An Explanation of מגילת רות: The redemption of רות, the נשמה of יובל, from the bondage of מואב
Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) שבועות no. 5 Pocket Guide p. 68 תשס"ה (2004–05) English 51 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains Megillas Rus as the megillah of Yovel, the return of a lost soul to its roots: Rus, a neshama of Yovel, is drawn out of Moav to Beis Lechem, and even her descendant Menashe is brought back through Hashem's hidden tunnel of teshuvah.
The Rav opens with Shavuos as a day of Yovel, of returning to one's roots, set against the eved who cuts himself off from the Jewish family and refuses the 'rope' of Shabbos until the shofar of Yovel drags him out. Megillas Rus is the megillah of Yovel; just as Yovel exists in time and in the soul, it has a place, Beis Lechem, the home of David and Moshiach. Naomi, wife of Elimelech, goes to Moav to bring back Rus, a neshama of Yovel. Boaz hints to Rus that Menashe will come from her, and the Rav asks why he would tell her such a painful thing. Through the Gemara's story of Rav Ashi and Menashe, he answers that even Menashe teaches Klal Yisrael how to make hamotzi. He explains Hashem's tunnel for Menashe's teshuvah as yibum, the tikkun of souls, ties it to the neshamos in our bread, and closes with preparing for Shavuos.
Topics: Megillas Rus · Teshuvah
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Shavuos, Yovel and the eved who leaves the family listed in the guide
The Rav introduces Rus and Boaz and calls Shavuos a day of Yovel, a return to one's roots. He contrasts the eved who cuts himself off from the Jewish family and refuses the 'rope' of Shabbos, until the shofar of Yovel on Yom Kippur drags him out like a lifeguard.
-
7:26 Beis Lechem, the place of Yovel listed in the guide
The Rav calls Megillas Rus the megillah of Yovel and, following the triad of time, place and soul, argues that the place of Yovel is Beis Lechem. David HaMelech and Moshiach, who gathers Jews back, are neshamos of Yovel, and Rachel near Beis Lechem was promised the return.
-
12:46 Naomi brings Rus out of Moav listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Naomi, wife of Elimelech, had the task of malchus, to bring back lost souls; she went to Moav, the opposite of Yovel, to draw out Rus. He then brings Boaz's words to Rus about dipping her bread in vinegar and the Gemara's reading that it hints at Menashe.
-
16:07 Menashe's teshuvah and Boaz's painful hint listed in the guide
The Rav tells of Menashe's wickedness, his captivity in a heated pot, his teshuvah and Hashem digging a tunnel under the Kisei HaKavod against the angels. He then asks why Boaz, bound by the prohibition of hurting with words, told Rus about this blemish in her line.
-
21:25 Menashe appears to Rav Ashi Story
The Rav tells the Gemara's story of Rav Ashi, who called Menashe 'our friend', and Menashe appearing to him in a dream to ask where one cuts the bread at hamotzi. Rav Ashi taught the answer the next day, and the halacha passed into the Rambam, the Shulchan Aruch and every Jewish table.
-
27:08 Boaz's comfort and the angels' objection listed in the guide
The Rav answers that Boaz was comforting Rus: even the rasha from her line would teach Klal Yisrael the halacha of hamotzi. He then asks why Hashem smuggled Menashe in rather than tell the angels they were wrong, and brings the Yerushalmi on who decides the sinner's fate.
-
31:28 Levels of Torah and the Mishnah's dispute listed in the guide
The Rav explains that teshuvah answers what the Torah's plain level does not, because there are levels in the soul and in Torah, and every Jew must return to his root. Thus the Mishnah, that Menashe has no share, and the Gemara, that he does, are both true at different levels, and Hashem acts on a level the angels cannot grasp.
-
35:55 Eretz Yisrael, Moshiach and the first yibum listed in the guide
The Rav brings the law that a man sentenced abroad who flees to Eretz Yisrael is judged again, because a deeper level of judgment is revealed there; so Moshiach, a neshama of Yovel, brings close every Jew. He then turns to yibum as a tikkun of souls, from Yehuda and Tamar to Boaz and Rus.
-
40:23 Yibum as a tunnel; neshamos in bread
The Rav calls yibum a tunnel under the Kisei HaKavod and ties it to Moshiach. He compares the body's unseen digestion of bread to the hidden tikkun of a neshama in food, and brings the Ba'al Shem Tov that hunger exists because a soul is wrapped in the food.
-
44:01 Eating with kavanah and Menashe's lesson
The Rav contrasts careless eating with washing, a bracha and kavanah that elevate the neshama in the bread. Baking is the last stage of the bread's tikkun, so the part baked first shows Hashem hurrying its tikkun; this was Menashe's message to Rav Ashi, that Hashem expedites the tikkun of malchus Beis David.
-
48:16 Preparing for Shavuos
The Rav returns to Shavuos as a return to one's roots and notes that the Torah commands preparation, seven weeks of counting, only for Shavuos. He urges using the last week of Sefirah, even after wasted time.
The shiur, written up
Shavuos, Yovel and the eved
The Rav notes that Rus came from Moav and Boaz from Yehuda, and that just as there was yibum with Yehuda and Tamar, there was yibum with Boaz and Rus. Rus descended from Lot's elder daughter, the mother of Moav, through Balak and Eglon. Shavuos, he says, is a day of Yovel, of returning to one's roots, and the counting of Klal Yisrael by families in Bamidbar prepares for it. d
Against this stands the eved, who leaves the Jewish family and loses its kedushah. Shabbos, a day of return, is a rope thrown to him, but he refuses it. Then comes Yovel, the fiftieth level: its shofar on Yom Kippur pulls him out by the hair like a lifeguard, as the shofar of Moshiach will.
Beis Lechem, the place of Yovel
The Rav calls Megillas Rus the megillah of Yovel. Following Sefer Yetzirah, everything exists in time, place and soul, so Yovel needs a place, and he is convinced, though he has not seen it in a sefer, that it is Beis Lechem. David HaMelech and Moshiach are neshamos of Yovel; as the Rambam writes, Moshiach is known by gathering Jews back to Eretz Yisrael. Rachel, near Beis Lechem, was promised the return. f,g
Naomi brings Rus out of Moav
Naomi was the wife of Elimelech, whose name the Midrash reads as a sign of malchus, whose task is to bring back lost souls. She went to Moav, the opposite of Yovel, to draw out Rus. Boaz later told Rus to dip her bread in vinegar, which the Gemara reads as a hint that Menashe would descend from her. h,a,b
Menashe's teshuvah and Boaz's hint
Menashe was a great rasha who brought an idol into the Beis HaMikdash. Captured by the king of Ashur and set in a pot over a fire, he did teshuvah. The Gemara relates that the angels objected, so Hashem dug a tunnel under the Kisei HaKavod and accepted him. i
The Rav asks why Boaz told Rus this at all, when hurting with words is forbidden, especially to a convert. Her lineage already carried blemishes, which surface in later generations.
Menashe appears to Rav Ashi
The Gemara in Sanhedrin tells that Rav Ashi, expounding Sefer Melachim, announced that next they would speak of 'our friend Menashe'. That night Menashe appeared in a dream and asked from which part of the loaf one cuts at hamotzi. When Rav Ashi did not know, Menashe asked how he could call him his friend, and told him: where the crust formed first, the best-baked part. k
Boaz's comfort and the angels' objection
The Rav answers that Boaz was comforting Rus, who worried about her lineage: even the rasha from her line would teach Klal Yisrael hamotzi, so her bread would be dipped in Menashe's halacha.
Levels of Torah
Teshuvah, the Rav explains, reflects deeper levels in the soul and in Torah, and every Jew must return to his root; that is Yovel. So the Mishnah, that Menashe has no share, and the Gemara, that he does, are both true at different strata, since a Jew can never be fully erased from Klal Yisrael. The angels judge by their level; Hashem acts from a higher one they cannot grasp, and so He smuggles Menashe in. j
Eretz Yisrael, Moshiach and yibum
A man sentenced to death who flees to another city is not retried, but if he flees to Eretz Yisrael he is; Rashi explains that a merit may be found for him there, where a deeper level is revealed. So Moshiach, a neshama of Yovel, finds merit for every Jew, including Menashe of malchus Beis David. n
Yibum as a tunnel; neshamos in bread
The Rav calls yibum a tunnel under the Kisei HaKavod, hard digging to bring a soul to its tikkun, and ties it to Moshiach. Just as a person eats bread unaware of how his body draws its nutrients, he is unaware of the neshama in it; the Ba'al Shem Tov explained that hunger exists because a soul is wrapped in the food.
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Talmud Yerushalmi
Midrash
- h Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 12:46
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 0:44 Shavuos is a day of Yovel: a return of every Jew to his roots and to the Jewish family, which the counting of Klal Yisrael by families prepares.
- 8:05 Yovel exists in time, in the soul and in a place; its place is Beis Lechem, home of David HaMelech and Moshiach, who gathers Jews back to Eretz Yisrael.
- 27:18 Boaz's hint that Menashe would descend from Rus was meant as comfort: even Menashe would teach Klal Yisrael the halacha of hamotzi.
- 33:53 Hashem accepted Menashe's teshuvah through a hidden tunnel because there is a level of Torah higher than the angels can grasp, where every Jew must return.
- 40:23 Yibum is the tikkun of souls, a 'tunnel under the Kisei HaKavod', and it is connected to Moshiach.
- 43:05 Food holds neshamos awaiting their tikkun; eating with washing, a bracha and kavanah elevates them, while careless eating lowers them.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 18:40 Why did Boaz tell Rus that Menashe would descend from her, when there is a prohibition against hurting someone with words, especially a convert?
Answer: 27:18 To comfort her: worried about the blemish in her lineage, she learns that even the rasha from her line will teach Klal Yisrael the halacha of hamotzi.
-
Question: 28:49 If the angels were wrong, why did Hashem not tell them so, and if they were right, why did He accept Menashe through a tunnel?
Answer: 34:08 The angels are right by the level of Torah they grasp, but Hashem acts from a higher level of Torah beyond their grasp, so He brings Menashe in without them seeing.
-
Question: 33:14 How can the Mishnah say Menashe has no share in the World to Come while the Gemara says he does?
Answer: 33:48 Both are true at different strata: a Jew can never be fully erased from Klal Yisrael, and it depends on which level of judgment one looks from.
-
Question: 22:49 Why is hamotzi made on the best-baked part of the loaf?
Answer: 46:32 Baking is the last stage of the tikkun of the soul in the bread; the part baked first shows Hashem hurrying its tikkun, so one joins Him by making the bracha there.
Stories
-
16:37 Menashe in the heated pot
Menashe was a great rasha who spread idolatry and brought an idol into the Beis HaMikdash. The king of Ashur took him captive, put him in a huge pot and lit a fire under it. Seeing he would be roasted, Menashe did teshuvah and turned to Hashem, and he was brought back to Yerushalayim. The angels argued that he should not be accepted, so Hashem dug a tunnel under the Kisei HaKavod and accepted him there.
In the story: Menashe
-
21:41 Menashe teaches Rav Ashi about hamotzi
Rav Ashi was expounding Sefer Melachim and ended a shiur saying that tomorrow they would speak of 'our friend Menashe'. That night Menashe came to him in a dream and asked from which part of the loaf one cuts at hamotzi; when Rav Ashi did not know, Menashe asked how he could call himself his friend. Menashe told him to cut where the crust formed first, the best-baked part. Asked why, if he was so wise, he served idols, Menashe answered that had Rav Ashi lived in his time he would have run after it, lifting his robes. The next day Rav Ashi taught this halacha in Menashe's name.
In the story: Rav Ashi, Menashe
Insights
- 4:47 The Rav describes Shabbos as a rope thrown to the eved to return, and Yovel as the lifeguard who pulls him out by the hair when he will not grab it; the shofar of Moshiach will do the same.
- 8:46 The Rav says he is convinced, though he has not seen it in a sefer, that the place of Yovel is Beis Lechem Yehudah, the home of David HaMelech, whose malchus gathers Jews back.
- 27:51 Boaz's 'dip your bread in vinegar' becomes a blessing: her bread will be dipped in the halacha that Menashe taught about how to make hamotzi.
- 33:53 The Mishnah and the Gemara on Menashe's share are both true at different levels, just as a deeper level of judgment in Eretz Yisrael can reopen a case closed abroad.
- 40:26 Yibum itself is Hashem's tunnel under the Kisei HaKavod: hard work digging to bring a lost soul to its tikkun, which is why it belongs to Moshiach.
- 46:32 Baking is the last stage in the tikkun of a soul in bread, so the part baked first shows that Hashem is hurrying its tikkun; that is why the bracha is made there, and why Menashe of malchus Beis David taught it.
What the Rav says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People Balak, Boaz, Dovid HaMelech, Eglon, king of Moav, Elimelech (husband of Naomi), Er, Kilyon, Lot, Machlon, Menashe, Naomi, Onan, Rachel Imeinu, Rashi, Rav Ashi, Rus, Tamar, the Baal Shem Tov, the Ohr HaChaim HaKadosh, the Rambam, Yehudah (son of Yaakov)
Terms המוציא, יבום, יובל, כסא הכבוד, מלכות בית דוד, ספירה, עבד עברי, תיקון