Explaining יצחק's Fondness of עשו and the meaning of ויגדלו הנערים
Catalog entry: PARSHA (English) תולדות no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 55 תשמ"ט (1988–89) English 1 hr 8 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that Yitzchak loved Esav because the food Esav brought him was really prepared by Yaakov with kedushah, so Yitzchak took Esav for a hidden tzaddik.
The Rav opens with the many blessings of Parshas Toldos, the sixth sedra, and links the number six and the root of the word bracha to doubling. He then asks how Yitzchak could prefer Esav because of his hunting, or be fooled by him. Through Rashi's statement that the twins 'grew up' at thirteen, though the arithmetic makes them fifteen, he explains that on the day a tzaddik passes away all his days come down to escort him, as with Eliyahu and Elisha. Since every tzaddik has an opposing rasha, Nimrod died the day Avraham did: Yaakov absorbed the kedushah at Avraham's bedside, while Esav absorbed the tumah of the slain Nimrod. That day Esav became a heretic, so his own shechitah could not be eaten. Yaakov therefore prepared the food that Esav brought; Yitzchak sensed its kedushah and thought Esav a hidden tzaddik, until the day of the brachos.
Topics: Yitzchak, Yaakov and Esav · The Passing of a Tzaddik · Kashrus and Kedushas HaAchilah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Toldos, the sedra of blessing
The Rav shows that every aliyah of Toldos contains a blessing, ties the sixth sedra, the sixth aliyah and the sixth hakafah to blessing, and explains the root of bracha as doubling. He ends with the Mishnah that only shalom is a vessel for blessing.
-
8:57 Why did Yitzchak love Esav? listed in the guide
Setting aside the topic of emunah for later sedros, the Rav brings the passuk that Yitzchak loved Esav for his hunting, with Rashi (Esav trapped his father) and Onkelos (Yitzchak ate from his hunting). He asks how Yitzchak could prefer Esav for good food or be fooled by him, and notes the same pattern at the brachos.
-
14:29 The day the bechorah was sold
Following Rashi, the Rav describes the day Avraham passed away: Yaakov cooked round lentils as a mourner's meal, and Esav came home after five sins, among them killing Nimrod for Adam's garment and denying techiyas hameisim. This made Esav an apikores, and the Rav asks how Yitzchak could then eat meat Esav brought.
-
21:24 Vayigdelu hanearim: thirteen or fifteen? listed in the guide
The Rav brings Rashi that 'the boys grew up' means they turned thirteen, and shows by the ages in the pesukim that on the day Avraham died they were fifteen. He rejects calling it a misprint, since one becomes grown at thirteen, not fifteen.
-
24:48 All one's days come on the last day
The Rav asks how Eliyahu could give Elisha double his own spirit, and answers with the Agra deKallah, the Bnei Yissaschar and the Zohar that time is a creation, each day ascends with what was done in it, and on a tzaddik's last day all his days return to escort him. So Moshe said 'today I am 120', and the Chasam Sofer grieved that he was not at his rebbe's bedside.
-
32:09 Every tzaddik has his opposing rasha
From the Gemara about Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya on his deathbed, the Rav explains that each tzaddik has a rasha of his measure who keeps the scale balanced. Nimrod, whose name means rebellion, was Avraham's opponent, and he was killed the very day Avraham passed away.
-
37:20 Kedushah at one bedside, tumah at the other listed in the guide
The Rav shows that Esav was Yaakov's opponent and died the day Yaakov was buried, as the Gemara in Sotah relates. Then he explains the day Avraham died: Yaakov at the bedside absorbed the kedushah of Avraham's 175 years, while Esav absorbed the tumah around the slain Nimrod, so both 'grew up' that day.
-
44:03 Michrah kayom: two philosophies
The Rav reads 'sell me as this day' as Yaakov telling Esav that the nature of this day decides who needs the bechorah. He contrasts the tzaddik's 'today to do them, tomorrow the reward' with the rasha's 'eat and drink, for tomorrow we die', and Esav agrees that by his view he has no use for it.
-
48:07 A tzaddik tastes kedushah, not flavor listed in the guide
The Rav explains that a real tzaddik enjoys life through Torah and mitzvos but measures food by its kedushah, telling of the Yismach Moshe who ate soapy water unaware. Kedushah enters food through kavanah, as with a wife cooking for Shabbos, matzah baked lishmah and the korban Pesach; then he begins his answer: Yaakov prepared Yitzchak's food so that Yitzchak would not sense Esav's treif shechitah.
-
56:14 The Slonimer Rebbe and the borrowed plates Story
To show that tzaddikim sense what they may not eat, the Rav tells a story he heard from an eyewitness: the Slonimer Rebbe, visiting Yerushalayim, would not eat from plates borrowed from a bearded man who had not immersed them, and contrasted him with the beardless host.
-
1:01:50 Yitzchak's mistake and the day of the brachos listed in the guide
The Rav concludes that Yitzchak sensed kedushah in the food Esav brought, which Yaakov had made, and took Esav for a hidden tzaddik; this reconciles Onkelos and Rashi. On Pesach night Rivka's prophecy forced Yaakov to bring the food himself, and the truth came out. He closes with a story of a tzaddik whose chulent tasted of his own handful of beans.
The shiur, written up
Toldos, the sedra of blessing
The Rav opens by showing that Parshas Toldos is full of blessing: every aliyah contains a bracha, and he counted thirty-two words from the root of bracha in it. Toldos is the sixth sedra, and six is a number of blessing. The Jews in Mitzrayim were blessed with six children at a time, and Yosef, the sixth of the ushpizin, had his blessing doubled into two shevatim.
The root of bracha itself spells doubling: beis is two, chaf twenty and reish two hundred. This is why, he says, chassidim treat shishi as the most important aliyah and put the most joy into the sixth hakafah. Yet to receive blessing a person must be whole, like a pocket without a hole, since the Mishnah teaches that only shalom is a vessel that holds blessing; so the Rav says one should pray for shalom among Jews. a
Why did Yitzchak love Esav?
Putting the subject of emunah aside for the sedros of Yetzias Mitzrayim and Matan Torah, the Rav turns to the passuk contrasting Esav the hunter with Yaakov who sat and learned, and Yitzchak loved Esav for his hunting. Rashi explains that Esav trapped his father as a hunter traps an animal; Onkelos, that Yitzchak ate from his hunting. b,c,d
Both are hard. The Rav cannot accept that Yitzchak would prefer Esav for a steak, nor that such a tzaddik could be fooled. The same pattern returns at the brachos, which Yitzchak makes depend on Esav's dish.
The day the bechorah was sold
Going back to the start of the sedra, the Rav brings Rashi that the bechorah was sold on the day Avraham Avinu passed away. A mourner's first meal comes from others and should be round, so Yaakov cooked lentils for Yitzchak, just as the round egg on the Seder plate recalls mourning for the Beis Hamikdash. e
That day Esav came home starving after five sins. He killed Nimrod to take the garment Hashem made for Adam, which drew animals to the hunter, and he denied techiyas hameisim, one of the thirteen principles of faith. This made him an apikores, whose shechitah may not be eaten, and the Rav asks how Yitzchak could eat his meat all those years. e,f
Vayigdelu hanearim: thirteen or fifteen?
The passuk says 'the boys grew up', and Rashi explains that at thirteen their natures became evident. But Yitzchak was sixty at their birth and Avraham died at a hundred seventy-five, so that day they were fifteen. Some say Rashi is misprinted; the Rav asks why, then, the passuk would call them grown only at fifteen. b,g,h,i
All one's days come on the last day
The Rav asks how Eliyahu could grant Elisha double his own spirit, as Melachim tells, and why only if Elisha saw him taken up. One cannot give what one does not have, yet Elisha did perform double Eliyahu's wonders. j
He answers with the Agra deKallah and the Bnei Yissaschar that time is a creation. As the Zohar says, each day comes down, is inscribed with a person's deeds and ascends, so teshuvah is easier before it goes up. On a person's last day all his days return to escort him; so Moshe said that today he had his hundred twenty years, and only then is he called 'the man of G-d'. k,l,m,n,o
Every tzaddik has his opposing rasha
The Gemara in Chagigah tells that Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, who always won debates on faith with the non-Jews, comforted his students on his deathbed: when he is gone, his opponents will lose their strength too. From this the Rav explains that every tzaddik has a rasha of his own measure who keeps the scale balanced, so that the choice between good and bad stays even. q
Avraham's opponent was Nimrod, whose name comes from rebellion: Avraham spread belief in one G-d, Nimrod rebellion against Him. Therefore Nimrod was killed the very day Avraham passed away.
Kedushah at one bedside, tumah at the other
Likewise Esav was Yaakov's lifelong opponent, and the Gemara in Sotah relates that he died on the day of Yaakov's burial: he claimed a share in the Me'aras HaMachpelah, and while Naftali ran to Mitzrayim for the deed, Chushim ben Dan cut off his head. s
Returning to the day of Avraham's passing, the Rav explains that Yaakov stood at his bedside, where all of Avraham's hundred seventy-five years came down, and like Elisha he absorbed great kedushah. Esav stood by the slain Nimrod amid the tumah of all his sins and absorbed it. So both 'grew up' that day at fifteen, one a great tzaddik, the other a great rasha.
Michrah kayom: two philosophies
Therefore Yaakov said 'sell me as this day': what this day made of them decides who needs the bechorah. The tzaddik lives by 'today to do them, tomorrow their reward'; the rasha, as the navi puts it, says 'eat and drink, for tomorrow we die'. Esav agreed that by his view he had no need of it. t,u,v
A tzaddik tastes kedushah, not flavor
Years later Yitzchak sends Esav for good food. The Rav explains that a real tzaddik enjoys life, feeling the sweetness of Torah and mitzvos, but measures food only by its kedushah. The Yismach Moshe once warmed the wrong pot and ate soapy water for supper without noticing.
Kedushah enters food through intention: a wife who cooks carefully kosher food so her family can serve Hashem, especially for Shabbos, puts kedushah into it. Matzah, prepared 'for the sake of the mitzvah' from the harvest on, is the holiest food, and the korban Pesach became holy through words.
The Slonimer Rebbe and the borrowed plates
The Rav tells a story he heard from an eyewitness. The Slonimer Rebbe, visiting Yerushalayim, dined with a poor, beardless, G-d-fearing man, but did not touch the fish and asked for a big plate. The plates were borrowed from a man with a long beard, who admitted he had not immersed them, relying on poskim. The Rebbe told the host that above they would ask him 'where is your beard?', and the other 'where is your Jew?'
Yitzchak's mistake and the day of the brachos
Tasting kedushah in food brought by a hunter who did not learn, Yitzchak concluded that Esav was a concealed tzaddik, one of the thirty-six, greater than a revealed one. On Pesach night Rivka's prophecy, as the Targum says, forced Yaakov to bring the food himself, and Rashi says Yitzchak sensed Gan Eden. Esav found nothing and brought a dog, says Targum Yonasan, and Yitzchak sensed Gehinnom. So Onkelos and Rashi agree. c,d,x,y,z
He closes with a tzaddik whose chulent no recipe could copy, because each Friday he threw in a handful of beans himself; that, the Rav says, is what tzaddikim taste.
Sources
Torah
- b Bereishis 25:27 text index In the write-up: 9:07, 21:24
- h Bereishis 25:26 text index In the write-up: 21:24
- i Bereishis 25:7 text index In the write-up: 21:24
- k Devarim 31:2 text index In the write-up: 27:17
- o apparently Devarim 33:1 index In the write-up: 27:17
- r apparently Bereishis 33:12 33:30 index
- t Bereishis 25:31 text index In the write-up: 44:40
- u apparently Devarim 7:11 index In the write-up: 44:40
Nevi'im
Targum
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 3:42 Toldos, the sixth sedra, is full of blessing; the number six and the letters of the root of bracha express doubling, and the vessel that holds blessing is shalom.
- 27:19 On the day of a tzaddik's passing all his days come down to escort him, so he is greater that day than ever, which is why Eliyahu could give Elisha a double portion only then.
- 33:59 Every tzaddik has an opposing rasha of his measure, so Nimrod died the day Avraham died and Esav died the day Yaakov was buried.
- 40:59 On the day of Avraham's passing Yaakov absorbed great kedushah at his bedside and Esav absorbed great tumah from the slain Nimrod; this is how 'the boys grew up' at fifteen.
- 49:37 A real tzaddik measures food by its kedushah, not its taste, and kedushah enters food through the intention with which it is prepared.
- 55:05 Yaakov prepared the food that Esav brought Yitzchak, so Yitzchak sensed kedushah in it and took Esav for a hidden tzaddik.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 11:47 How could Yitzchak, the great tzaddik, prefer Esav because he brought him good food, or be deceived by him like an animal by a hunter?
Answer: 1:02:14 The food Esav brought was prepared by Yaakov with kedushah; Yitzchak sensed it and concluded that Esav was a hidden tzaddik.
-
Question: 20:28 How could Yitzchak eat the meat Esav brought, when from the day Esav denied techiyas hameisim his shechitah was not kosher?
Answer: 55:05 Yaakov prepared the food all those years and let Esav bring it, to spare Yitzchak the distress of sensing treif.
-
Question: 22:38 Rashi says 'the boys grew up' at thirteen, but by the arithmetic they were fifteen when Avraham died; and if it is a misprint, why would the passuk say they grew up at fifteen?
Answer: 42:54 They grew up that day not in years but in what they absorbed: Yaakov the kedushah at Avraham's bedside, Esav the tumah at Nimrod's corpse.
-
Question: 25:22 How could Eliyahu give Elisha double his own spirit, and why only if Elisha saw him taken away?
Answer: 30:38 On the day of his ascent all of Eliyahu's days came down to escort him, so he was far greater than on an ordinary day and could give double.
Stories
-
50:01 The Yismach Moshe's supper of soapy water
The wife of the Yismach Moshe had to go out one evening and asked him to serve himself supper from the pot on the stove. On the same stove stood a dirty pot soaking in soapy water. He warmed the wrong pot and ate the soapy water for supper. When his wife returned and discovered it, it was clear he had not known the difference.
In the story: the Yismach Moshe
-
57:37 The Slonimer Rebbe and the unimmersed plates
On a visit to Yerushalayim the Slonimer Rebbe ate each night at a different chassid's house, and once chose a poor, G-d-fearing man without a beard. When the fish was served the Rebbe did not eat, and asked for a big plate; the host looked at a man with a long beard from whom he had borrowed the plates. The Rebbe asked that man whether the plates were immersed in a mikveh, and he said no, relying on poskim. The Rebbe told the host that above they would ask him 'Jew, where is your beard?', but the other man 'Beard, where is your Jew?'
In the story: the Slonimer Rebbe
-
1:05:36 The tzaddik's secret chulent ingredient
A great rav spent a Shabbos with a tzaddik about 150 years ago and found the chulent more delicious than any he had eaten. He asked the Rebbetzin for the recipe, but when his wife followed it the chulent was ordinary. The next time he came, the Rebbetzin explained what was missing: every Friday her husband the tzaddik came into the kitchen and threw a handful of beans into the pot himself.
Insights
- 4:22 The root of bracha spells doubling in three orders of magnitude: beis is two, chaf twenty, reish two hundred, as alef is one; this is why Yosef, the sixth of the ushpizin, had his blessing doubled into two shevatim.
- 27:52 Time is a creation: each day comes down, is inscribed with what a person does, and ascends; therefore teshuvah is easier before the day goes up, at night before sleep, on Erev Shabbos and on Erev Rosh Hashanah.
- 24:20 Rashi's 'thirteen' is not a misprint: the boys became bar mitzvah-grown not by age but by what they absorbed on the day of Avraham's passing, Yaakov from Avraham's days and Esav from Nimrod's tumah.
- 44:22 Yaakov's words 'sell me as this day' mean that the very nature of that day, which made Esav a denier of the World to Come, showed that he had no use for the bechorah.
- 1:04:51 Onkelos and Rashi do not disagree: Yitzchak loved Esav for the food he ate from his hunting, and that was Esav's deception, since the food with its kedushah was really Yaakov's.
- 1:02:48 Yitzchak concluded from the kedushah in the food that Esav was a concealed tzaddik, one of the thirty-six, who is greater than a revealed one; this is why he favored him.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 7:25 The Rav says that approaching Shabbos Parshas Toldos one should make oneself a fitting receptacle for the sedra's blessings through completeness, and pray to Hashem for shalom among Jews.
- 28:33 The Rav says that one who did wrong during the day should do teshuvah at night before sleeping, before the day ascends.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Chushim ben Dan, Elisha HaNavi, Eliyahu HaNavi, Esav, Moshe Rabbeinu, Naftali, Nimrod, Rabbi Nosson Adler, Rabbi Yehoshua ben Chananya, Rivka Imeinu, the Chasam Sofer, the Slonimer Rebbe, the Yismach Moshe, Yaakov Avinu, Yitzchak Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אושפיזין, אפיקורס, בכורה, ברכה, טומאה, י"ג עיקרים, מערת המכפלה, פי שנים, צדיק נסתר, קדושה, תחיית המתים