emunah lead to shirah, preparing for the geulah as at the Yam Suf.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 1:12 The Rav says that in the weeks from Rosh Chodesh Tammuz one must strengthen oneself in emunah.
- 44:12 The Rav says that when a person finds himself placed where he can do something for kedushah, he must believe in himself, including in his own chiddushei Torah.
- 51:05 The Rav tells the bochurim that their task is to be a living example for the children, in learning, davening and conduct, so the children will want to be like them.
- 53:51 The Rav says it is not enough to hold Torah within oneself; one must engrave it into Jewish hearts.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Aharon HaKohen, Avraham Avinu, Doeg HaAdomi, Dovid HaMelech, Korach, Miriam, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, Rabbi Moshe HaDarshan, Rabbi Moshe of Kobrin, Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch, Rashi, Shlomo HaMelech, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chasam Sofer, the Gerrer Rebbe, the Ramban, Yiftach
Terms חוקה, חטא העגל, חלק אלוק ממעל, מי מריבה, מלכות, ענוה, פרה אדומה, רבונו של עולם