Lag Beomer
Catalog entry: זמנים ל"ג בעומר no. 11 Yiddish 1 hr 7 min
Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the folder and file name.
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that the golden dinars with which Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai filled the valley of Meron were the secrets of his Torah, given material form, and that every Jew may rejoice on his hillula even without grasping him.
The Rav opens with the Arizal's words that it is a mitzvah to rejoice in the simcha of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, who asked that people rejoice on his hillula. Rashbi was not grasped even by his colleagues, which is why the halacha follows Rabbi Yehuda; in the future, when the world is filled with knowledge of Hashem, it will follow Rabbi Shimon. Yet even the lowest Jew has a place at his simcha. The Rav then tells of Rashbi's miracles, above all the valley he filled with golden dinars, and asks why the Midrash calls the taking back of Rabbi Shimon ben Chalafta's gift a greater miracle but says nothing of the kind about Rashbi. He answers that the gold was Rashbi's own Torah secrets spread over Meron, which took material form because the students showed interest in wealth; it was no gift from heaven, and when they held back it returned to Torah. He closes with blessings that Rashbi's merit bring the redemption, and with the niggun the Satmar Rav learned in Meron.
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Untranscribed opening (Unclear audio)
-
11:05 Rejoicing with Rashbi without grasping him listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Arizal that it is a mitzvah to rejoice in Rashbi's simcha, explains that even his colleagues could not grasp him, which is why the halacha follows Rabbi Yehuda until the future, and says that even the lowest Jew has a place at his simcha, illustrating it with a story at the Ruzhiner Rebbe's.
-
15:54 The valley of golden dinars and the question Story
The Rav recounts Rashbi's miracles: how he drove off an official who came with a decree, and how he filled a valley with golden dinars for a student who had grown rich abroad. He then brings the Midrash about Rabbi Shimon ben Chalafta, where the taking back of a heavenly gift is called the greater miracle, and asks why nothing like it is said of Rashbi's gold.
-
20:42 The gold was Rashbi's Torah secrets
The Rav offers his own answer: spiritually silver is love and gold is fear, and through the constrictions of this world they become metal. Rashbi's chiddushim lay spread over Meron, and when the students showed interest in wealth he constricted them into golden dinars; he connects this to the Midrash that the gold of Eretz Yisrael is its Torah.
-
26:22 Why taking it back was no miracle
Gold has many levels; when the students held back, the gold turned back into Torah. The Rav contrasts one who takes his heavenly bounty materially with a Jew whose bounty stays spiritual, concludes that the question falls away since nothing came down from heaven, and says Rashbi raised the gold to the level of the beis of Bereishis.
-
30:45 Chizuk and blessings in Rashbi's merit
The Rav says Rashbi gives strength to everyone, even the lowest, and reveals the hidden treasure in every Jew. He brings Rashbi's words that he could free the world from judgment and blesses that in his merit the Jewish people be redeemed, before a niggun is introduced.
-
35:00 Niggun (Singing)
-
43:49 The Satmar Rav's niggun from Meron
Between singing, the Rav tells how the Satmar Rav learned this niggun in Meron and taught it to his chassidim, and the one time he heard him sing alone while all were silent. He explains that a dveikus niggun sung too fast loses its depth and taste.
The shiur, written up
Rejoicing with Rashbi without grasping him
The Rav brings the Mishnas Chassidim, citing the Arizal, that it is a mitzvah to rejoice in the simcha of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, and notes that the Zohar shows Rashbi himself asked that people rejoice on his hillula. What Rashbi is, the Rav says, we cannot grasp; even his colleagues could not. The Gemara relates that Rabbi Akiva seated Rabbi Meir ahead of him, and told Rabbi Shimon it is enough that he and his Creator know his strength. a,b,c
For this reason, the Rav explains from the seforim, the halacha follows Rabbi Yehuda over Rabbi Shimon: he was not grasped. When the earth is filled with knowledge of Hashem, the halacha will follow him. Even so it is a nachas for every Jew to join his simcha. With a story from the Ruzhiner Rebbe's court he shows that with a tzaddik who is altogether different, even the lowest find a place. d
The valley of golden dinars and the question
On this day all of Rashbi's merits and wonders come together. The Rav tells how he drove away a man sent with a decree against the Jews, until the man's superior conceded that if Rabbi Shimon does not allow it, it cannot be done. This, he says, is Rashbi's power to annul decrees.
Chazal relate that a student of Rashbi came back rich from trading abroad, and the others envied him. Rashbi called on a valley to fill with golden dinars, and it filled; when the students reached for it he warned that whoever takes now will not have later, and no one took. The Rav adds that it was the valley of Meron. e
Then he raises a question. The Midrash tells that Rabbi Shimon ben Chalafta, suffering poverty, was given a treasure from heaven, and at his wife's urging prayed that it be taken back; it calls the second miracle greater than the first. Rashbi's gold was surely also taken back, so why is no such greater miracle mentioned there? g
The gold was Rashbi's Torah secrets
The Rav offers his own answer. Rashbi revealed the secrets of the Torah, showing that it holds levels far higher than one imagines, a hidden side beside the revealed one. The upper worlds have no constrictions, while everything in this world passes through constrictions so that it can become material. As the seforim say, silver is love and gold is fear; only when they are made material do they become the metals.
Today the halacha follows Beis Hillel, a Torah of silver, of love, since the attribute of judgment cannot yet be borne; with Moshiach there will be a Torah of gold. Rashbi's Torah lay spread over all of Meron, waiting to be given over to his students in the form of the Zohar. When they showed interest in wealth, wanting to go abroad to grow rich, he constricted those sparks of Torah, and the valley filled with golden dinars.
Why taking it back was no miracle
Gold has many levels; the Gemara counts seven kinds. Because the students held back and did not take, the gold went back to being words of Torah. One who draws his bounty into material things gets real gold, the lowest level. An upright Jew's bounty from heaven stays spiritual, in the joy of a blatt Gemara and the warmth of shalosh seudos, and that is his wealth. k
So for one bound to Rashbi the question does not arise. It was no miracle sent from heaven that had to fly back up; it was there on the spot, changed from Torah into gold and back into Torah. Rashbi raised it to the beis of Bereishis, the highest level, which cannot be grasped and has not yet become letters; the seforim say the word Bereishis holds Rashbi's name.
Chizuk and blessings in Rashbi's merit
The well-known words about Bar Yochai, the Rav says, are reason enough for chizuk: as Hashem is blessed for all, so Rashbi is for all, even the lowest, and one can sit and rejoice with him. Rashbi reveals the hidden treasure in every Jew.
Rashbi said he could free the whole world from judgment, and the Zohar tells what was said to his students at his passing. Jews and the whole world need a great salvation, and the Rav prays that in his merit the Jewish people be taken out of all their troubles and the complete redemption come. l,m
The Satmar Rav's niggun from Meron
Between the singing, the Rav tells that the Satmar Rav, who spent some time in Eretz Yisrael before coming to America, learned this niggun in Meron and taught it to his chassidim. It was the only time the Rav heard the Satmar Rav sing while everyone kept silent to hear him.
He explains that a niggun of dveikus should not be sung too fast, for then one cannot feel its depth, its taste and its breadth.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Talmud Yerushalmi
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Other
Key points
- 11:05 Following the Arizal and the Zohar, the Rav says it is a mitzvah and a nachas for every Jew to rejoice on the hillula of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai.
- 13:15 The halacha follows Rabbi Yehuda rather than Rabbi Shimon because his contemporaries could not grasp him; in the future, when the world is full of knowledge of Hashem, it will follow Rabbi Shimon.
- 24:10 The golden dinars that filled the valley of Meron were Rashbi's chiddushei Torah, which took material form because his students showed interest in wealth.
- 28:21 Since the gold was not sent from heaven but was Torah already present in Meron, its disappearance was no miracle: it simply returned to being Torah.
- 31:45 Rashbi said he could free the whole world from judgment, and the Rav prays that his merit bring the redemption.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 13:15 Why does the halacha follow Rabbi Yehuda and not Rabbi Shimon?
Answer: 13:20 Because his contemporaries could not grasp him; when the world is full of knowledge of Hashem, the halacha will follow Rabbi Shimon.
-
Question: 20:12 If the taking back of Rabbi Shimon ben Chalafta's gift was a greater miracle, why is nothing like it said of Rashbi's valley of gold, which surely also had to be taken back?
Answer: 24:56 The gold was not sent from heaven; it was Rashbi's Torah, already present in Meron, given material form. When the students held back it returned to Torah, so no miracle was needed.
-
Question: 11:50 How can one rejoice with Rashbi when one cannot grasp who he is?
Answer: 14:27 Rashbi is there even for the lowest; as Hashem is blessed for all, so Rashbi is for all, and this is a great chizuk.
Stories
-
14:45 A chassid at the Ruzhiner Rebbe's
A Jew came to the Ruzhiner Rebbe and did not follow what the Rebbe was saying. One chassid remarked on it, and another chassid answered that with the Rebbe, who is altogether different from everyone, understanding him is not the measure. The Rav applies this all the more to Rashbi, with whom even the lowest find a place.
In the story: Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner)
-
16:18 Rashbi drives off an official with a decree
A man came with a decree against the Jews and wanted to carry it out, and Rabbi Shimon drove him away. He went to his superior and said he had been sent to carry out a decree but Rabbi Shimon would not allow it. He was told that if Rabbi Shimon does not allow it, it cannot be done. The Rav calls this Rashbi's power to annul harsh decrees.
In the story: Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai
-
17:02 The valley filled with golden dinars
One of Rashbi's students went abroad, traded and came back wealthy, and the other students wished they had done the same. Rabbi Shimon took them to a valley and said, 'Valley, valley, fill with golden dinars,' and the whole valley filled. When the students wanted to grab, he told them that whoever takes now will not have later, and nobody took. The Rav adds that the valley was the valley of Meron.
In the story: Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai
-
18:22 Rabbi Shimon ben Chalafta's gift taken back
Rabbi Shimon ben Chalafta suffered from poverty, prayed, and was sent a great treasure from heaven. His wife told him that in the next world, when he sits with his friends, their table will have four legs and his only three, since this was already taken in this world. He prayed that it be taken back, and it was; the Midrash says the second miracle was greater than the first.
In the story: Rabbi Shimon ben Chalafta
-
44:09 The Satmar Rav's niggun from Meron
The Satmar Rav spent some time in Eretz Yisrael before coming to America and learned this niggun in Meron. He taught it to his chassidim, and it was the only time the Rav heard the Satmar Rav sing a niggun while everyone else was silent so they could hear him.
In the story: the Satmar Rav
Insights
- 24:10 The Rav reads the golden dinars of the valley as Rashbi's own Torah secrets, which lay spread over Meron and took material form only because the students showed interest in wealth.
- 21:39 Silver and gold are, spiritually, love and fear; only the constrictions of this world turn them into metal, so the material object is a lowered form of a spiritual level.
- 23:42 Today halacha follows Beis Hillel because this is a Torah of silver, of love; when Moshiach comes there will be a Torah of gold, of the attribute of judgment.
- 28:14 Because the gold was Torah already present in Meron rather than a gift from heaven, its vanishing needed no miracle, which answers why the Midrash speaks of a greater miracle only for Rabbi Shimon ben Chalafta.
- 13:17 The halacha does not follow Rabbi Shimon only because he was not grasped; in the future, when the world is full of knowledge of Hashem, it will.
- 27:15 A Jew who does not take his heavenly bounty materially keeps it as spiritual wealth: the joy of a blatt Gemara and the warmth of shalosh seudos.
What the Rav says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Beis Hillel, Rabbi Akiva, Rabbi Meir, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, Rabbi Shimon ben Chalafta, Rabbi Yehuda (bar Ilai), Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), the Arizal, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum)
Terms הילולא, ימות המשיח, מדת הדין, סודות התורה, צמצום