Waiting for Miriam in the Desert and the Hidden Treasure of ט' באב
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) בהעלותך no. 4 Pocket Guide p. 60 תשס"ד (2003–04) English 50 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains why the Jews' waiting for Miriam, which made the meraglim return on Tisha B'Av, was in the end a reward: Tisha B'Av is a 'mo'ed' with a hidden good root, the day Moshiach is born.
The Rav opens with the passuk that the people did not travel until Miriam returned, and brings the Satmar Rav: because of those seven days the meraglim came back on Tisha B'Av, an ill-fated day. He traces a chain of lashon hara from Miriam to the meraglim to both churbanos, and sees the recent movement for guarding one's speech as a sign of the Geulah. He then asks why Miriam, a tzadeikes, should be the cause, and compares Moshe's added day at Sinai that led to the luchos breaking on Shiva Asar B'Tammuz. Turning to the inner side of Tisha B'Av, he calls it a mo'ed that went sour, which will become the greatest yom tov, the day Moshiach is born. Days, like people, have tzaddikim and reshaim, and a hidden root. He concludes that waiting for Miriam placed the meraglim's sin on Tisha B'Av, whose hidden good gave them hope of tikkun.
Topics: Tisha B'Av · The Meraglim · The Beis HaMikdash and Its Churban · The Hidden Roots of Moshiach
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Waiting for Miriam led to Tisha B'Av listed in the guide
The Rav opens with the passuk that the people did not travel until Miriam returned, a reward for her waiting for Moshe. He brings the Satmar Rav that without those seven days the meraglim would have returned before Tisha B'Av, an ill-fated day, and perhaps there would have been no Tisha B'Av at all.
-
4:59 Hashem's plan and the chain of lashon hara listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Hashem's plans come about through causes, answers a listener's question on free will with the Rambam, and traces lashon hara from Miriam to the meraglim to both churbanos. He sees the recent movement to learn the laws of lashon hara, begun by the Chafetz Chaim, as Hashem sending agents to repair this flaw before the Geulah.
-
10:40 Why Miriam? Moshe's added day at Sinai listed in the guide
The Rav asks why Miriam, a tzadeikes whose song is eternal, should cause the churban, and whether she would not rather have stayed in the desert. He brings a similar question from a sefer: Moshe's added day at Sinai made the forty days end on Shiva Asar B'Tammuz, so the luchos were broken, connected to the Magen Avraham's question on the date of Shavuos.
-
17:06 Tisha B'Av, a mo'ed that went sour listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Tisha B'Av is called a mo'ed and has a good inner side. He describes levels of talmidei chachamim like Shabbos, Yom Tov and Chol HaMoed, and compares Tisha B'Av to a gifted bochur who went sour but can be brought back and become great. The 22 days from Shiva Asar B'Tammuz to Tisha B'Av correspond to the 22 holiest days of Tishrei.
-
25:05 Torah of the Nine Days and kiddush for Tisha B'Av Story
The Rav tells of a sefer by a tzaddik, the grandfather of the Bluzhever Rebbe, whose greatest Torah for Sukkos was prepared during the Nine Days. He then tells of a great tzaddik who, on Shabbos Chazon, lifted a cup of wine and made kiddush for Tisha B'Av, as a picture of the days of Moshiach, with tears streaming from his eyes.
-
29:38 The ascent to Shavuos and the descent after
The Rav describes the yearly climb from Chamisha Asar B'Shvat through Purim and Pesach to the peak of Shavuos, and the descent that begins after it. He mentions Chaf Sivan, a fast day for the massacres of the Crusades, later persecutions and the Holocaust deportations, as part of the slide toward Tisha B'Av.
-
33:37 Moshiach's birthday and days that are reshaim listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Midrash that on Tisha B'Av a soul with the potential of Moshiach is born, which explains customs of rising from the floor. He brings the Chasam Sofer that Pesach was once a fast day for Avraham and was transformed, as Tisha B'Av will be. Days, like people, are tzaddikim and reshaim; a rasha is rooted in Tisha B'Av, and his teshuvah transforms his day too.
-
39:03 The hidden root and the hidden Beis HaMikdash listed in the guide
The Rav says the galus is needed like the Geulah, and that even the greatest rasha has a hidden good point, the root represented by Yom Kippur, the fortieth day, like the fortieth lash that is not given. He brings Tosafos in Chagigah on the 'hidden' gematria of the letters, and applies it to Tisha B'Av: what is hidden in it is the third Beis HaMikdash.
-
44:35 What we draw from Tisha B'Av; Miriam's reward listed in the guide
The Rav says each yom tov feeds the whole year, and from Tisha B'Av one draws the knowledge that every tzarah hides good. He concludes that the meraglim had a hidden root, and because they waited for Miriam their sin fell on Tisha B'Av, the day of Moshiach's birth, whose good point gave them hope, so the waiting was a reward for Miriam.
The shiur, written up
Waiting for Miriam led to Tisha B'Av
Hashem's plan and the chain of lashon hara
Hashem's plan, the Rav explains, comes about through causes: as the Midrash says on 'awesome in deed toward men', Adam had to eat from the tree and Yosef had to be sold. When a listener asks how this fits with free choice, the Rav answers that the Rambam already asked it and said we cannot understand these things. e,f,g
He adds that the whole chain began with lashon hara. Miriam's lashon hara held the people back seven days, so the meraglim returned on Tisha B'Av, causing the first churban; the Gemara says the second churban also came through lashon hara, Kamtza bar Kamtza being only the occasion. This is why, since the Chafetz Chaim's sefer, there has been a great movement to learn these laws: as the Geulah nears, Hashem sends agents to repair the flaw. h,i
Why Miriam? Moshe's added day at Sinai
Yet a great question remains. Miriam was a tzadeikes and prophetess whose song is eternal; why should the churban come through her, through the very favor of waiting for her? Would she not rather have stayed behind in the desert? The Satmar Rav says we cannot understand these things.
The Rav brings a similar idea from a sefer: Moshe added a day at Sinai for more preparation and purity, so his forty days on the mountain ended on Shiva Asar B'Tammuz, an ill-fated day, and the luchos were broken. He mentions it with the Magen Avraham's famous question, why the sixth of Sivan is called the time of the giving of the Torah when it was given on the seventh. j
Tisha B'Av, a mo'ed that went sour
The passuk in Eichah calls Tisha B'Av a mo'ed, and so Tachanun is not said. What kind of yom tov is that? The Rav answers that it has a good inner side; when Moshiach comes it will be the greatest yom tov. k
He brings the Zohar that a talmid chacham is like Shabbos, and describes levels: the great talmid chacham who is 'Shabbos' and is supported to learn; one who is 'Yom Tov' and works only for his needs, like cooking on Yom Tov; and a lesser 'Chol HaMoed', who works for more. l
Then there is a mo'ed that went sour: a gifted bochur who could have become a great talmid chacham but went off. He is still a mo'ed; he can be brought back and become one of the greatest. Tisha B'Av is such a mo'ed, and its 22 days from Shiva Asar B'Tammuz correspond to the holiest days of Tishrei.
Torah of the Nine Days and kiddush for Tisha B'Av
The Rav speaks of a sefer by a wondrous tzaddik, the grandfather of the Bluzhever Rebbe, which he once told a bochur troubled by doubts to learn. That tzaddik prepared his greatest Torah for Sukkos during the Nine Days.
He also tells of a great tzaddik who on Shabbos Chazon showed what will be when Moshiach comes: he lifted a cup of wine and made kiddush for Tisha B'Av, and two streams of tears ran from his eyes.
The ascent to Shavuos and the descent after
The Rav describes the yearly climb from Chamisha Asar B'Shvat through Purim and Pesach to the peak of Shavuos, and the descent after it. Chaf Sivan was a fast for the massacres of the Crusades, repeated centuries later and in the Holocaust; from there the days slide toward Tisha B'Av.
Moshiach's birthday and days that are reshaim
The Rav brings the Midrash that every Tisha B'Av a soul is born with the potential to be Moshiach. This is why people rise from the floor, and among Sefardim women wash their faces: they rejoice that Moshiach is born. n
The Chasam Sofer writes that Pesach was once a fast for Avraham Avinu because of the decree of exile, yet it was transformed; so will Tisha B'Av be. Days, the Rav explains, are like people: there are tzaddik days and rasha days, and a rasha is rooted in Tisha B'Av. When he does teshuvah, his day is transformed with him.
The hidden root and the hidden Beis HaMikdash
What we draw from Tisha B'Av; Miriam's reward
Every yom tov feeds the whole year: Pesach gives Geulah, Shavuos Torah, Sukkos bitachon, Yom Kippur teshuvah. From Tisha B'Av, the Rav says, one draws the knowledge that good is hidden in every tzarah.
Rashi says the meraglim were tzaddikim, and the Rav explains that a hidden root remained in them after their sin. On another day they would have had no rising, but on Tisha B'Av their root combined with the day's. Because the people waited for Miriam, the meraglim returned on the day of Moshiach's birth, so the waiting was truly a reward for her. t
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Talmud Yerushalmi
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- b apparently Rashi on Bamidbar 12:15 index In the write-up: 0:00
- g apparently Rambam, Hilchos Teshuvah 5:5 index In the write-up: 5:08
- q Tosafos (place not identified) index In the write-up: 42:28
- s apparently Rambam, Hilchos Gerushin 2:20 46:08 index
- t apparently Rashi on Bamidbar 13:3 index In the write-up: 46:27
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 2:44 According to the Satmar Rav, the seven days the people waited for Miriam made the meraglim return on Tisha B'Av instead of seven days earlier.
- 7:13 The Rav traces a chain of lashon hara from Miriam through the meraglim to the first and second churban.
- 17:38 Tisha B'Av is called a mo'ed because it has a good inner side; when Moshiach comes it will be the greatest yom tov.
- 37:12 Just as there are tzaddikim and reshaim among people, there are tzaddik days and rasha days in the calendar, and a rasha's teshuvah transforms his day too.
- 44:27 Hidden within Tisha B'Av is the third Beis HaMikdash, and from Tisha B'Av one draws for the whole year the knowledge that every tzarah hides good.
- 48:19 Because they waited for Miriam, the meraglim's sin fell on the day of the birth of Moshiach ben David, whose good point gave them hope; so the waiting was a reward for Miriam.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 5:45 If Tisha B'Av had to be, how is a person's free choice preserved?
Answer: 6:07 The Rambam already asked this and said we cannot understand these things; there was a reason it had to be so.
-
Question: 10:52 Why should Miriam, a tzadeikes, be the cause of the churban through the favor of waiting for her?
Answer: 48:19 Because they waited for her, the meraglim's sin fell on Tisha B'Av, the day of Moshiach's birth, whose good point gave them hope; so it was truly a reward.
-
Question: 17:45 What kind of yom tov is Tisha B'Av, that it is called a mo'ed and Tachanun is not said?
Answer: 17:59 It has a good inner side, and when Moshiach comes it will be the greatest yom tov.
-
Question: 44:58 Each yom tov gives something for the whole year; what does one draw from Tisha B'Av?
Answer: 45:36 The knowledge that something good is hidden in every tzarah and will come out of it.
Stories
-
25:05 The bochur with doubts and the tzaddik's sefer
The Rav mentions a sefer by a wondrous tzaddik, the grandfather of the Bluzhever Rebbe who lived in Boro Park. A bochur once complained to the Rav about doubts he had, and the Rav told him to learn that sefer. The tzaddik's greatest Torah for Sukkos was prepared during the Nine Days, one day for each day of Sukkos, up to Tisha B'Av itself.
In the story: the Bluzhever Rebbe
-
28:32 Kiddush for Tisha B'Av on Shabbos Chazon
A very great tzaddik used, on Shabbos Chazon, to give a small presentation of what will happen when Moshiach comes. He took a cup of wine in his hand and made kiddush for Tisha B'Av. As he said it, two streams of tears flowed from his eyes.
Insights
- 2:59 The Satmar Rav: every journey in the desert had its function, and because they waited seven days for Miriam the forty days of the meraglim ended exactly on Tisha B'Av, an ill-fated day; otherwise the whole episode might not have happened.
- 9:14 Since the churban began with Miriam's lashon hara, the great movement in recent decades to learn the laws of lashon hara is Hashem sending agents to repair this flaw as the time of the Geulah approaches.
- 13:51 A sefer the Rav brings sees the same pattern at Sinai: Moshe added a day for more preparation and purity, so the forty days ended on Shiva Asar B'Tammuz and the luchos were broken.
- 21:23 The Rav compares Tisha B'Av to a gifted bochur who could have become a great talmid chacham but went sour: he too is a 'mo'ed', can be brought back, and will become one of the greatest.
- 37:12 Days are like people: there are tzaddik days and rasha days, each person is rooted in his day, and when a rasha does teshuvah not only his soul but his day is transformed.
- 43:46 Building on Tosafos' 'hidden' gematria, the Rav computes the hidden letters of the words Tisha B'Av and finds in them the third Beis HaMikdash.
- 46:34 The meraglim had a hidden root of good, and because their sin fell on Tisha B'Av, which also has a hidden root, the two combined to give them hope of a tikkun; this is why waiting for Miriam was a reward.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 22:58 The Rav says a bochur who went off the path can be salvaged: one can be mekarev him, he can do teshuvah, and he can develop into what he has the potential to be.
- 45:36 According to the Rav, whenever one sees a tzarah one should know that something good is hidden in its deep root and will come out of it.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Adam HaRishon, Avraham Avinu, Dovid HaMelech, Miriam, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rashi, Rav Avraham Yaakov Pam, Rav Segal of Manchester, the Baalei Tosafos, the Bluzhever Rebbe, the Chasam Sofer, the Chofetz Chaim, the Magen Avraham, the Rambam, the Satmar Rav (Rabbi Yoel Teitelbaum), Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms חול המועד, לשון הרע, מועד, מצורע, מרגלים, נקודה הפנימית, פנימיות, שבירת הלוחות, שבעה עשר בתמוז, שבת חזון, שורש הנעלם, תחנון, תשעה באב