sh

Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת שושן פורים no. ⁨11⁩ Yiddish 1 hr 5 min

Not in the 2012 Pocket Guide; the title is taken from the folder and file name.

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr 5 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains Esther's words that she had not been called to the king for thirty days, in two ways, and Mordechai's answer 'al tedami venafshech': not to calculate for oneself when Klal Yisroel needs a yeshuah.

The Rav opens with Esther's words that she had not been called before the king for thirty days, noting that thirty days marks a new period. Citing the Rambam, he explains that one who davens must know he stands before the King, that each word of tefillah is a heichal, and that before every aliyah comes a yeridah. In his first approach, Esther, about to rise to 'vatilbash Esther malchus', felt for thirty days that she could not say a warm word before Hashem; Mordechai answered 'al tedami venafshech', and the Rav compares Avraham sitting at the opening of the tent, who then received the revelation. After a remark on Shushan Purim, his second approach: the thirty days before Pesach were her preparation in purity, and Mordechai told her that her personal preparation must yield to the need of Klal Yisroel. The rest of the recording holds rhymed performances by others and a long untranscribed stretch.

Topics: Megillas Esther · Shushan Purim · Kavanah in Davening

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Thirty days and standing before the King listed in the guide

    Starting from Esther's words that she had not been called for thirty days, the Rav explains that thirty days is a new period, brings the Rambam that one who davens stands before the King, and describes each word of tefillah as a heichal. He adds that before every aliyah there is a yeridah.

  2. 7:50 Esther's descent before her ascent

    The Rav explains that Esther, about to rise to 'vatilbash Esther malchus', felt for thirty days that she could not speak before Hashem, and Mordechai answered 'al tedami venafshech'. He compares Avraham Avinu sitting at the opening of the tent and concludes that the descent was the preparation for the ascent; he then remarks that Shushan Purim is a yom tov for all Jews.

  3. 13:43 The thirty days before Pesach

    In a second approach, the Rav explains that Esther's thirty days were the thirty days before Pesach, when she was preparing in purity and saw the king's not calling her as siyata dishmaya. Mordechai told her that her preparation is a personal matter and Klal Yisroel needs the decree annulled now; the Rav applies this to davening for a great yeshuah for the klal.

  4. 18:43 A rhymed poem on Erev Shabbos and galus (Another speaker)

  5. 28:47 Untranscribed stretch (Unclear audio)

  6. 55:42 A Purim performance on outwardness and inwardness (Another speaker)

The shiur, written up

Thirty days and standing before the King

4:48

The Rav opens with Esther's words that she had not been called to the king for thirty days (Esther 4:11), noting that thirty days marks a new period. He brings the Rambam that one who davens must know he stands before the King, and explains that each word of tefillah is a heichal. As received from the talmidei haBa'al Shem Tov, before every aliyah comes a yeridah. a

Esther's descent before her ascent

7:52

Esther needed a great aliyah to go in with 'vatilbash Esther malchus' (Esther 5:1), on which the whole miracle rested. Yet for thirty days she felt unable to say a warm word before Hashem, and asked Mordechai how she could bring a yeshuah. He answered 'al tedami venafshech' (Esther 4:13): make no calculations about yourself. b,d

11:03

The Rav compares Avraham Avinu sitting 'at the opening of the tent' (Bereishis 18:1): he felt still outside, and precisely then Hashem appeared to him. So Esther's descent was the preparation for her ascent, and a Jew who feels his words accomplish nothing can precisely merit the heichal of the Shechinah. e

The thirty days before Pesach

13:46

In a second approach, the thirty days were those before Pesach, which the Gemara (Pesachim 6a) marks as its preparation. Esther was preparing in purity and saw the king's silence as siyata dishmaya; why go on Pesach itself? Mordechai answered that this was personal, and Klal Yisroel needed the decree annulled now. The Rav adds that one must likewise daven for a great yeshuah for the klal. g

Sources

Torah

  1. e Bereishis 18:1 text index In the write-up: 11:03
  2. h apparently Vayikra 6:9 14:37 index

Kesuvim

  1. a Esther 4:11 text index In the write-up: 4:48
  2. b Esther 5:1 text index In the write-up: 7:52
  3. d Esther 4:13 text index In the write-up: 7:52
  4. f apparently Esther 9:31 13:05 index

Talmud Bavli

  1. c Gemara Megillah (place not identified) 8:24 index
  2. g apparently Pesachim 6a index In the write-up: 13:46

Key points

  1. 4:42 Thirty days is a set period of time; after thirty days a new period begins, which is why Esther counted thirty days without being called.
  2. 5:17 One who davens must know that he stands before the King; each word of tefillah is a heichal, and one goes from one heichal to the next.
  3. 9:28 Esther felt for thirty days that she could not say a warm word before Hashem and asked how she could bring a yeshuah; Mordechai answered 'al tedami venafshech', not to make calculations about herself.
  4. 7:42 A descent comes before an ascent and is its preparation, as with Avraham Avinu, who sat at the opening of the tent and precisely then received a great revelation.
  5. 13:46 In a second approach, the thirty days were the thirty days before Pesach, in which Esther was preparing herself in purity, and Mordechai told her that her personal preparation must yield to the need of Klal Yisroel.
  6. 18:26 The Rav applies this to the present: looking at the time, one must prepare for a great yeshuah and daven for the klal, not only for oneself.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 9:21 Why did Esther give as her reason that she had not been called to the king for thirty days?

    Answer: 10:24 For thirty days she had felt a descent, unable to speak before Hashem, and doubted she could bring a yeshuah; Mordechai told her not to calculate, since the descent was the preparation for the ascent.

  2. Question: 16:55 Why did Esther want to wait until after Pesach before going to the king?

    Answer: 17:24 She had been preparing in purity for thirty days before Pesach and did not want to give up her preparations; Mordechai answered that this was personal, and Klal Yisroel needed the decree annulled now.

Insights

  1. 5:48 Each word of tefillah is a heichal, a chamber of the King, and davening is passing from one heichal into the next; feeling one has said many chapters without knowing what he said is a sign of being pushed out of the heichalos.
  2. 8:06 Esther's thirty days of feeling unable to say a warm word before Hashem were the preparation for 'vatilbash Esther malchus', the moment on which the whole miracle of Purim rested.
  3. 11:24 Esther's 'I have not been called' parallels Avraham sitting at the opening of the tent: he felt he was still outside and could not enter, and precisely then Hashem appeared to him.
  4. 10:58 A Jew who feels that his words accomplish nothing is precisely the one who can merit the heichal of the Shechinah.
  5. 16:12 According to the second approach, Esther saw the king's not calling her during the thirty days before Pesach as siyata dishmaya for preparing in purity, and Mordechai's 'al tedami venafshech' meant that even holy personal preparation must give way when Klal Yisroel needs a yeshuah.
  6. 12:46 The Rav remarks that Shushan Purim, too, is a yom tov for all Jews, even where the megillah is not read, since there are two days of Purim.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 7:03 The Rav says that one who sees he has no kavanah must exert himself and ask Hashem that he be able to daven together with kavanah in the meaning of the words.
  2. 13:53 The Rav says that thirty days before Pesach one already needs to learn hilchos Pesach and begin to be careful about chametz.
  3. 18:26 The Rav says that, seeing the nature of the time, one must prepare for a great yeshuah and ask Hashem on behalf of the klal, in the spirit of 'al tedami venafshech'.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Achashverosh, Avraham Avinu, Esther HaMalkah, Mordechai HaTzaddik, the Baal Shem Tov, the Rambam

Terms היכל, ישועה, כוונה, סייעתא דשמיא, קטנות, שושן פורים

Report an error on this page