שלימות של מצות סוכה - "למחסה ולמסתור מזרם וממטר"' אושפיזין של יעקב
Catalog entry: זמנים סוכות no. 2 Pocket Guide p. 17 תשמ"ו (1985–86) Yiddish 59 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that a sukkah in its perfection draws down the protection of the Clouds of Glory so that rain cannot enter it, and then presents Yaakov Avinu, the night's guest, as the one who grew greater in the impurity of Lavan's house.
The Rav opens with the Midrash that Avraham's hospitality was repaid with the Clouds of Glory and the sukkah, 'a shelter from storm and rain'. He asks why sukkah, unlike most mitzvos, must be comfortable, so that one who suffers is exempt, and answers that mitzvos bound up with physical life, like settling Eretz Yisrael, require pleasure. Tzaddikim who ate in the sukkah in the rain were simply not suffering, surrounded by its holiness. Avraham sitting in the heat suffered only from lacking guests. The Rav then works through Tosafos, who require that a sukkah be able to let rain in, and the Ba'al Shem Tov's sukkah where it did not rain: a perfect sukkah carries the Clouds of Glory, as Rabbi Zeira reads the pasuk. After a niggun he turns to Yaakov, the night's guest: the angels banished after Sodom found their repair by escorting Yaakov, who did not falter at Lavan's, and the Rav urges taking him into the heart.
Topics: Sukkos · Yaakov, Lavan and the Imahos
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Sukkah: shelter from storm and rain listed in the guide
The Rav opens with the Midrash that Avraham's hospitality to the angels was repaid with the Clouds of Glory and the sukkah, 'a shelter from storm and rain'. He notes that one who suffers is exempt from sukkah, and brings Rabbi Ami and Rabbi Assi who moved between sun and shade so that Eretz Yisrael would be pleasant, something not found by other mitzvos.
-
4:08 Mitzvos of physical life need pleasure listed in the guide
The Rav explains that only mitzvos bound up with physical life, such as eating with appetite on Erev Pesach or settling Eretz Yisrael, require comfort, and sukkah is one of them. Tzaddikim who ate in the sukkah in the rain were not suffering, since they felt the holiness surrounding them; one who does not feel it should not imitate them.
-
8:48 Avraham in the heat; the Ba'al Shem Tov's sukkah listed in the guide
Avraham, who had the mitzvos of Eretz Yisrael and milah, sat at his tent in the heat of the day, though he should have been as careful about comfort as Rabbi Ami and Rabbi Assi. The Rav explains that his comfort was only Hashem's will, so he suffered only from lacking guests, and Hashem sent him guests. He then tells of the Ba'al Shem Tov's sukkah where it did not rain, and of Reb Yitzchak of Drohobitch who came to eat there.
-
14:41 Tosafos: a sukkah must let rain in listed in the guide
The Rav brings Tosafos, who prove from rain on Sukkos being a bad sign that a sukkah must be able to let rain in, and explains it according to Rabbi Zeira, who requires sitting in the sukkah's shade. He calls this reading forced, and with a mashal of a fine tablecloth with a bulge shows that under every forced reading of Tosafos lies something hidden. He asks whether the Ba'al Shem Tov's rainless sukkah was then still valid.
-
20:11 Sukkah, bitachon and the Clouds of Glory listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Hashem made the sukkah so that a Jew sitting in it depends on Him for the rain, which is the bitachon in the sukkah, and asks why the Ba'al Shem Tov would need a miracle. He answers with the Clouds of Glory, which the Shulchan Aruch says one must have in mind: they shielded the Jews in the desert from the climate, and a Jew sitting in the sukkah with joy draws down some of their light according to his level.
-
25:15 The perfect sukkah keeps out the rain listed in the guide
Through the Gemara's dispute, where the Chachamim apply 'a shelter from storm and rain' to the days of Moshiach and Rabbi Zeira applies it to the sukkah too, the Rav explains that a sukkah in perfection shields from rain; we are not worthy of it, but the Ba'al Shem Tov was, without a miracle. Returning to the Midrash, he shows that Avraham's three rewards are one: Avraham himself was not suffering, but he assumed his guests were and told them to rest under the tree.
-
32:08 Niggun (Singing)
-
35:23 Yaakov Avinu, the night's guest listed in the guide
The Rav introduces the ushpizin, the seven guests who come into every Jewish sukkah, and says that Yaakov Avinu is that night's guest, whose greatness cannot be described. He brings the pasuk 'Yaakov sent angels' and Rashi that the angels of Eretz Yisrael escorted him to its border and others met him outside it.
-
40:04 The angels of Sodom and their return listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Midrash, Targum Yonasan and Da'as Zekeinim that the ascending angels of Yaakov's dream were the angels sent to Sodom, expelled from Heaven for saying 'we are destroying', and asks why they were readmitted now. He prepares two introductions: from the Haggadah's 'I and not an angel', that impurity like Egypt's can damage even an angel, which is what happened at Sodom; and that one who escorts another, or helps him do a mitzvah, shares in it.
-
47:40 Yaakov at Lavan: the angels' repair listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Yaakov went to Lavan, the source of impurity, and needed protection; the angels who escorted him fulfilled the mitzvah of escorting and gained a share in him. Unlike the angels, who grew worse in Sodom, Yaakov grew greater at Lavan, and this was their repair. On his return they met him in gratitude, and he sent them to Esav as witnesses that he lived with Lavan and kept the mitzvos.
-
53:30 Taking Yaakov into the heart listed in the guide
The Rav says Yaakov's strength came from fourteen sleepless years of toil in the yeshivah of Shem and Ever. He asks how one honors such a guest, not with cake or fish, and answers that the ushpizin must be taken into the heart: to learn from Yaakov toil in Torah and self-sacrifice for truth, and to contemplate how each guest served Hashem, leaving Sukkos with a lasting treasure.
The shiur, written up
Sukkah: shelter from storm and rain
Mitzvos of physical life need pleasure
The Rav explains that comfort matters only in mitzvos bound up with physical life. Eating on the night of Pesach must be with appetite, since eating is a physical act done with desire. Settling Eretz Yisrael, a positive mitzvah according to the Ramban, must likewise be pleasant, and one who suffers there is not fulfilling it.
Avraham in the heat; the Ba'al Shem Tov's sukkah
Avraham had only two mitzvos, going to Eretz Yisrael and milah, which belong together: the Midrash says one cannot enter the land uncircumcised, and Yehoshua circumcised the people before they crossed. Now, on the third day after his milah, Avraham felt Eretz Yisrael more than before, and should have sought comfort like Rabbi Ami and Rabbi Assi. Yet he sat at his tent in the heat of the day. k,m,l,i,f
The Rav explains that his comfort came only through doing Hashem's will, so the heat did not trouble him; lacking guests did. Rashi says Hashem brought out the sun so as not to trouble him with guests, but in truth Hashem saw that the lack of guests was his suffering, and sent him guests. j
He then tells how it did not rain in the Ba'al Shem Tov's sukkah. Reb Yitzchak of Drohobitch, though in dispute with him, heard of it on a rainy night, took his challah and plate and went to eat in the Ba'al Shem Tov's sukkah for the sake of the mitzvah.
Tosafos: a sukkah must let rain in
Tosafos prove from rain on Sukkos being a bad sign that a sukkah must be able to let rain in; if rain could not enter, what sign would it be? The Rav explains this according to Rabbi Zeira, who disqualifies a sukkah above twenty amos because one must sit in the shade of the s'chach, not of the walls. o,p,q
He calls the reading forced, and gives a mashal: a fine tablecloth with a bulge is not a craftsman's mistake; someone hid an ornament beneath it, and one must lift it and look. Under every forced reading of Tosafos lies something. He then asks whether the Ba'al Shem Tov's rainless sukkah was still a proper sukkah, and suggests the miracle may have been in the rain, not the s'chach. o
Sukkah, bitachon and the Clouds of Glory
Hashem made the sukkah so that a Jew sitting in it must turn to Him that it should not rain; this is the bitachon of the sukkah. A sukkah where one is sure it will not rain, and can make a miracle, would seem to miss that intent, and the Rav asks why the Ba'al Shem Tov did not simply let it rain or not.
He answers with the Clouds of Glory, which the Shulchan Aruch says one must have in mind. They shielded the Jews for forty years from the desert's sun and climate. A Jew who sits in the sukkah with joy, knowing he is in the shadow of the Shechinah, merits some of their light, each according to his level. r,d
The perfect sukkah keeps out the rain
Since no rain or sun entered the Clouds of Glory, a true sukkah should not let rain in either, but that was a miracle, and we cannot rely on miracles. The Gemara records that the Chachamim apply 'a shelter from storm and rain' to the days of Moshiach, while Rabbi Zeira applies the verse to the sukkah as well. b,q
According to Rabbi Zeira, a sukkah sat in properly would protect from storm and rain; we are not worthy of drawing so much from the Clouds of Glory. The Ba'al Shem Tov and Reb Yitzchak were, so their dry sukkah was no miracle but the mitzvah in its perfection.
Returning to the Midrash, the Rav says the three rewards are one. Avraham was not suffering, but he assumed his guests were, so he told them to rest under the tree. The verses of the Midrash describe levels: the cloud in the desert, the sukkah each according to his level, and full protection in the days of Moshiach. a,s
Yaakov Avinu, the night's guest
The Rav turns to the ushpizin, the seven guests who come into every Jewish sukkah, and says that Yaakov Avinu is that night's guest, whose greatness cannot be described. He brings the verse that Yaakov sent angels to Esav, and Rashi that the angels of Eretz Yisrael escorted him to its border while others met him outside it. t,u
The angels of Sodom and their return
On 'angels of G-d ascending and descending', Chazal say these were the angels who escorted Yaakov. The Midrash, Targum Yonasan and Da'as Zekeinim explain that they were the angels sent to Sodom, Gavriel and Refael, who said 'we are destroying this place' as if on their own, and were not let back into Heaven for many years. Now, escorting Yaakov, they ascend. The Rav asks why they were forgiven now. v,w,x,y,z
He gives a first introduction from the Haggadah's 'I and not an angel': the early sources say Egypt's impurity was so great that an angel sent there would have been damaged. So too Sodom's impurity damaged even these great angels, and they forgot their mission. aa
Two more principles follow. The commentators say the escort's merit protects the one escorted. And a sefer cites that one who helps another fulfill a mitzvah he cannot do himself, such as pidyon haben, is counted as having done it.
Yaakov at Lavan: the angels' repair
Yaakov was going to Lavan, the source of impurity; the Midrash says Esav did not chase him, sure that Lavan would finish him. Escorting Yaakov, the angels fulfilled the mitzvah of escorting, protected him and gained a share in his mitzvos. ab
Yaakov was the opposite of the angels: they grew worse in Sodom, while he came to the most impure place and only grew greater. Sharing in him was their repair, and they were readmitted to Heaven. Twenty-two years later they met him again in gratitude, and he sent them to Esav: they were the witnesses that he lived with Lavan and kept the mitzvos, since their own repair came through it. ac
Taking Yaakov into the heart
Yaakov's strength, the Rav says, came from fourteen years in the yeshivah of Shem and Ever, toiling in Torah without sleep. He asks how one honors such a guest: with cake, meat or fish? Rather, the ushpizin must be invited into the heart and soul, and one must ask, as Chazal say, when one's deeds will reach those of the Avos. ad,ae
From Yaakov one learns to toil in Torah and to give oneself for the truth; so one is not damaged even in impure times. One must contemplate how each guest served Hashem, and leave Sukkos with a lasting treasure.
Sources
Torah
- d Vayikra 23:42-43 text index In the write-up: 22:47
- i Bereishis 18:1 text index In the write-up: 9:07
- k Bereishis 12:1 text index In the write-up: 9:07
- n apparently Bereishis 17:8 9:54 index
- s Bereishis 18:4 text index In the write-up: 0:00, 29:29
- t Bereishis 32:4 text index In the write-up: 35:33
- v Bereishis 28:12 text index In the write-up: 40:15
- w Bereishis 19:13 text index In the write-up: 40:15
- ac Bereishis 32:5 text index In the write-up: 48:55
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Targum
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
- a apparently Bereishis Rabbah 48:10 index In the write-up: 0:00, 29:29
- m Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 9:07
- x Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 40:15
- ab Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 47:43
- ae Tanna Devei Eliyahu (place not identified) index In the write-up: 53:34
Rishonim
- g apparently Rashi on Kesubos 112b index In the write-up: 1:34
- j apparently Rashi on Bereishis 18:1 index In the write-up: 12:01
- o Tosafos (place not identified) index In the write-up: 15:11, 17:36
- u apparently Rashi on Bereishis 32:2 index In the write-up: 35:33
- z apparently Da'as Zekeinim on Bereishis 28:12 index In the write-up: 40:15
- ad apparently Rashi on Bereishis 28:11 index In the write-up: 53:34
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 3:54 Sukkah, like other mitzvos tied to physical life such as settling Eretz Yisrael or eating with appetite, must be done with comfort, which is why one who suffers is exempt.
- 6:26 Tzaddikim who ate in the sukkah in pouring rain did not dispute the halachah; surrounded by the sukkah's holiness they felt pleasure and were not suffering at all.
- 12:01 Avraham Avinu sitting in the heat was not suffering from the heat, since his comfort came only through Hashem's will; he suffered from lacking guests, so Hashem sent him guests.
- 24:58 A sukkah kept in its perfection carries some of the light of the Clouds of Glory, and then rain does not enter it; this was the Ba'al Shem Tov's sukkah, not a miracle.
- 48:31 The angels expelled for saying 'we are destroying' at Sodom were readmitted to Heaven through escorting Yaakov, who entered the impurity of Lavan's place and grew greater rather than worse.
- 55:33 Hosting Yaakov as ushpiz means taking him into one's heart and learning from him toil in Torah and self-sacrifice for truth.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 3:32 Why must the mitzvah of sukkah be comfortable, so that one who suffers is exempt, when comfort is not a condition of other mitzvos?
Answer: 4:26 Mitzvos bound up with physical life, like eating with appetite or settling Eretz Yisrael, are only fulfilled with pleasure, and dwelling in the sukkah is such a mitzvah.
-
Question: 6:26 How could tzaddikim eat in the sukkah in pouring rain, when one who suffers is exempt?
Answer: 6:54 They were not suffering: surrounded by the holiness of the sukkah they felt pleasure, and leaving would only have pained them more.
-
Question: 11:08 Why did Avraham, who had the mitzvah of Eretz Yisrael, sit in the heat instead of seeking comfort like Rabbi Ami and Rabbi Assi?
Answer: 12:01 His comfort lay only in doing Hashem's will, so the heat did not trouble him; only the lack of guests did, and Hashem sent him guests.
-
Question: 19:07 If, as Tosafos say, a sukkah must be able to let rain in, was the Ba'al Shem Tov's sukkah where it did not rain still a proper sukkah?
Answer: 27:56 It was no miracle but the mitzvah of sukkah in its perfection, which carries the protection of the Clouds of Glory, as Rabbi Zeira reads 'a shelter from storm and rain'.
-
Question: 42:07 How could angels as great as Gavriel and Refael forget their mission and say 'we are destroying' at Sodom?
Answer: 45:14 Sodom's impurity was so great that, as an angel would have been damaged in Egypt, even these great angels were damaged there.
-
Question: 43:20 Why were the angels readmitted to Heaven precisely when they escorted Yaakov to Charan?
Answer: 48:31 By escorting him they shared in Yaakov, who entered the impurity of Lavan's place and grew greater, the opposite of their fall in Sodom, and this was their repair.
Stories
-
13:22 The Ba'al Shem Tov's dry sukkah
The Rav relates, from reliable seforim of tzaddikim, that when the Ba'al Shem Tov sat in his sukkah and it rained, it did not rain in his sukkah. Reb Yitzchak of Drohobitch had a dispute with him; once, when it rained hard on Sukkos, a man told him that by the Ba'al Shem Tov it was not raining. He took his challah and his plate, went over to the Ba'al Shem Tov's sukkah, made a blessing on the sukkah and ate there, despite their dispute, for the sake of the mitzvah.
In the story: the Baal Shem Tov, Reb Yitzchak of Drohobitch
Insights
- 4:23 Comfort as a condition of a mitzvah appears only where the mitzvah is itself a physical act made holy, like eating, dwelling in Eretz Yisrael or dwelling in the sukkah; there suffering means the mitzvah is not being done at all.
- 6:45 The tzaddikim who stayed in the sukkah in the rain did not override the exemption of one who suffers; leaving would have made them suffer more, so for them the halachah itself required staying.
- 12:27 Rashi's 'so as not to trouble him with guests' is turned around: Hashem saw that the heat did not trouble Avraham at all, but the lack of guests did, so He sent guests.
- 27:16 Rabbi Zeira reads 'a shelter from storm and rain' as the sukkah's own nature: a sukkah kept in perfection, like the Clouds of Glory, keeps out the rain, so the Ba'al Shem Tov's dry sukkah was the mitzvah in its completeness, not a miracle.
- 17:54 Under every forced reading of Tosafos lies something hidden, like a bulge under a fine tablecloth that hides an ornament rather than a craftsman's mistake.
- 45:35 The angels were damaged by Sodom's impurity just as an angel would have been by Egypt's; their repair had to come through Yaakov, who did the opposite and grew greater in the place of greatest impurity.
- 52:13 The angels were the fitting messengers to Esav because they were the living witnesses that Yaakov had not been damaged at Lavan's, since their own repair depended on it.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 8:24 The Rav says one who does not feel the sukkah's holiness should not imitate the tzaddikim who sat in it in the rain.
- 55:33 The Rav says the ushpizin must be invited not only into the sukkah but into the heart and soul.
- 56:47 From Yaakov, he says, one should learn to toil in Torah and to give oneself for the truth.
- 57:39 The Rav says one should contemplate who each of the ushpizin was and how, with which trait, he served Hashem.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Esav, Ever, Lavan, Lot, Rabbi Ami, Rabbi Assi, Rabbi Yitzchak of Drohobitch, Rabbi Zeira, Rashi, Shem, the angel Gavriel, the angel Michael, the angel Refael, the Baal Shem Tov, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu
Terms אושפיזין, ארץ ישראל, בטחון, הכנסת אורחים, טומאת מת, ישיבת שם ועבר, לויה, סוכה, ענני הכבוד