צד א: בגורל תחלק הארץ - יהודי הוא גורל של הקב"ה - אנו גורלך ואתה גורלנו צד ב: התגלות הסוד שנגנז בימי המצרים
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע מטות מסעי no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 12 תש"מ (1979–80) Yiddish 1 hr 2 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that a Jew is Hashem's goral, bound to Him beyond reason, so he may not attach himself to the ways of the nations, and that the hidden good of the Three Weeks, revealed through the Arizal's teaching of sod, calls for strengthening one another and for tefilah.
The Rav asks why Parshas Masei repeats the division of Eretz Yisroel by goral, already stated in Pinchas, and why it is placed between the command to drive out the inhabitants and the warning about those left behind. He explains that a goral expresses a bond beyond reason: Klal Yisroel is Hashem's goral, as on Yom Kippur and Purim, and an inheritance can never be cut off. Every nation stands under its own heavenly minister, and even its styles of dress come from there; therefore a Jew, Hashem's lot, must not dress, play or rejoice like the nations. In the second part he speaks of the Arizal, whose teaching revealed the hidden side of Torah and of history: the Three Weeks hide great good, and a broken person is great in sod. Comparing the generation to night swimmers who need a buddy, he urges mutual strengthening without envy, and stresses tefilah, which the Arizal said is the main pillar before Moshiach.
Topics: Hashem's Love for Klal Yisroel · Yisroel and the Nations
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why the goral is repeated in Masei listed in the guide
The Rav reads the verses commanding the Jews to drive out the inhabitants of the land and to divide it by goral. He asks why the goral is repeated after Pinchas, and why it is placed between the two verses about driving out the nations.
-
4:38 Anu goralecha: a bond beyond reason listed in the guide
Noting that Tammuz opens the last quarter of the year, the Rav turns to 'we are Your goral and You are our goral' from Yom Kippur. A goral, unlike a purchase, shows a bond beyond reason, as with Purim and the goats of Yom Kippur; he adds that an inheritance cannot be cut off, and that yerushah and horashah share one root.
-
12:00 The nations' angels and their clothing listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the seventy nations each stand under a heavenly minister, and that a designer's new style reflects how his nation's angel is dressed. This is why the prohibition of dressing like the nations is in the laws of avodah zarah; he brings a story about the minister of Hungary wearing red, and the Shach on Esav's red garments.
-
18:04 Hashem's lot must not bow to the nations listed in the guide
Since a Jew is Hashem's goral, the Rav says, he must not submit to the lots of the nations, each tied to its own land, language and avodah zarah; Eretz Yisroel is Hashem's land given by goral. He applies this to clothing worn for sports and brings the Gemara of an Amora who tore an immodest garment.
-
23:29 Kol anos: a Jew's joy is different listed in the guide
From Moshe's words 'kol anos anochi shome'a' the Rav explains that wild shouting is the voice of avodah zarah, and that a Jew eats, sleeps, lives and rejoices differently from a gentile. He returns to the verses: because the land is Hashem's lot, the Jews must have no bond with the nations.
-
30:33 The Arizal and the hidden side of things listed in the guide
The Rav says the Arizal's explanations often overturn the plain reading, as when he makes Korach a tzaddik, because his soul was rooted in the sod of the Torah. Just as Torah is full of secrets, so are the events of the world and of every Jew's day, as the Modim prayer speaks of daily hidden miracles.
-
35:22 The hidden good of the Three Weeks listed in the guide
The Rav explains that under the din of the Three Weeks and the Nine Days great things happen in sod, and likewise a broken person who feels he is failing is great in sod. He speaks of the avodah of trust when nothing goes, notes that the Arizal passed away in the Nine Days, and urges using these days to toil despite their difficulty.
-
42:41 Night swimming and the need for a buddy
The Rav describes night swimming where each swimmer must have a buddy, and asks why Dovid HaMelech in Tehillim cries out alone in deep waters. He answers that Dovid was a stranger to his people, and that a tzaddik passes trials so his followers need not; in the deep waters before Moshiach, as Malachi says of the yirei Hashem, one must join others and strengthen each other.
-
49:19 Without envy, and davening together
The Rav adds 'nosnim reshus zeh lazeh': friends must not begrudge each other's success, and he brings the Eretz Tzvi on Kamtza and Bar Kamtza, that a son reveals his father's inner self. He then laments that people come late to davening here and urges that all begin and say the tefilah together, like many lights forming one torch.
-
53:29 Tefilah as the pillar before Moshiach
The Rav brings the Arizal, cited in the Tanya from Rav Chaim Vital, that before Moshiach the world stands chiefly on tefilah, reading 'panah el tefilas ha'ar'ar' as written for the last generation. Bochurim must still give their full strength to Torah, but at davening each must add his share; he closes by honoring the Arizal and praying that the secrets of Torah and of the Three Weeks be revealed.
The shiur, written up
Why the goral is repeated in Masei
The Rav reads the verses commanding the Jews to drive out the inhabitants of the land and to inherit it by goral (Bamidbar 33:53-54), followed by the warning that those left behind will become thorns in their eyes (Bamidbar 33:55). He asks why the goral is repeated, since Parshas Pinchas already states it (Bamidbar 26:55), and why it stands between two verses about driving out the nations. The placement, he says, shows that the goral is connected to driving them out. a,b,c
Anu goralecha: a bond beyond reason
Tammuz, the Rav notes, begins the last quarter of the year, a time for a reckoning. On Yom Kippur one says 'we are Your goral and You are our goral' (Ki Anu Amecha). A purchase has a reason; a goral shows a bond from Above that reason cannot explain. The salvation of Purim came because Jews are Hashem's lot, and the Tikkunei Zohar likens Purim to Yom Kippur, whose atonement comes through the lots of the two goats (Vayikra 16:8). d,e,f
So one says 'Ashreinu, how pleasant is our goral, how beautiful our inheritance.' An inheritance comes to a son because he is his father's child, and it cannot be cut off. 'Yerushah' also means driving out, as 'saklu me'even' (Yeshayahu 62:10) means clearing stones. No Jew, the Rav says, can tear himself away from Hashem, and Jews must act accordingly. g,j
The nations' angels and their clothing
The seventy nations, the Rav explains, each stand under a heavenly minister, with their own language and ways. Dressing like the nations is therefore forbidden in the laws of avodah zarah (Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh De'ah 178), for as the Gemara says (Megillah 3a), a person's mazal sees what he does not. A designer creates a new style because his angel above dresses that way, and one who adopts it subjugates himself to that avodah zarah. k,l
Hashem's lot must not bow to the nations
Kol anos: a Jew's joy is different
Even ball must be played as a Jew. When Yehoshua heard a noise in the camp and took it for war, Moshe said it was 'kol anos' (Shemos 32:17-18): from the sound alone he knew it was the shouting of avodah zarah, not of davening or learning. The frenzied shouting over a ball, the Rav says, is that voice. p
Jews need another kind of joy, as the navi says 'al tismach Yisrael el gil ka'amim' (Hoshea 9:1). A Jew eats, sleeps, lives and dies differently from a gentile, and his clothing brings him holiness. q
Returning to the verses, the Rav concludes: because the land is Klal Yisroel's by goral, the Torah follows with the command to have no connection with the nations.
The Arizal and the hidden side of things
The Arizal's explanations, the Rav says, often overturn the plain reading, as when he makes Korach a tzaddik from 'tzaddik katamar yifrach' (Tehillim 92:13). His soul belonged to the sod of the Torah. Every part of Torah is full of secrets to be revealed in Moshiach's time, and so is everything that happens in the world; the Modim prayer thanks Hashem for daily miracles one does not see. r,s
The hidden good of the Three Weeks
So too with times. The sefarim, especially the Ba'al Shem Tov's students, say that in the Three Weeks and the Nine Days very great things happen, covered by a coldness of din. This is 'sod Hashem lirei'av' (Tehillim 25:14), not revealed to everyone. t
So too in the soul: some succeed in Torah and yiras Shamayim, while others are broken and keep falling. Such a person, the Rav says, is very great in sod, and in time it will be revealed that his present hiding was for his good. When nothing goes, his avodah is to trust that all Hashem does is good.
The Arizal passed away in the Nine Days because he was the soul of sod. Knowing this, one can use these days to toil, though learning and davening are harder then.
Night swimming and the need for a buddy
The Rav describes night swimming at a pool where the lifeguards insist that everyone swim with a buddy, since deep water at night is dangerous. Why, he asks, does Dovid HaMelech cry out alone in deep waters (Tehillim 69:2-4)? People did not love him; though one whom people are pleased with is pleasing to Hashem (Avos 3:10), those who are not upright hate the upright, and Dovid calls himself a stranger to his brothers (Tehillim 69:9-10). u,v,w
Rav Tzadok writes in Tzidkas HaTzaddik that a Rebbe passes trials so his students need not. Dovid swam alone, but in today's deep waters before Moshiach one needs a buddy. Malachi foretold that even when the wicked prosper, the yirei Hashem will speak to one another (Malachi 3:15-16); joined with them, one gains yiras Shamayim and success in Torah and tefilah. x,y
Without envy, and davening together
A further point is 'nosnim reshus zeh lazeh': friends must not begrudge each other. The Rav brings the Eretz Tzvi on Kamtza and Bar Kamtza (Gittin 55b): a son is his father's inner self, so Bar Kamtza showed that Kamtza was a friend only outwardly. One must be glad when another serves Hashem with success. aa,ab,ac
He laments that people come late to davening here, and urges that all begin together, like many lights forming one torch.
Tefilah as the pillar before Moshiach
The Rav brings the Tanya citing the Arizal through Rav Chaim Vital: the world stands on three things (Avos 1:2), and though Talmud Torah outweighs them all (Peah 1:1), before Moshiach the world stands mainly on tefilah. As in a person's youth Torah is primary, so in the world's youth. He reads 'panah el tefilas ha'ar'ar', written for the last generation (Tehillim 102:18-19), as referring to this. ae,af,ag,ah
Bochurim must still give all their strength to Torah, but at davening each must add his share and come on time so all can begin together. This, the Rav says, is what can be taken from the Arizal's teaching; he closes by honoring the Arizal, believing that the Torah holds secrets, and praying that the secrets of the Three Weeks be revealed with Hashem's glory.
Sources
Torah
- a Bamidbar 33:53-54 text index In the write-up: 0:24
- b Bamidbar 33:55 text index In the write-up: 0:24
- c Bamidbar 26:55 text index In the write-up: 0:24
- f Vayikra 16:8 text index In the write-up: 5:09
- i apparently Devarim 33:4 10:10 index
- n apparently Bereishis 10 index In the write-up: 18:04
- p Shemos 32:17-18 text index In the write-up: 23:35
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
- h apparently Eichah 3:24 9:07 index
- r apparently Tehillim 92:13 index In the write-up: 31:17
- t Tehillim 25:14 text index In the write-up: 35:52
- u Tehillim 69:2-4 text index In the write-up: 43:12
- w apparently Tehillim 69:9-10 index In the write-up: 43:12
- ah Tehillim 102:18-19 text index In the write-up: 53:38
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Acharonim and Chassidus
- k apparently Shulchan Aruch, Yoreh De'ah 178 index In the write-up: 12:53
- m apparently Shach, Yoreh De'ah 178 index In the write-up: 16:28
- x Tzidkas HaTzaddik (place not identified) index In the write-up: 46:23
- ad Tanya (place not identified) 53:07 index
- ae Tanya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 53:38
Tefillah and Piyut
- d apparently Ki Anu Amecha (Yom Kippur prayers) index In the write-up: 5:09
- g apparently Shacharis, Ashreinu mah tov chelkeinu index In the write-up: 8:59
- s apparently Shemoneh Esrei, Modim index In the write-up: 31:17
- aa apparently Shacharis, blessings before Shema (Kedushah of Yotzer) index In the write-up: 49:21
Other
Key points
- 5:56 A goral shows a connection that cannot be explained by reason; Klal Yisroel is Hashem's goral and He is theirs.
- 4:02 Eretz Yisroel belongs to the Jews by goral, so those bound to it cannot keep company with the nations; hence the goral is placed between the verses about driving them out.
- 12:53 Each nation draws its ways, language and dress from its heavenly minister, so dressing like the nations belongs to the laws of avodah zarah.
- 24:58 A Jew eats, sleeps, plays and rejoices differently from a gentile; the wild shouting of the stadium is the 'kol anos' of avodah zarah.
- 31:58 Through the Arizal's teaching one learns that behind the plain sense of Torah and of events lies sod; the Three Weeks hide great good, and a struggling Jew is great in sod.
- 46:53 In the deep waters of the generation before Moshiach one needs a 'buddy': friends who strengthen each other without envy.
- 54:07 The Arizal taught that before Moshiach the world stands chiefly on tefilah, so one should come on time and daven together with the tzibbur.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:32 Why does Masei repeat the division of the land by goral, already stated in Pinchas, between the verses about driving out the nations?
Answer: 29:33 Because the land is the Jews' by Hashem's goral, which shows a bond with Him; one bound to that lot cannot keep company with the nations.
-
Question: 44:44 Why does Dovid HaMelech cry out alone in deep waters, without a buddy?
Answer: 44:53 He was a stranger to his own brothers; and a tzaddik passes such trials so that later generations need not swim alone.
-
Question: 50:01 Why should Jerusalem be destroyed because of Kamtza, the friend?
Answer: 50:08 A son reveals his father's inner self; Bar Kamtza's hatred showed Kamtza was a friend only outwardly.
Stories
-
16:20 The heavenly minister of Hungary in red
In connection with the Bnei Yissaschar, who was then in Munkatch in Hungary, the Rav tells of a tzaddik (heard as Reb Hershele) who said he knew the heavenly minister of Hungary, though he did not live there. He gave a sign: that minister wears red trousers. The Rav uses this to show that a nation's dress follows the dress of its angel above.
In the story: the Bnei Yissaschar
Insights
- 3:52 The Rav reads the placement of the goral verse between the two commands to drive out the nations as a statement that a land held by Hashem's lot cannot be shared with the nations.
- 10:19 He shows from the dual meaning of the root (yerushah, to inherit; horashah, to drive out), like 'saklu me'even', that the inheritance bond is one that cannot be cut off.
- 15:39 A fashion designer creates a new style because his nation's angel above dresses that way, which is why the laws of dress are part of the laws of avodah zarah.
- 23:46 Moshe recognized from the very sound of the shouting at the egel that it was avodah zarah, not war; the Rav applies this to the frenzied shouting of ball games.
- 40:45 The Arizal, the soul of sod, passed away in the Nine Days, because these days, like his teaching, hold a hidden good whose time to be revealed has not yet come.
- 44:44 Dovid HaMelech swam alone in deep waters, and a tzaddik passes trials so that his followers need not; in our generation one must have a 'buddy'.
- 50:08 Citing the Eretz Tzvi, he explains that Jerusalem fell over Kamtza because a son reveals his father's inner self: Kamtza's son's hatred showed Kamtza was a friend only outwardly.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 20:48 The Rav says a Jew must dress as the Shulchan Aruch describes and not in the styles of the nations, even for sports.
- 23:18 He says that even when playing ball or exercising, one must do it as a Jew, without the gentile frenzy.
- 47:32 He urges joining with yirei Hashem and strengthening one another, and being glad of a friend's success in Torah and avodah rather than envying it.
- 52:14 He asks that people make the effort to come on time in the morning so that all can begin davening together.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Bar Kamtza, Dovid HaMelech, Esav, Kamtza, Korach, Malachi, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Chaim Vital, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Kozhiglover Rav, Yehoshua bin Nun
Terms גורל, ירושה, מדת הדין, עבודה זרה, עקבתא דמשיחא, רבונו של עולם