יכולים למצוא השי"ת בחודש אדר ובכל מאורעות הזמן
Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת פורים קטן no. 1 Pocket Guide p. 21 תש"ל (1969–70) Yiddish 1 hr 21 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that Adar is the 'heel' of time, a month of garments and hiddenness, and that its avodah is to find Hashem's name hidden in the events of the world, as in the Megillah, and to laugh at the costumes of history.
The Rav begins with the Tanya's question: if every Jewish soul is truly G-dly, how can Moshe Rabbeinu's generation be the 'head' and the final generations the 'heels'? He answers that the inner point is the same in all; only the garments differ. Since soul, time and place parallel each other, time too has a head, Nisan, the month of open miracles, and heels, Adar, the month of garments. The last generations, like the Torah's last parshiyos, live in hester within hester. The avodah of Adar is to find Hashem's name in the 'megillah' of world events, to know that 'the King' is Hashem, and to laugh at the costumes. He develops this through Yaakov's descent to Egypt, Mordechai and David sparing Shimi, rulers as puppets, the Maharal on the speed of the Purim miracle and Naftali's swiftness, ending with simcha within hester.
Topics: Chodesh Adar · Hester Panim and Suffering · Megillas Esther · Hashgacha Pratis · Purim Katan and the Leap Year
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The generations as one body: head and heels
After a brief, garbled opening, the Rav describes the generations as one body, with Moshe Rabbeinu's generation the head and the generations before Moshiach the heels. He raises the Tanya's question of how souls that are truly G-dly can differ in level, and reads its answer of the son drawn from the father's mind.
-
6:00 Same inner point, different garments
The Rav answers that the inner point of every Jew is the same in the head as in the heels; the difference is only how much physicality covers it. Like a fetus that needs nine months to form, Moshe Rabbeinu's soul came with few garments and the souls before Moshiach with many.
-
9:13 Nisan the head of time, Adar its heels listed in the guide
Since place, time and soul parallel each other, the Rav shows that time too has a head, Nisan, 'rosh chodashim', and heels, Adar, the month furthest from Nisan. Nisan, from 'nes', is a month of open miracles, while Adar, from 'aderes', a cloak, is wrapped in garments.
-
14:03 The last generations and the Torah's last parshiyos listed in the guide
The Rav compares the souls of the heels to the Torah's order: Bereishis corresponds to Moshe Rabbeinu, and today's souls to the last parshiyos, where there is no one to ask and Hashem says He will hide His face. In the heels there is a hester within hester, which the Ba'al Shem Tov spoke of.
-
18:03 Adar, Adar Sheini and Megillas Esther listed in the guide
The Rav calls Adar a month of garments in which Hashem appears hidden. When the hester seems to end, a second Adar begins, hester upon hester. He brings the Kozhnitzer Maggid on the name 'Megillas Esther' and notes that Jews make a brachah on the miracles of a Megillah that seems to tell only ordinary events and never names Hashem.
-
22:25 Costumes, 'the King', and the hidden Name listed in the guide
The Rav explains that all the events of the Megillah are miracles clothed in nature, and that the custom of dressing up teaches that garments mean nothing: Chazal say 'the King' in the Megillah means Hashem. From Purim one leaves knowing that the hidden guidance is also His, and the mekubalim found His name in the Megillah's roshei teivos at its turning points.
-
26:20 Searching for Hashem in the world, and laughing listed in the guide
The Rav says the avodah of Adar is to find Hashem's name in the 'megillah' of the world, where He peers through the cracks. A child is frightened by a man dressed as Haman, but one who sees Hashem's name laughs. Adar's organ is the spleen, the source of laughter, so its avodah is to laugh at the newspapers and commentators and to know that 'the King' is Hashem.
-
32:21 The claim against Europe's rabbis, and Yaakov's descent to Egypt listed in the guide
The Rav takes up the claim that the rabbis and rebbes of Europe erred by not urging Jews toward Eretz Yisrael before the war. He answers from Yaakov Avinu: his going down to Egypt could look like a mistake, but it was a decree from Hashem, and Chazal say he would otherwise have been brought in iron chains. Instead of complaining 'my way is hidden', one should look through the cracks of the hester.
-
40:52 Achashverosh's feast and the complaints against Mordechai listed in the guide
The Rav describes the Megillah's story unfolding over years. Mordechai cried out not to go to Achashverosh's feast, though everything there was kosher, yet many Jews went; later he refused to bow to Haman, and Jews blamed him for the decree.
-
46:49 Ish Yehudi and Ish Yemini: David and Shimi listed in the guide
The Rav asks who really caused the decree and brings the Gemara on 'ish Yehudi … ish Yemini': Knesses Yisrael complains that David did not kill Shimi, from whom Mordechai descended. At the end of the Megillah it became clear that David's mercy was the cause of the rescue, because David saw Hashem's name even in Shimi's curse, and measure for measure he brought forth Mordechai, who revealed the hester.
-
53:20 Rulers as puppets and the 'Jewish question' listed in the guide
The Rav says rulers are marionettes on strings from above, so it makes no difference who sits in the White House; it depends on the King. He notes that the whole world revolves around the Jews, that a progressive nation followed a leader set on 'solving the Jewish question', and tells of an old Jew angered at having to wait six hours after meat, explaining that the very existence of Jews proclaims morality and arouses hatred.
-
1:02:06 Hiding until the wrath passes; the Maharal on speed listed in the guide
The Rav says the answer to the 'Jewish question' is 'chavi kim'at rega': go into your rooms, take your Gemara and Mishnayos and hide until the wrath passes, as Esther hid her origins. He then asks where the miracles of the Megillah are and brings the Maharal that they lie in the speed of the events, a sign of Hashem's hand, which he sees in his own times too.
-
1:08:04 Naftali, the swift tribe of Adar listed in the guide
The Rav links Adar to the tribe of Naftali, whom Yaakov blessed as 'ayalah sheluchah', not for a particular quality but for swiftness, and brings Chazal's account of Naftali running to bring the deed. When Jews are low and Amalek high, things happen with Naftali's speed, and so even amid distress one must learn to laugh and be b'simcha.
-
1:13:26 Simcha within hester, and Adar leading to Nisan listed in the guide
The Rav warns against losing hope when the redemption seems delayed, and says the joy of Purim comes from seeing Hashem's name, so it can exist even within hester; in simcha alone one may go to extremes. He closes by joining Adar to Nisan, 'to join redemption to redemption'.
The shiur, written up
The generations as one body: head and heels
The Rav describes all the generations of Jewish history as one body. The world was made in the form of a complete man, so the generations too have a head and limbs down to the heels: Moshe Rabbeinu's generation is the head, the mind; later came the heart, the level of David HaMelech and Shlomo with the Beis HaMikdash; and the generations before Moshiach are the heels.
Same inner point, different garments
The Rav concludes that the inner point of every Jew is the same in the greatest souls as in the smallest, in the head as in the heels. Just as a fetus needs nine months to become complete, Moshe Rabbeinu's soul came with few garments, while the souls before Moshiach come wrapped in many; the inner point stays the same.
Nisan the head of time, Adar its heels
The Rav brings Sefer Yetzirah's teaching that place, time and soul parallel each other, so time too has a head and heels. Nisan is the head, as the passuk says, 'this month shall be for you the head of months'; Adar, the month furthest from Nisan, is the heels of time. c,b
Nisan, from the word 'nes', is a month of open miracles, when G-dliness is seen without the cloak of nature. Adar, from 'aderes', a cloak, is wrapped in garments; in its heart it holds the same G-dliness as Nisan.
The last generations and the Torah's last parshiyos
The same holds for the Torah: its beginning, Bereishis, corresponds to Moshe Rabbeinu, who is called 'reishis', while today's souls correspond to its last parshiyos, a time when there is no one to ask, as Chazal describe the heels of Moshiach. There the passuk says Hashem will hide His face, and in the heels there is a hester within a hester, which the Ba'al Shem Tov spoke of. e,d
Adar, Adar Sheini and Megillas Esther
Adar is a month of garments, in which Hashem appears in disguise. Jews in exile have learned to wait, but at times it seems everything is covered, and just when Adar seems over, a second Adar begins: hester upon hester.
The Rav cites the Kozhnitzer Maggid on the name 'Megillas Esther'. The Megillah tells only ordinary events and never names Hashem, yet Jews make the brachah 'she'asah nissim' over it, believing He is hidden within it.
Costumes, 'the King', and the hidden Name
Everything in the Megillah, the Rav says, is a miracle clothed in nature, and the custom of dressing up teaches that garments mean nothing. Chazal say that 'the King' in the Megillah means Hashem; a Jew is not fooled by someone dressed as Haman or Achashverosh.
Searching for Hashem in the world, and laughing
The avodah of Adar is to search for Hashem's name in the Megillah and in the world. Haman's existence creates a state in which Hashem 'peers through the windows', and one must find Him in history and current events, where people keep judging what is good or bad for Jews. h
A child is terrified of a man in red trousers with a sword dressed as Haman; one who finds Hashem's name in the world's Megillah laughs. Each month has an organ, and Adar's is the spleen, which the Gemara says laughs. The avodah of Adar, the Rav says, is to laugh at the newspapers and commentators, and to know that 'the King' means Hashem. i
The claim against Europe's rabbis, and Yaakov's descent
The Rav takes up a claim he heard: that the rabbis and rebbes of Europe erred by not urging their followers to go to Eretz Yisrael before the war, when the Zionists dominated. He recalls asking about this at the time.
He answers from Yaakov Avinu. Yaakov went down to Egypt because of Yosef, and when the bondage came one could say he had made a bitter mistake by leaving the promised land. Yet Chazal say that had he not gone, he would have been brought in iron chains; it was a decree already from the time of Avraham. k
The passuk rebukes Yaakov for saying 'my way is hidden from Hashem': what is there to complain about, when Hashem has prepared everything? When Yaakov met Yosef he saw the whole plan. So too, instead of complaining, one should look between the cracks of the hester and catch a glimpse of Hashem Himself. l
Achashverosh's feast and the complaints against Mordechai
The Megillah's story stretched over nine years, and its first event was Achashverosh's feast. Everything there was kosher, the Rav notes with humor, with fine wine and a proper hechsher, yet Mordechai cried out not to go, and Chazal say eighteen thousand Jews went anyway.
Later Haman ordered everyone to bow and Mordechai refused. The sensible people told him he was ruining relations with the authorities, and Jews blamed him for the whole decree.
Ish Yehudi and Ish Yemini: David and Shimi
Who caused the decree, asks the Rav: the Jews who ignored Mordechai, or Mordechai who defied Haman? He brings the passuk 'ish Yehudi ... ish Yemini'. Mordechai was from Binyamin, yet is called Yehudi because of David HaMelech: David's servants wanted to kill Shimi, David refused, and from Shimi came Mordechai. m
Rulers as puppets and the 'Jewish question'
The rulers of the world, the Rav says, are marionettes tied with strings from above. Jews should not persuade themselves that if a certain man rises things will be good; it makes no difference who sits in the White House or whether Golda Meir is in power. It depends on the King, Hashem.
All of history revolves around the Jews, even in secret cabinets. One of the most progressive nations raised a man whose ambition was to solve the Jewish question, and a whole civilized country followed him.
The Rav tells of an old Jew who, after eating meat, wanted a coffee and grew angry at having to wait six hours. The anger came from his desire, for the Jew's very existence demands setting desires aside. So too the Jews' existence proclaims morality, and this arouses the nations' hatred.
Hiding until the wrath passes; the Maharal on speed
The answer to the Jewish question, the Rav says, is Hashem's call to hide 'for a moment until the wrath passes': go into your rooms, take your Gemara and Mishnayos. So Esther hid her origins. p,q
Where are the miracles of the Megillah? The Maharal says they lie in the speed of the events, one after another. What comes directly from Hashem happens quickly, and in his own day, too, the Rav sees great things happening one after another, things that once took hundreds of years.
Naftali, the swift tribe of Adar
Each month corresponds to a tribe, and Adar to Naftali, whom Yaakov blessed as 'ayalah sheluchah', a swift hind. Chazal tell that Naftali ran to bring the deed in the dispute with Esav. Yaakov blessed him not for a quality but because he is fast. r,s
When Jews are low and Amalek is high, things happen with Naftali's speed. Since things change quickly, the Rav says, one must learn to laugh and to be b'simcha even amid distress.
Simcha within hester, and Adar leading to Nisan
When the redemption seems delayed, Jews can lose hope and their bond with Hashem. The Rav says not to lose it but to hope for the geulah.
The joy of Purim does not come from what one possesses, but from seeing Hashem's name; therefore it can exist even in hester. The Rav says that in simcha alone one may be extreme.
Sources
Torah
Nevi'im
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
- e apparently Sotah 49b index In the write-up: 15:19
- i apparently Berachos 61b index In the write-up: 29:09
- k apparently Shabbos 89b index In the write-up: 35:42
- n apparently Megillah 12b-13a index In the write-up: 49:48
- s apparently Sotah 13a index In the write-up: 1:08:36
- t apparently Megillah 6b index In the write-up: 1:19:57
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 6:10 All Jewish souls are truly G-dly; the difference between the great early generations and the last ones lies only in how many garments cover the same inner point.
- 10:20 Like the soul, time has a head and heels: Nisan, the month of revealed miracles, is the head, and Adar, the furthest point from Nisan, is the heels, a month of garments.
- 26:20 The avodah of Adar is to search for Hashem's name in the world's events, in the news and in one's own experiences, just as the mekubalim found His name hidden in the Megillah.
- 29:23 One who knows that 'the King' means Hashem is not frightened by the costumes of history but laughs at them, and laughter is the trait of Adar.
- 54:00 The rulers of the world are like puppets moved by strings from above; what matters is not who sits in power but the King, Hashem.
- 1:05:24 Events that happen with great speed are a sign of Hashem's hand, as the Maharal says of the Purim miracle, and Adar, the month of Naftali, is a swift month.
- 1:16:04 The joy of Purim comes not from what one has but from seeing Hashem's name, so one can be b'simcha even within hester.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 4:42 If all Jewish souls are truly G-dly, how can some be the 'head' and others the 'heels'?
Answer: 6:10 The inner point is identical in all of them; the difference is only in how many garments of physicality cover it.
-
Question: 33:04 Did the rabbis and rebbes of Europe err by not urging Jews to leave for Eretz Yisrael before the war?
Answer: 36:42 As with Yaakov's descent to Egypt, which also looked like a mistake but was Hashem's decree, one should not complain but look for Hashem behind the hester.
-
Question: 49:48 Did David's sparing of Shimi cause the decree of Haman?
Answer: 51:20 At the end of the Megillah it became clear that it caused the rescue, since Mordechai descended from Shimi.
-
Question: 1:04:59 Where are the miracles in the Megillah, if everything there looks natural?
Answer: 1:05:24 According to the Maharal, the miracle lies in the speed with which the events followed one another.
-
Question: 1:01:41 What is the way to deal with the 'Jewish question'?
Answer: 1:01:51 Not through diplomacy, but by hiding 'for a moment until the wrath passes': going into one's rooms with Gemara and Mishnayos.
Stories
-
58:13 The old Jew who had to wait six hours
The Rav tells of an old Jew who had eaten meat and then wanted to drink a coffee. When he was told he must wait six hours, he grew angry. The Rav explains that the anger came from his desire: the very existence of the Jew demands that a person set aside his desires, and that is what he could not bear.
-
1:08:57 Naftali runs for the deed
The Rav brings Chazal's account that when a dispute arose with Esav over the burial place, a deed was needed from Egypt, and Naftali, the swift one, was sent to bring it.
In the story: Naftali, Yaakov Avinu, Esav
Insights
- 10:20 The Rav parallels soul and time: just as the souls before Moshiach are the 'heels' of the generations, Adar, the month furthest from Nisan, is the 'heels' of the year, with the same inner G-dliness under more garments.
- 20:07 Adar Sheini is read as hester upon hester: just when it seems Adar is over and Nisan has come, another Adar begins.
- 23:09 The custom of dressing up on Purim teaches that garments mean nothing: a Jew is not fooled by someone dressed as Haman or Achashverosh, for behind everything stands Hashem.
- 51:20 David's sparing of Shimi, which seemed to cause the decree, was really the root of the rescue: because David saw Hashem's name even in Shimi's curse, measure for measure Mordechai descended from Shimi and revealed that Haman is nothing.
- 59:54 The very existence of the Jewish people proclaims morality, and this, the Rav says, is what arouses the nations' hatred.
- 1:09:37 Yaakov blessed Naftali not with a virtue but with swiftness; Adar is Naftali's month, so in Adar things change quickly, and speed itself is a sign of Hashem's hand.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 24:47 The Rav says that from Purim one must take away the knowledge that the guidance in which Hashem is not seen is also His.
- 30:49 The Rav says the avodah of Adar is to find Hashem in the world, in current events and in one's personal experiences.
- 30:20 The Rav says one should laugh at the world, at the newspapers and at the commentators.
- 1:17:51 The Rav says one may be extreme in one thing only, in simcha.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achashverosh, Dovid HaMelech, Esav, Esther HaMalkah, Golda Meir, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Moshe Rabbeinu, Naftali, Rabbi Yaakov Emden (the Yaavetz), Shimi ben Gera, the Baal Shem Tov, the Kozhnitzer Maggid (Rabbi Yisrael of Kozhnitz), the Maharal of Prague, Yaakov Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אדר, אלקות ממש, הסתר, לבושים, נקודה הפנימית, עולם שנה נפש, עקבתא דמשיחא, רבונו של עולם