תפלו על המן שהוא לבן - טעם מנהג לאכילת חלב ב9 טעג

Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע דברים no. ⁨1⁩ Pocket Guide p. 13 תשמ"א (1980–81) Yiddish 1 hr 21 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr 21 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

Starting from the rebuke over the white mann, the Rav explains that the low days of Bein HaMetzarim, and the generation of the 'heel' before Moshiach, hide the greatest chesed, and that this generation's test is an Akeidah: serving Hashem with unanswered questions and strengthening one another.

The Rav asks why Moshe Rabbeinu's rebuke mentions that the mann was white. Every color comes from Heaven, and white is pure chesed; the mann fed Israel the way milk feeds a baby, without toil, so their complaint was against open chesed. Parshas Devarim falls in the Nine Days, when Jews eat milk to arouse the chesed hidden in these low days: where the kelipah is thickest the kedushah is greatest, and the Chasam Sofer says these days will become Yamim Tovim. Tisha B'Av is a moed, and its lesson is that Hashem is with the Jews in exile. History, too, has a Tisha B'Av: the generation of the heel before Moshiach, a time without feeling and of enormous tests. Its test is like the Akeidah, serving Hashem despite questions. Malachi's last counsel is that those who fear Hashem gather and strengthen one another, and Rus, which follows him, shows that destruction precedes the kingdom of David.

Topics: Avodah of the Last Generation · Tisha B'Av

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Why mention that the mann was white? listed in the guide

    The Rav opens with Chazal's reading of 'Lavan' in the first passuk of Devarim as the rebuke over their complaint against the mann, which was white, and asks what the mann's color has to do with the rebuke.

  2. 3:20 White is pure chesed: the mann as a baby's milk listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that every color comes from Heaven and white stands for pure chesed. A baby is fed with milk through chesed alone, without toil, and so were the Jews with the mann in the desert; their complaint was against food that came straight from Heaven.

  3. 10:21 Milk in the Nine Days and the hidden chesed listed in the guide

    Parshas Devarim always falls in the Nine Days, and the Rav explains the custom of eating milk then: white foods arouse the chesed hidden in these days. The days are low because great kedushah lies behind them, as the kelipah is thickest where the kedushah is greatest, and he brings the Chasam Sofer that these days will one day become Yamim Tovim.

  4. 17:44 Tisha B'Av as a moed: what to take away

    Moshiach is born on Tisha B'Av and it is called a moed, a festival still covered over. Just as one takes freedom from Pesach, Torah from Shavuos and simchah from Sukkos, the Rav says one takes from Tisha B'Av the comfort that Hashem mourns and sits with the Jews in their exile.

  5. 24:47 Acharis hayamim and the generation of the heel

    From the Tisha B'Av Torah reading, 'b'acharis hayamim', which the Chasam Sofer reads as Tisha B'Av, the lowest point of the year, the Rav moves to the generations. Like the year and the body, the generations form a shiur komah, from Moshe's generation at the head down to the heel before Moshiach, a part of the body that feels nothing.

  6. 31:55 The Tisha B'Av of history and the worth of a Jew today

    The Rav describes the enormous tests of ikvesa d'Meshicha, with the signs in the Gemara in Sotah, as the Tisha B'Av of history in which every accepted sanctuary of Torah, avodah and decency is destroyed, like an old building torn down before a new one is built. In such a time Jews must hold together, and the smallest good deed of a Jew today is immeasurably precious.

  7. 40:19 Why the Akeidah was Avraham's greatest test

    The Rav asks why the Akeidah is so great. A nisayon both tests and raises, and Avraham's ten tests grew ever harder. The first, being thrown into the fire for a Creator he had found through his own understanding, had no contradiction; at the Akeidah Hashem Himself told him to slaughter the son through whom the promise was to come, and Avraham closed his eyes to the questions and served Hashem without understanding.

  8. 51:53 The last test of Klal Yisrael is an Akeidah

    Using the Ramban's rule that what happened to the Avos is a sign for their children, the Rav concludes that the last test of Klal Yisrael before Moshiach resembles the Akeidah: serving Hashem with unanswered questions, as after the destruction of six million. Like Avraham HaIvri standing alone against the world, a Jew today must hold on to emunah, tznius and shemiras einayim.

  9. 1:00:59 Malachi's last counsel: those who fear Hashem speak together

    As there is an end of days, there is an end of prophecy: Malachi, the last navi, speaks in his last chapter to the last generation, which says serving Hashem is in vain. His answer is 'az nidberu yirei Hashem': those who fear Hashem gather and strengthen one another, remember the Torah of Moshe, and so cross the sea of heresy until Eliyahu comes.

  10. 1:06:54 After Malachi comes Megillas Rus

    The Rav notes that Tanach does not end with Malachi: in the Gemara's order the Kesuvim begin with Rus, and he asks what its message is. He touches on Chazal about the young women who spoke at length with Shaul because one kingdom may not overlap another, and on the rule that an old building is torn down before a new one is built.

  11. 1:12:18 Signs of destruction before the kingdom of David

    In the days of Rus the kingdom of David began to be built, so it opened with signs of destruction: 'the days when the judges were judged', chutzpah and breakdown, the same signs as ikvesa d'Meshicha. The Rav concludes that Moshiach is brought by the individual who stands apart from the crowd's chutzpah and follows Malachi's counsel, that those who fear Hashem help and strengthen one another.

The shiur, written up

Why mention that the mann was white?

0:08

The Rav opens with Rashi on the first passuk of Devarim: there is no place called 'Lavan', so Moshe was rebuking the Jews for complaining about the mann, which was white, the complaint of 'our soul is disgusted with this light bread'. He asks what the mann's color has to do with the rebuke. a,b

White is pure chesed

3:50

To answer, the Rav explains that every color a person sees is sent from Heaven and corresponds to a different power. White is pure chesed, and for this reason the kohanim in the Beis HaMikdash wore white, to draw chesed down onto Klal Yisrael. Food likewise is not just fuel: its taste and its look are part of what nourishes, which is why, as the Gemara says, a blind man is never fully satisfied. c

7:19

A baby's food, its mother's milk, is white because it comes from pure chesed: the baby has not earned it with mitzvos or tefillos. Adam's curse of earning bread by sweat does not touch the baby, and in the desert the Jews were fed the same way, with mann from Heaven. Their complaint was thus against food of open chesed. d

Milk in the Nine Days

10:21

Parshas Devarim always falls in the Nine Days, and the Rav ties this to the custom of eating milk then. Since every food comes from its own root, the white foods of these days are a sign that chesed lies hidden in them; meat is red, a color of sorrow, while milk arouses chesed.

13:23

The days are low precisely because great things are hidden there: where a great kelipah takes hold, the kedushah behind it is greater still, as in Eretz Yisrael. Thus 'all her pursuers overtook her bein hametzarim' is read as reaching the greatest heights in these days. The Rav cites a Lubliner teaching that these are three regalim, and the Chasam Sofer that when Moshiach comes they will become Yamim Tovim. e,f

Tisha B'Av as a moed

17:50

The Midrash says Moshiach is born on Tisha B'Av, and it is called a moed, which is why no tachanun is said. It is a Yom Tov still covered, like a monument under a curtain that will one day be unveiled. g

20:12

From every Yom Tov one takes something for the year: from Pesach freedom, from Shavuos Torah, from Sukkos simchah. From Tisha B'Av, the Rav explains, one takes the Midrash's lesson that Hashem Himself mourns as a king does. Sitting on the ground is a comfort, since the Shechinah is with the Jew in his pain. One must carry this all year, to strengthen oneself in hard times. h

Acharis hayamim and the heel

25:00

The Tisha B'Av reading speaks of exile and of returning to Hashem 'b'acharis hayamim', and the Chasam Sofer reads this as Tisha B'Av, the lowest day. As a body has a head and a lowest part, the year has Rosh Hashanah and these days; the new year's light already begins after Tisha B'Av. i,j,k

27:39

Sefarim read 'vehaya eikev tishme'un' as the time before Moshiach. Following the Arizal, the Rav explains that the generations form a shiur komah, from Moshe's generation at the head down to the last, tiny souls. That last generation is the heel: dark and without feeling, so that one senses no light of Torah or tefillah. l

The Tisha B'Av of history

31:56

The tests of this generation are enormous: the Satan has been given permission, like a condemned man granted a last wish, and the world is full of breach and heresy, the signs the Gemara in Sotah gives for ikvesa d'Meshicha. As each year has its Pesach and its Tisha B'Av, the generation of the desert was history's Pesach, and ikvesa d'Meshicha, which the Chasam Sofer calls acharis hayamim, is its Tisha B'Av. k,m

36:59

Now every accepted sanctuary of Torah, avodah, morality and decency is destroyed, as an old building is torn down to build a new one. In such a time Jews must hold together and strengthen one another. The Rav cites the Arizal that the last generations are in some way greater, and says no one knows how precious a Jew is today when he guards his eyes, holds back lashon hara or learns a blatt Gemara. n

Why the Akeidah was the greatest test

40:20

Every morning the Akeidah is recalled, and the Rav asks why it is so great. 'Hashem tested Avraham', and Chazal note that Hashem asked Avraham to stand this test, lest the earlier ones be rendered empty. A nisayon both tests and raises, like a boy examined so he can move to a higher class, and so each of Avraham's ten tests was harder than the last. o,p

43:10

His first test came after he found the Creator through his own investigation, as the Midrash and Rambam describe: he saw one hand behind trees, seas and animals, like a man seeing a lit palace. He told the world to break its idols, Nimrod threw him into the fire, and only afterwards did Hashem first speak to him with 'Lech lecha'. q,r,s

46:37

At the Akeidah, Hashem, who had promised him descendants through Yitzchak, told him to slaughter that son. The Satan, as the Midrash says, argued against it, but Avraham stood firm. He closed his eyes to the questions and served Hashem without understanding. t

The last test of Klal Yisrael

51:53

The Ramban's rule is that what happened to the Avos is a sign for their children, and he reads Avraham's going down to Egypt and Pharaoh's plagues that way. By this rule, since Avraham was tested ten times, so are his children, and their last test before Moshiach will resemble the Akeidah: serving Hashem though one does not see Him and has questions. u

54:06

The Rav points to the destruction of six million, after which heretics wrote books raising questions against Hashem. The answer may be simple and not yet seen; when Moshiach comes everything will be understood. Until then one must serve Hashem even when the mind is closed and the heart feels nothing, together with Avraham, whose spark every Jew carries.

57:59

Avraham was called 'HaIvri' because he stood on one side and the whole world on the other. So too today, a Jew must hold on to the emunah inherited from Avraham, 'maaminim bnei maaminim', even when the whole world is against him, and to the tznius and shemiras einayim seen in Avraham. v,w

Malachi's last counsel

1:01:32

As there is an end of days, there is an end of prophecy. Malachi was the last navi, and his last chapter speaks to the last generation, which says it is in vain to serve Hashem. His remedy is 'az nidberu yirei Hashem ish el re'eihu': those who fear Hashem come together, speak with each other and strengthen one another, and this is very dear before Hashem. x,y

1:05:28

Malachi then says, 'Remember the Torah of Moshe': with this last counsel the Jews can cross the whole sea of heresy and breach until Eliyahu HaNavi comes. z,aa

After Malachi comes Rus

1:06:54

Tanach does not end with Malachi: in the Gemara's order the Kesuvim begin with Rus, and the Rav asks what this teaches. He touches on Chazal that the young women spoke at length with Shaul because one kingdom may not overlap another, so Shmuel's kingdom had to run its time first. ab,ac

Signs of destruction before the kingdom of David

1:12:23

To build a fine building, the Rav explains, one first tears down the old one. In the days of Rus the kingdom of David began to be built, so its time opened with signs of destruction: 'in the days when the judges were judged', with chutzpah and breakdown. This, he says, is a rule seen also in our time, and it is no bad sign but a sign of the coming redemption. ad

1:17:17

In such a time, the one who brings Moshiach is the yachid, the honest Jew who does not go along with the crowd's chutzpah and foolishness but stands up and shines. He follows Malachi's counsel, 'az nidberu yirei Hashem', until 'I send you Eliyahu HaNavi'. y,aa

1:19:10

The Rav concludes that every Jew must hold on to the Ribono shel Olam and not be dragged along by the stream of the generation, and this task can only be done when those who fear Hashem help one another, 'ish es re'eihu ya'zoru'. n

Sources

Torah

  1. b Bamidbar 21:5 text index In the write-up: 0:08
  2. d Bereishis 3:19 text index In the write-up: 7:19
  3. i Devarim 4:25 text index In the write-up: 25:00
  4. j Devarim 4:30 text index In the write-up: 25:00
  5. l Devarim 7:12 text index In the write-up: 27:39
  6. o Bereishis 22:1 text index In the write-up: 40:20
  7. s Bereishis 12:1 text index In the write-up: 43:10

Nevi'im

  1. n Yeshayahu 41:6 text index In the write-up: 36:59, 1:19:10
  2. x Malachi 3:13-14 text index In the write-up: 1:01:32
  3. y Malachi 3:16 text index In the write-up: 1:01:32, 1:17:17
  4. z Malachi 3:22 text index In the write-up: 1:05:28
  5. aa Malachi 3:23 text index In the write-up: 1:05:28, 1:17:17

Kesuvim

  1. e Eichah 1:3 text index In the write-up: 13:23
  2. ad Rus 1:1 text index In the write-up: 1:12:23

Talmud Bavli

  1. c apparently Yoma 74b index In the write-up: 3:50
  2. m Sotah 49b text index In the write-up: 31:56
  3. p apparently Sanhedrin 89b index In the write-up: 40:20
  4. w Shabbos 97a text index In the write-up: 57:59
  5. ab Bava Basra 14b text index In the write-up: 1:06:54
  6. ac apparently Berachos 48b index In the write-up: 1:06:54

Midrash

  1. g Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 17:50
  2. h Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 20:12
  3. r apparently Bereishis Rabbah 39:1 index In the write-up: 43:10
  4. t Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 46:37
  5. v apparently Bereishis Rabbah 42:8 index In the write-up: 57:59

Rishonim

  1. a apparently Rashi on Devarim 1:1 index In the write-up: 0:08
  2. q Rambam, Mishneh Torah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 43:10
  3. u apparently Ramban on Bereishis 12:6 index In the write-up: 51:53

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. f Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 13:23
  2. k Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 25:00, 31:56

Key points

  1. 4:23 White is the color of pure chesed, and the mann, like a baby's milk, came to Israel through chesed alone, without toil.
  2. 10:46 Jews eat milk in the Nine Days because white foods arouse the chesed that lies hidden in these low days.
  3. 13:23 Where the kelipah is strongest, the kedushah behind it is greatest; the days of Bein HaMetzarim hold the greatest light of the year.
  4. 29:06 The generations form one body, and the generation of the heel before Moshiach is the Tisha B'Av of history: dark, without feeling, and full of great tests.
  5. 46:32 The Akeidah was Avraham's hardest test because he had to serve Hashem against questions he could not answer, and the last test of Klal Yisrael before Moshiach is of that kind.
  6. 1:03:59 Malachi's last counsel for the end of days is that those who fear Hashem should speak with and strengthen one another.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 0:47 Why does Moshe's rebuke mention that the mann was white?

    Answer: 4:23 White is pure chesed; the mann came like a baby's milk, without toil, so the complaint was against open chesed.

  2. Question: 10:42 Why do Jews eat milk in the Nine Days?

    Answer: 11:50 White foods arouse the chesed hidden in these days; meat is red, the color of sorrow.

  3. Question: 40:44 Why is the Akeidah considered so great, when Avraham had already let himself be thrown into fire?

    Answer: 46:37 In the fire there was no contradiction; at the Akeidah Hashem commanded against His own promise, and Avraham served Him without answers.

  4. Question: 1:01:25 How can a Jew hold on in the last generation, when serving Hashem seems in vain?

    Answer: 1:03:59 Through Malachi's counsel: those who fear Hashem gather, speak with one another and strengthen each other.

  5. Question: 1:07:03 Why does Tanach continue after Malachi with Megillas Rus?

    Answer: 1:12:23 In Rus's days the kingdom of David began, and such building is preceded by signs of destruction, as in ikvesa d'Meshicha.

Stories

  1. 44:04 Avraham's discovery of the Creator and the fire

    The Rav tells how Avraham searched until he understood that one Creator made all of nature, the trees, the seas and the animals. He went out into the world calling on people to break their idols, and Nimrod had him thrown into the fire, from which he was saved by a miracle. Only after this did Hashem speak to him for the first time, with 'Lech lecha'.

    In the story: Avraham Avinu, Nimrod

    told in 6 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 7:48 The mann's whiteness is the point of the rebuke: white is pure chesed, and the mann fed Israel as milk feeds a baby, so complaining about it was complaining against open chesed.
  2. 11:50 The custom of eating milk in the Nine Days is not merely avoiding meat: white foods draw down the chesed that is hidden in these days, while red meat belongs to sorrow and din.
  3. 19:52 From every Yom Tov one takes something for the whole year, and from Tisha B'Av, also a moed, one takes the comfort that Hashem is with the Jews in their exile and suffering.
  4. 35:26 History has its own calendar: the generation of the desert was its Pesach, and ikvesa d'Meshicha is its Tisha B'Av, when every accepted sanctuary is destroyed to make room for the new building.
  5. 46:37 Avraham's first test had no contradiction to his understanding, but the Akeidah set Hashem's command against Hashem's own promise; its greatness is serving Hashem while the questions remain open.
  6. 1:07:03 Tanach places Rus right after Malachi because the building of David's kingdom, like the coming of Moshiach, begins with signs of destruction and chutzpah.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 23:13 The Rav says one must take from Tisha B'Av, for the whole year, the strength that Hashem is with the Jews in their suffering, and comfort and strengthen oneself in hard times.
  2. 55:40 The Rav says one must serve Hashem even when it is hard, when the mind is closed and the heart feels nothing, and so pass the last test together with Avraham Avinu.
  3. 59:16 The Rav says Jews must hold on to the emunah inherited from Avraham even when the whole world is against them.
  4. 1:06:48 The Rav says those who fear Hashem must gather and strengthen one another, and so avoid being swept along by the stream of the generation.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Eliyahu HaNavi, Malachi, Moshe Rabbeinu, Nimrod, Rabbi Yochanan, Rus, Shaul HaMelech, the Arizal, the Chasam Sofer, the Rambam, the Ramban

Terms אחרית הימים, בין המצרים, חוצפה יסגא, מועד, מלכות בית דוד, מן, נסיון, עקבתא דמשיחא, עקידה, קליפה, שיעור קומה

Report an error on this page