תש"ס - אפשר כשיבא משיח יהיה פורים באדר ראשון

Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת פורים קטן no. ⁨7⁩ Pocket Guide p. 22 תש"ס (1999–2000) Yiddish 30 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 30 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains, following the Chasam Sofer, that placing Purim next to Nissan is a segulah for salvation needed in galus, and suggests that when Moshiach comes Purim of a leap year may move to Adar Rishon, the month that repairs the diminished moon.

The Rav opens with the Yerushalmi that Adar Rishon is an addition and Adar Sheni the main month, and then brings the Gemara's dispute over which Adar of a leap year holds Purim: Rabbi Eliezer the son of Rabbi Yosi argues from 'one does not pass over mitzvos', Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel from joining redemption to redemption. He asks what lies behind the second reason, which Rashi gives no verse for. From the Chasam Sofer's account of how Haman and the Sanhedrin calculated the year, he concludes that joining the redemptions is a segulah for salvation, not a halacha. In galus Jews need that segulah like bread; when Moshiach comes it will no longer be needed, so Purim may then fall in Adar Rishon. He explains the name Purim Katan through the small luminary and the moon's diminution, which Adar Rishon repairs, and closes with the humility of Shaul, Mordechai and Esther.

Topics: Purim Katan and the Leap Year · Moshiach and the Days of Moshiach

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Which Adar holds Purim in a leap year

    The Rav cites the Yerushalmi that Adar Rishon is an addition, then sets out the Gemara's dispute between Rabbi Eliezer the son of Rabbi Yosi (one does not pass over mitzvos) and Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel (join redemption to redemption). He asks what the root of the second reason is, that it can override the first.

  2. 7:10 The Chasam Sofer: Haman's calculation

    The Rav brings the Chasam Sofer's derush: Haman picked a year that should have been a leap year so his Adar would be far from Nissan, and the Sanhedrin countered by making it a plain year. From this he proves that joining redemption to redemption is a segulah, which the Sages kept because the days are remembered and re-enacted.

  3. 11:55 When Moshiach comes: Purim in Adar Rishon listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that in galus Jews need Purim's salvation like bread, against the power of Achashverosh, through the power of Mordechai and against Haman. When Moshiach comes it will only be a remembrance, so only the reason of not passing over mitzvos remains, and he suggests Purim of a leap year will then be in Adar Rishon.

  4. 15:11 Purim Katan and the diminished moon

    The Rav asks why the day is called Purim Katan and not Purim Rishon, and answers that Adar Rishon repairs the moon's diminution, the root of a chain of jealousies through history. Esther is the moon, and he ends with a brachah that in the merit of Purim Katan every Jew should long to reconcile with Hashem.

  5. 21:13 Untranscribed stretch (Unclear audio)

  6. 25:32 Lowliness brings kingship and redemption

    The Rav explains that one who has lowliness in himself merits kingship: Binyamin, Shaul, who did not reveal his kingship, and Mordechai, of whom it is said that Hashem stands at the right of the poor. Esther, like the moon, had nothing of her own, and the redemption came through people of true humility, upon whom Hashem looks.

The shiur, written up

Which Adar holds Purim in a leap year

0:00

The Rav opens with the Yerushalmi that Adar Rishon is the month of addition and Adar Sheni the main one. He then brings the Gemara's dispute: Rabbi Eliezer the son of Rabbi Yosi holds that just as Adar is always next to Shevat, so in a leap year Purim belongs in the first Adar, because one does not pass over mitzvos. Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel holds that, as always, it must be next to Nissan, to join the redemption of Adar to that of Nissan, and the practice follows him. a,b

5:40

The Rav sharpens the difficulty. Rashi brings a verse for not passing over mitzvos, and keeping Purim itself is a kal vachomer from leaving Egypt: if one sings for slavery to freedom, surely for death to life. For joining redemption to redemption Rashi brings no verse, so the Rav asks what its root is, that it can override a Torah reason. c,d

The Chasam Sofer: Haman's calculation

7:48

To answer, the Rav brings a derush of the Chasam Sofer. Haman chose for his decree a year that by calculation should have been a leap year, so that his Adar would not be near Nissan, fearing the Jews would otherwise be helped. The Sanhedrin saw this and made it a plain year, so the decree fell in an Adar next to Nissan; the next year was made a leap year, and Purim was fixed next to Nissan. e

10:30

From this the Rav concludes that joining redemption to redemption is neither a Torah nor a rabbinic law: Haman surely had no such law in mind. It is a segulah, that an Adar next to Nissan brings Jews salvation, and since the days are remembered and re-enacted, the Sages fixed Purim there. f

When Moshiach comes: Purim in Adar Rishon

12:03

Therefore, the Rav explains, in galus Jews need Purim like bread: every year they need miracles, the power of Achashverosh turned to good decrees, the power of Mordechai raised up, and Haman's power brought down. When Moshiach comes this will no longer be needed and Purim will only be a remembrance. Then only Rabbi Eliezer the son of Rabbi Yosi's reason remains, and the Rav suggests that in a leap year Purim will be in Adar Rishon. Both views, he adds, are the words of the living G-d. g

Purim Katan and the diminished moon

15:11

The Rav asks why the day is called Purim Katan, when Pesach has Pesach Rishon and Pesach Sheni. He answers that Adar Rishon belongs to the small luminary and fills in the moon's diminution. That diminution began a chain of jealousy: the brothers against Yosef, the spies, the kingdom of David against that of Yosef. Each year the moon, Kenesses Yisrael, runs after the sun and seeks to reconcile, and in Adar Rishon it reaches a great love and unity with Hashem. h

18:03

Esther, the Gemara says, is the moon, and her counsel to gather all the Jews was the way to fill the diminution. Purim Katan is thus a preparation: at the seudos one should ask the Ribono shel Olam to reconcile. He blesses that every Jew gain that longing, bringing great salvation. i,j

Lowliness brings kingship and redemption

25:53

The Rav explains that one who has lowliness in himself merits kingship. Binyamin had it, and Shaul, already anointed, did not reveal the kingship, seeing himself as nothing; from his merit came Mordechai, who had the same lowliness. Of such a person it says Hashem stands at the right of the poor. k,l

27:13

Esther, like the moon, had nothing of her own; the Midrash links her being an orphan to the verse 'we were orphans'. The redemption came through people of true lowliness, and Hashem looks upon the lowly. m,n,p,q

Sources

Nevi'im

  1. k Shmuel I 10:16 text index In the write-up: 25:53

Kesuvim

  1. f Esther 9:28 text index In the write-up: 10:30
  2. h apparently Tehillim 84:12 index In the write-up: 15:11
  3. j apparently Esther 4:16 index In the write-up: 18:03
  4. l Tehillim 109:31 text index In the write-up: 25:53
  5. o Eichah 5:3 27:40 text index
  6. p Esther 2:7 text index In the write-up: 27:13
  7. q apparently Tehillim 138:6 index In the write-up: 27:13

Talmud Bavli

  1. b Megillah 6b text index In the write-up: 0:00
  2. d apparently Megillah 14a index In the write-up: 5:40
  3. g Eruvin 13b text index In the write-up: 12:03
  4. i Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 18:03

Talmud Yerushalmi

  1. a Yerushalmi (place not identified) index In the write-up: 0:00

Midrash

  1. n Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 27:13

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. m Zohar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 27:13

Rishonim

  1. c apparently Rashi on Megillah 6b index In the write-up: 5:40

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. e Chasam Sofer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 7:48

Key points

  1. 3:47 Rabbi Eliezer the son of Rabbi Yosi places Purim of a leap year in the first Adar because one does not pass over mitzvos; Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel places it in the second to join the redemption of Adar to that of Nissan, and the practice follows him.
  2. 10:30 From the Chasam Sofer's account of Haman's calculation the Rav concludes that joining redemption to redemption is a segulah for salvation, neither a Torah law nor a rabbinic one.
  3. 12:03 In galus Jews need Purim's power of salvation like bread, so the Sages fixed it in the second Adar; when Moshiach comes that need falls away and Purim may move to Adar Rishon.
  4. 15:11 The name Purim Katan points to the small luminary: Adar Rishon is the month that fills in the moon's diminution and reconciles Kenesses Yisrael with Hashem.
  5. 25:53 Humility brings kingship and salvation: Binyamin, Shaul and Mordechai had lowliness in themselves, and Esther, like the moon, had nothing of her own.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 6:45 Rabbi Eliezer the son of Rabbi Yosi's reason, not passing over mitzvos, is from the Torah; what is the root of joining redemption to redemption, for which Rashi brings no verse, that it can override it?

    Answer: 10:30 From the Chasam Sofer's account of Haman's calculation, it is a segulah for salvation rather than a law.

  2. Question: 13:29 Why might Purim of a leap year be in Adar Rishon when Moshiach comes?

    Answer: 13:45 Then Jews will not need Purim's power of salvation, it will only be a remembrance, so only the reason of not passing over mitzvos remains.

  3. Question: 15:11 Why is it called Purim Katan and not Purim Rishon, as there is Pesach Rishon and Pesach Sheni?

    Answer: 15:32 Because Adar Rishon belongs to the small luminary and fills in the moon's diminution.

Insights

  1. 10:30 The Rav reads the Chasam Sofer's account as proof that joining redemption to redemption is not a law at all: Haman, who knew the calendar, was not concerned with a Torah or rabbinic law, only with keeping salvation away, so it must be a segulah.
  2. 13:32 Because the second Adar was chosen only for the salvation Jews need in galus, the Rav suggests that in the days of Moshiach, when Purim is only a remembrance, the reason of not passing over mitzvos will prevail and Purim of a leap year will be in Adar Rishon.
  3. 15:11 The day is called Purim Katan, not Purim Rishon like Pesach Rishon, because Adar Rishon belongs to the small luminary, the moon, and is the month that fills in its diminution.
  4. 15:52 The Rav traces a chain of jealousy from the moon's diminution: the brothers against Yosef, the spies, and the rivalry of the kingdom of the House of David with that of Yosef, all of which Moshiach will heal.
  5. 18:03 Esther is the moon, and since the whole Purim story grows out of the moon's diminution, her counsel to gather all the Jews was the way to fill it in.
  6. 26:06 Shaul's merit of hiding his kingship, out of lowliness, is what brought forth Mordechai, who had the same lowliness; to such a person Hashem stands at his right hand.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 18:48 The Rav says that at the Purim Katan seudos one should say to the Ribono shel Olam that we want to make peace and reconcile with Him.
  2. 26:59 The Rav says one should ask Hashem to feel that one has nothing of one's own.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Achashverosh, Binyamin, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Rabban Shimon ben Gamliel, Rabbi Eliezer ben Rabbi Yossi, Rashi, Shaul HaMelech, the Chasam Sofer, Yosef HaTzaddik

Terms אדר, זכר לנס, כנסת ישראל, מאור הקטן, מיעוט הירח, סגולה, פורים קטן, שנה מעוברת, שפלות

Report an error on this page