ביאור על מחלוקת אברם עם לוט; גנות עמי הארץ שמחרחרי ריב בין הצדיקים
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע לך לך no. 6 Pocket Guide p. 4 תש"נ (1989–90) Yiddish 45 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains the quarrel between Avraham's and Lot's shepherds through the story of Bar Kamtza: a small dispute among great people becomes a destructive machlokes when the ignorant turn it into politics.
The Rav opens with the pasuk that there was a 'riv' between the shepherds of Avraham and Lot, while Avraham asks that there be no 'merivah', and asks what each word means. He turns to the Gemara's story of Kamtza and Bar Kamtza and asks why the Chachamim heeded Rabbi Zechariah ben Avkulas. He explains Rabbi Zechariah's fear of spreading a false halachah, bringing the Yam Shel Shlomo, and shows that the dispute was only over assessing the situation. Citing a letter of the Chasam Sofer, he decries machlokes that ignorant people drag into politics, unlike healthy disputes between talmidei chachamim. The Chachamim yielded to avoid a political split. So too, Lot's shepherds wanted to join the warring sides, turning a small 'merivah' into a 'riv'. Finally, from the Chasam Sofer and a Midrash on Tidal, he contrasts Avraham's tactics and warns that today's galus bites with a kiss.
Topics: Bein Adam LaChaveiro · The Beis HaMikdash and Its Churban · Avraham Avinu
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Riv and merivah; the story of Bar Kamtza listed in the guide
The Rav reads the pesukim about the quarrel between the shepherds of Avraham and Lot and asks what 'riv' and 'merivah' mean. He then tells the Gemara's story of Kamtza and Bar Kamtza and asks why the Chachamim had to heed Rabbi Zechariah ben Avkulas.
-
6:02 Why Rabbi Zechariah would not allow the offering
The Rav explains that a Roman ruler would never accept a tiny blemish as a reason, so the Chachamim saw it as pikuach nefesh. He brings the Gemara in Bava Kamma and the Yam Shel Shlomo that one must give one's life rather than falsify a halachah, and explains that Rabbi Zechariah feared a false halachah would spread; the Chachamim disagreed only in assessing that danger.
-
13:30 The Chasam Sofer's letter: two kinds of machlokes listed in the guide
The Rav brings a letter of the Chasam Sofer that a machlokes in an earlier generation, with disgrace of talmidei chachamim, held back Moshiach, and that true bnei Torah should stay silent and learn. He distinguishes a healthy machlokes in halachah from one with political undercurrents that everyone discusses, and explains that great poskim rule from daas Torah, which outsiders cannot judge.
-
20:23 Peace party and war party at the Churban listed in the guide
The Rav explains that at the time of the Churban there were two factions: the Chachamim under Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai, who wanted peace with Rome, and the biryonim under Abba Sikra, who wanted war. The question of the Caesar's offering became a political platform, so the Chachamim stayed passive and followed Rabbi Zechariah to avoid a split in Klal Yisrael.
-
25:28 Lot's shepherds and the war over the land listed in the guide
The Rav applies this to Avraham and Lot: Lot's shepherds wanted to join the winning side in the war between the Canaanites and Perizzites and the descendants of Shem. He explains that 'merivah' is feminine and weak, a small dispute over whether the promise of the land already took effect, while 'riv' is masculine, the shepherds' political quarrel, and so Avraham asked Lot to separate.
-
30:47 Why Avraham stopped fighting in Eretz Yisrael
The Rav brings the Chasam Sofer: in Ur Kasdim Avraham was a zealous fighter who broke the idols and was thrown into the fire, but in Eretz Yisrael he lived in peace with his neighbors. Alone in Ur, he could not raise students and gave his life; with 'Lech lecha' he was promised a great following, so he was no longer permitted to risk his life.
-
35:05 The vav of Tidal and Esav's kiss
The Rav brings a Midrash that the vav in 'v'Sidal' among the four kings is part of the name. He connects it to Rashi on Esav's kiss: Esav wanted to bite Yaakov and, unable, kissed him. He then introduces the galus of Edom, the Roman Church that ruled Europe, the fourth of the four galuyos named in the zemiros and Maoz Tzur, which the Midrash links to the four kings.
-
40:08 Edom bites with a kiss
The Rav explains that Edom first bit the Jews with persecutions, the Crusades and the Inquisition, and when that failed it now bites with a kiss: friendship, interfaith meetings and assimilation. Tidal, 'king of nations', is the fourth kingdom of many peoples under one church, and the vav of joining is its way of tormenting Jews, so he says Jews must not fall into its web or take on its culture.
The shiur, written up
Riv and merivah; the story of Bar Kamtza
The Rav opens with the pasuk in Bereishis 13:7 that there was a 'riv', a quarrel, between the shepherds of Avraham and of Lot, while the Canaanites and Perizzites were in the land. Rashi explains that they were then at war, taking Eretz Yisrael from the descendants of Shem. Yet Avraham tells Lot (13:8) that there should be no 'merivah'. The Rav asks what each word means, and why the Torah tells of the quarrel at all. a,b,c
Why Rabbi Zechariah would not allow the offering
The Rav explains that a Roman ruler would never accept that so tiny a defect disqualifies an offering; he would take a refusal as rebellion. So the Chachamim held it was pikuach nefesh, which overrides offering a blemished animal. Why, then, did Rabbi Zechariah object?
He brings the Gemara in Bava Kamma 38a on a difference in law between a Jew and a gentile, and the Yam Shel Shlomo there: for pikuach nefesh one transgresses a sin, but to state a false halachah one must give one's life. Rabbi Zechariah feared people would say, in the words of the Gemara in Gittin, that blemished animals may be offered, and a false halachah would spread. The Chachamim held no such mistake would arise; they differed only in assessing the situation, not in halachah. f,g,e
The Chasam Sofer's letter: two kinds of machlokes
The Rav brings a letter of the Chasam Sofer: in an earlier generation full of gedolim, among them the Pnei Yehoshua and Rabbi Yaakov Emden, Moshiach could have come, but a machlokes spread with disgrace of talmidei chachamim and held him back. True bnei Torah, the Rav says, should stay out, learn and daven and say nothing, as the pasuk in Amos says the wise keep silent at such a time. h,i
A machlokes in halachah, one forbidding and one permitting, is healthy and l'shem shamayim. But a machlokes with political undercurrents is discussed by everyone, even in the mikveh, by people who do not understand it. When the Rambam or the Rosh rules without a proof, the Rav explains, it comes from daas Torah, a mind gained by mastering all of Torah lishmah, which no outsider can judge. j
Peace party and war party at the Churban
Returning to the Churban, the Rav explains from the Gemara and from Josephus that there were two factions: the Chachamim under Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai, who wanted peace with Rome, and the biryonim under Abba Sikra, who wanted war. The question of the Caesar's offering was taken up by these factions as a political platform. l,k
So the Chachamim stayed passive. Rabbi Zechariah meant it l'shem shamayim, and a split in Klal Yisrael was worse than the sin. He should have kept quiet, the Rav says, but once he spoke they had to follow him, so the machlokes would not spread.
Lot's shepherds and the war over the land
The same was true in Avraham's time. Some fought for the Canaanites and Perizzites, others for the descendants of Shem. Lot's shepherds wanted to use the political climate and join the likely winner, to gain the land for their fields.
'Riv' is masculine and 'merivah' feminine, which denotes weakness, as the Gemara says 'his strength weakened like a woman's'. Between Avraham and Lot there was only a small halachic dispute, whether the promise of the land had already taken effect; among the shepherds it became a political quarrel. So Avraham asked Lot to separate, before their small merivah could grow. b
Why Avraham stopped fighting in Eretz Yisrael
The Rav brings the Chasam Sofer: in Ur Kasdim Avraham broke his father's idols and Nimrod threw him into the fire, yet in Eretz Yisrael he lived at peace with his neighbors. In Ur he stood alone and could raise no students. With 'Lech lecha' he was promised a great following, and had he been killed his students would be lost, so he no longer risked his life. m,n
The vav of Tidal and Esav's kiss
The Rav brings a Midrash that the vav of 'v'Sidal' among the four kings of Bereishis 14:1 is part of the name, since in the other pasuk only Tidal has a vav. He connects this to Rashi on Esav's kiss: Esav wanted to bite Yaakov, but Yaakov's neck turned to marble, so he kissed him instead. o,p,q
Edom bites with a kiss
Edom first tried to bite the Jews with persecutions, the Crusades and the Inquisition. When that failed, the Rav says, it changed tactics and now bites with a kiss: friendship, interfaith meetings, assimilation. This, he explains, is what the Midrash hints at: Tidal, 'king of nations', is many peoples under one church, and the vav of joining is its way of tormenting Jews. So he says Jews must not fall into this web, nor take on its culture, amusements or sports. o
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
Key points
- 27:51 A 'merivah' (feminine form) is a small, weak dispute, as between Avraham and Lot; a 'riv' (masculine) is a strong quarrel, as among the shepherds who tied it to the war over the land.
- 9:25 Rabbi Zechariah ben Avkulas refused to offer the Caesar's blemished sacrifice even for pikuach nefesh because people would conclude that blemished animals may be offered, and one must give one's life rather than falsify a halachah.
- 16:15 A machlokes between talmidei chachamim over halachah is healthy and l'shem shamayim, but a machlokes with political undercurrents, discussed by everyone in the street, is destructive.
- 22:48 The Chachamim yielded to Rabbi Zechariah because the question had been taken up by political factions, the peace party and the war party, and a split in Klal Yisrael was worse than the sin itself.
- 25:40 Lot's shepherds wanted to join one side of the war between the Canaanites and Perizzites and the descendants of Shem, so as to gain the land, and Avraham separated from Lot to keep their small dispute from growing.
- 40:45 Following the Midrash on Tidal and Esav's kiss, the Rav says that the galus of Edom, which once tried to bite the Jews, now bites with a kiss, by drawing them close, and he says Jews must not be drawn into its culture.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:42 What is the difference between 'riv' and 'merivah', and why does the Torah tell of the quarrel at all?
Answer: 27:51 'Merivah' is feminine and weak: between Avraham and Lot there was a small halachic dispute. 'Riv' is masculine: among the shepherds it became a strong political quarrel tied to the war over the land.
-
Question: 7:39 Why did Rabbi Zechariah ben Avkulas refuse to offer the Caesar's sacrifice despite the danger to life?
Answer: 9:25 He feared people would conclude that blemished animals may be offered, spreading a false halachah, and as the Yam Shel Shlomo writes, one must give one's life rather than falsify the Torah.
-
Question: 5:42 Why did the Chachamim, who held it was permitted, have to follow Rabbi Zechariah?
Answer: 23:16 Because the question had become a political issue between the peace party and the war party, and the machlokes that could result was worse than the sin, so they stayed passive.
-
Question: 31:45 Why was Avraham a militant fighter in Ur Kasdim but peaceful in Eretz Yisrael?
Answer: 32:45 In Ur he was alone and could not raise students, so he gave his life; in Eretz Yisrael he was promised many followers, and had he been killed his students would have been lost.
-
Question: 37:53 Why did Esav kiss Yaakov?
Answer: 38:10 He wanted to bite him and could not, so he 'bit' him with a kiss instead, and this is the tactic of the galus of Edom.
Stories
-
2:39 Kamtza, Bar Kamtza and the Caesar's offering
Following the Gemara, the Rav tells that Bar Kamtza went to the Roman Caesar and said that the Jews had rebelled and would not offer his sacrifice. The Caesar sent an offering, and Bar Kamtza made a small blemish on it, on the lip or the eye, which is a blemish for Jews but not for the gentiles. The Chachamim wanted to offer it, but Rabbi Zechariah ben Avkulas did not allow it, the Caesar made war on Yerushalayim, and Rabbi Yochanan says that his conduct destroyed the Beis HaMikdash.
In the story: Bar Kamtza, Rabbi Zechariah ben Avkulas, Rabbi Yochanan
-
30:55 Avraham the zealot in Ur Kasdim
The Rav recounts that in Ur Kasdim Avraham fought openly against idol worship, broke his father's idols and entered into a conflict with Nimrod. Nimrod wanted to kill him and threw him into the fire, and from there came the miracle of his emerging alive.
In the story: Avraham Avinu, Nimrod
Insights
- 27:51 The feminine 'merivah' in Avraham's words, against the masculine 'riv' of the narrative, shows that between Avraham and Lot there was only a weak, small dispute, while among the shepherds it became a forceful quarrel.
- 28:33 The Rav reads the dispute between Avraham and Lot as a halachic question: whether Hashem's promise of the land to Avraham had already taken effect or would only take effect later.
- 11:40 Rabbi Zechariah and the Chachamim did not disagree in halachah but in assessing the situation: whether offering a blemished animal would lead people to a false halachah.
- 32:45 Avraham's change from zealotry in Ur Kasdim to peace in Eretz Yisrael followed from his mission: once promised a following, he was no longer allowed to risk his life, because his students needed him.
- 43:21 The vav that the Midrash says belongs to Tidal's name is a 'vav of joining': the fourth kingdom torments the Jews by joining with them, as Esav bit Yaakov with a kiss.
- 42:24 Unlike the earlier kingdoms, each of which was one nation, the fourth kingdom, 'Tidal king of nations', is many peoples united under one church with one policy toward the Jews.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 15:34 The Rav says that in a machlokes among gedolim, true bnei Torah should not get involved or say a word, but learn and daven.
- 17:33 The Rav says that people who talk about a machlokes of gedolim should first ask themselves whether they understand what they are talking about.
- 43:50 The Rav says Jews today must not fall into the web of the nations' friendliness and must not take on their culture, amusements, way of life or sports.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Abba Sikra, Avraham Avinu, Bar Kamtza, Esav, Josephus, Lot, Nimrod, Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai, Rabbi Yaakov Emden (the Yaavetz), Rabbi Yochanan, Rabbi Zechariah ben Avkulas, Rashi, the Chasam Sofer, the Pnei Yehoshua, Yaakov Avinu
Terms אור כשדים, בעל מום, בריונים, גלות אדום, דעת תורה, ו' החיבור, מחלוקת, מסירות נפש, פיקוח נפש