סעודת פורים קטן
Catalog entry: זמנים פורים קטן no. 9 Pocket Guide p. 22 תשע"א (2010–11) Yiddish 36 min
Listen
About this shiur
On Purim Katan the Rav explains, following the Chasam Sofer, that the joy of Purim stands on its own, and shows through the image of the Megillah as a kallah why that joy can join the joy of a chasan and kallah.
The opening of the recording is lost. When the speech becomes clear, the Rav brings the Chasam Sofer: rejoicing over a miracle, like the song sung over the redemption of Pesach, is itself an obligation, but the Torah gives no details, so the Sages set the seudah, matanos la'evyonim and mishloach manos. The joy itself, he says, is the deeper layer, and the Chasam Sofer holds that the seudah is not the only way to fulfill it. This, he explains, is the reason of the Yerushalmi that a Purim seudah falling on Shabbos is moved to Sunday: two joys are not mixed. That raises a question about joining a wedding's joy with Purim. The Rav answers with the passuk that Hashem does not reject Israel even in exile, the mashal of a king who goes to his kallah even in a disgraceful place, and Rashi's teaching that the twenty-four books are like a kallah's adornments. Megillas Esther became a kallah, so its joy is a kallah's joy, and there is no contradiction. He closes with a brachah for Yerushalayim.
Topics: Purim · Purim Katan and the Leap Year · Megillas Esther
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Untranscribed opening (Unclear audio)
-
17:23 The Chasam Sofer: the joy of Purim listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Chasam Sofer that rejoicing over the miracle is itself an obligation, while the Sages set the seudah, gifts and mishloach manos as its details. He explains with this the Yerushalmi that a Purim seudah falling on Shabbos is moved to Sunday, since two joys are not mixed.
-
21:20 The Megillah as a kallah listed in the guide
The Rav asks how, given the Yerushalmi, a wedding's joy can be joined with Purim. He answers with the passuk that Hashem does not reject Israel even in exile, the mashal of a king going to his kallah in a disgraceful place, and Rashi's teaching on the twenty-four adornments of a kallah: Megillas Esther became a kallah, so there is no contradiction. He ends with a brachah for Yerushalayim.
The shiur, written up
The Chasam Sofer: the joy of Purim
The Rav brings the Chasam Sofer: just as song is sung over the redemption of Pesach, there is an obligation to rejoice over a miracle, but the Torah gives no details. The Sages therefore set the seudah, gifts to the poor and mishloach manos, while the joy itself is the deeper obligation. This, the Rav explains, is the reason of the Yerushalmi that a Purim seudah falling on Shabbos is made on Sunday: two joys are not mixed together. a,b
The Megillah as a kallah
According to this Yerushalmi, the Rav notes, it would seem that the joy of Purim cannot be joined with the joy of a wedding. In a sense, he says, the question does not apply. He brings the passuk in Vayikra that even in the land of their enemies Hashem did not reject or despise Israel, and explains it with a mashal: a king's kallah is found in a disgraceful place, yet it is no disgrace for the king to go to her, since she is his kallah. So too the joy of Purim is that Hashem is with Esther and the Jewish people even in their lowest state. c
He then brings Rashi, that a talmid chacham must be expert in the twenty-four books just as a kallah wears twenty-four adornments. Each of these books is a kallah, and Megillas Esther, when it became one of them, became a kallah. The joy of Purim, a joy with the Jewish people in all their situations, is therefore the joy of a kallah, so there is no contradiction in joining a sheva brachos with it. He closes with a brachah to celebrate in rebuilt Yerushalayim with all Jews together. d
Sources
Torah
Talmud Yerushalmi
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 17:23 Following the Chasam Sofer, the Rav explains that the joy over the Purim miracle is an obligation in its own right, while the Sages only set its details: the seudah, gifts to the poor and mishloach manos.
- 20:55 The Rav says this is the reason of the Yerushalmi that a Purim seudah falling on Shabbos is made on Sunday: two joys may not be mixed together.
- 23:46 Each of the twenty-four books is a kallah, and Megillas Esther, once it became one of them, became a kallah; the joy of the Megillah is the joy of a kallah.
- 22:24 The joy of Purim is a joy with the Jewish people in all their situations, even the lowest, and that is its connection to the joy of a kallah.
Questions and answers
Insights
- 18:54 Following the Chasam Sofer, the Rav separates the joy of Purim, which is the core obligation of remembering the miracle, from the seudah and gifts, which the Sages only added as its form.
- 20:55 The Rav reads the Yerushalmi's moving of a Shabbos Purim seudah to Sunday as proof that the joy of Purim is a distinct joy that may not be mixed with another.
- 23:46 Joining Rashi's comparison of the twenty-four books to a kallah's adornments with the Megillah, the Rav says Megillas Esther itself became a kallah, so the joy of the Megillah is a kallah's joy.
- 22:24 With the mashal of a king whose kallah is found in a disgraceful place, the Rav explains that it is no disgrace for the king to go to her, since she is his kallah; so the joy of Purim is Hashem's closeness to the Jewish people even in their lowest state.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Esther HaMalkah, Rashi, the Chasam Sofer
Terms זכר לנס, משלוח מנות, משתה ושמחה, מתנות לאביונים, פורים קטן, שבע ברכות