שושן פורים הוא תחילת וסוף נס של מגילה

Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת שושן פורים no. ⁨3⁩ Pocket Guide p. 25 תשס"ג (2002–03) Yiddish 54 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 54 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav shows that the miracle of the Megillah begins and ends on Shushan Purim, and that the mitzvos of Purim are the Jews' weapon against Yishmael in the last stage of exile.

The Rav opens with two stories of tzaddikim whose Purim joy brought salvation: the Lubavitcher Rebbe's farbrengen before Stalin's fall, and Rabbi Elazar of Amsterdam during a flood. He then brings the Ya'aros Devash that Vashti was killed on the night of Pesach, the yahrzeit of her father Belshazzar, and the Chasam Sofer that the Beis Hamikdash could be rebuilt right after the war on Amalek on erev Pesach. This explains why Shaul counted the people with Pesach lambs, and, with the Ruzhiner's words, why Shaul spared Agag and what Shmuel cried about all night. The kings timed their feasts for after Pesach, but the wise men told Achashverosh that the day was in fact Shushan Purim, so the Megillah opens and closes with Shushan Purim. From 'vaya'avor Mordechai' and the Akeidah he teaches that mesiras nefesh crosses the Satan's barriers, and closes that the Purim mitzvos defeat Yishmael today.

Topics: Shushan Purim · Megillas Esther · Avodah of the Last Generation

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 The Purim farbrengen before Stalin's fall Story

    The Rav tells how, fifty years earlier, while Stalin was plotting against the Jews, the Lubavitcher Rebbe at a Purim seudah told a story of an old chassid who shouted 'hurrah' three times at an election, and shouted it with the crowd. Two days later Stalin was announced ill, and he soon died.

  2. 5:55 Rabbi Elazar of Amsterdam and the broken dike Story

    The Rav tells how the queen of Holland sent to Rabbi Elazar of Amsterdam when a dike broke, and was saved; coming to thank him she found him drinking and singing, and he told her that on Purim drinking does more than a year of Tehillim. He then speaks of the present seudah of Shushan Purim and the need for great salvations.

  3. 9:43 Vashti and her father's yahrzeit on Pesach

    The Rav brings the Ya'aros Devash that Achashverosh's feast fell on Pesach and that Vashti had an excuse: it was the yahrzeit of her father Belshazzar, killed on Pesach night, and whether it was a leap year decided the matter. The proof is from the piyut of the Haggadah, and the Rav asks how the paytan knew it.

  4. 13:45 Why wait for Pesach: the Chasam Sofer

    Since kings counted their years from Tishrei, the Rav asks why the feast celebrating that the Beis Hamikdash would not be rebuilt was held after Pesach. He brings Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakai's decree that the whole day of the omer waving is forbidden for new grain, and the Chasam Sofer's explanation: the war on Amalek will be on erev Pesach, and right after it the Beis Hamikdash can be built.

  5. 19:34 Shaul's war on Amalek and the Pesach lambs

    With the Chasam Sofer the Rav explains the haftarah of Parshas Zachor: Shaul counted the people with lambs, which the Targum Yonasan says were the Pesach lambs, since the war was on erev Pesach. Leaving Agag alive while the war was still going on was not yet a sin, but once erev Pesach ended the time for wiping out Amalek had passed, and Shmuel cried to Hashem all night.

  6. 24:17 The Ruzhiner on Shaul and Agag

    The Rav brings the Ruzhiner's answer to the Chiddushei HaRim: Shaul left Agag alive one night so that Haman would be born, the Jews would have Purim and accept the Torah anew; but a king may not bring his people into danger. The Rav adds that Shmuel's night of crying was a tefillah that Shaul's plan should succeed.

  7. 28:03 Shushan Purim opens and closes the Megillah listed in the guide

    Belshazzar and Achashverosh both counted from Tishrei but held their feasts after Pesach, knowing the Beis Hamikdash could only come after the war on Amalek on erev Pesach. When Vashti refused and Achashverosh asked whether it was her father's yahrzeit, the wise men answered that the day was not Pesach but Shushan Purim; the Megillah thus opens with Vashti's death on Shushan Purim and closes with Shushan Purim, and its first miracle, the end of Nebuchadnezzar's house, is its main one.

  8. 35:54 'Vaya'avor Mordechai' and the Akeidah

    The Rav asks why the Gemara stresses that Mordechai crossed water when he went to gather the Jews. He brings the Midrash that the Satan turned himself into a river to stop Avraham on the way to the Akeidah, and Avraham cried 'hoshi'eini Elokim'; the Akeidah answered Yishmael's boast about his milah, and Mordechai crossed the Satan's water the same way, making Purim for all generations.

  9. 42:27 Ikvesa deMeshicha and the wine of Purim

    Bringing the Chiddushei HaRim that Purim sustains the Jews in the trials before Moshiach, the Rav describes today's exile, with its politics, parties and elections, as a great 'water' meant to keep Jews from serving Hashem, and Esther's 'I have not been called' as the smallness of that time; the answer is tefillah with mesiras nefesh. He brings the Midrash that 'oil for the light' is Moshiach and explains that the Satan of Yishmael hates wine because his fall will come through the Jews' wine on Purim.

  10. 49:53 Esther's plea and the Purim 'breaking news'

    The Rav mentions a Slonimer custom of singing 'Vatosef Esther' and says this verse holds the whole strategy against Yishmael: to plead again and again, with more davening, learning and tzedakah. He closes with 'breaking news' that Yishmael has been struck down by the tzedakah, Megillah reading, wine and gifts of Jews everywhere, the final victory and end of exile, and asks for a niggun.

The shiur, written up

The Purim farbrengen before Stalin's fall

0:30

The Rav recalls the Purim of fifty years earlier, when Stalin had made a libel against the Jewish doctors of Moscow and prepared trains to send Jews to Siberia. At a Purim seudah the Lubavitcher Rebbe told of an old chassid in the Rebbe Rashab's time who knew nothing of politics, yet went to the mikvah, put on his gartel and voted as the Rebbe wished, and when the crowd shouted 'hurrah' for their candidate he shouted it three times with great kavanah.

4:19

The Lubavitcher Rebbe then shouted 'hurrah' three times with the whole crowd, and people whispered that he was bringing Stalin down. Two days later Stalin was announced ill, and soon after he died; the Rav says he remembers it.

Rabbi Elazar of Amsterdam and the broken dike

6:12

A second story: when a dike broke near Amsterdam, which lies below sea level, the queen sent to Rabbi Elazar to pray, and the city was saved. Coming to thank him, she expected to find him saying Tehillim, but found him and his students drinking and singing. He told her it was Purim, when drinking accomplishes more than a whole year of Tehillim. The Rav adds that now too great salvations are needed, and the Shushan Purim seudah with song is the time for them.

Vashti and her father's yahrzeit

10:30

The Rav brings the Ya'aros Devash that Achashverosh's feast fell on Pesach, which was the yahrzeit of Vashti's father Belshazzar, killed on Pesach night; this could excuse her refusal, and the matter turned on whether the year was a leap year. His proof is the line of the Haggadah's piyut that the one who drank from the holy vessels was killed that night. The Rav notes this is the only source, and asks how the paytan himself knew it. a,b

Why wait for Pesach: the Chasam Sofer

14:01

The Ya'aros Devash adds that the feast began in Tishrei, since the kings of the nations count their years from Tishrei, as the Gemara in Rosh Hashanah says. The Rav asks: if so, why was the feast celebrating that the Beis Hamikdash would not be rebuilt held only after Pesach? a,c

16:38

He answers with the Chasam Sofer on Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakai's decree that new grain is forbidden all day on the day of the omer waving, lest the Beis Hamikdash be rebuilt. The Rav calls the usual reading forced. The Chasam Sofer explains that the war on Amalek will be on erev Pesach, and since Israel was commanded to wipe out Amalek and then build the Beis Hamikdash, it could be built that same night; the concern is real every Pesach. e,f

Shaul's war and the Pesach lambs

19:54

This explains the haftarah of Parshas Zachor, where Shaul counted the people with lambs. The Targum Yonasan says these were the Pesach lambs: the war was on erev Pesach, and right after it they would offer the korban Pesach, so he counted how many could eat from one lamb. g,h

22:52

It also explains Agag: while the war was still going on, leaving him alive was not yet a failure. Once erev Pesach ended, the time for wiping out Amalek had passed, Hashem told Shmuel He regretted making Shaul king, and Shmuel cried out all night. i

The Ruzhiner on Shaul and Agag

24:21

The Chiddushei HaRim visited the Ruzhiner, who asked how Shaul could say 'I have fulfilled the word of Hashem.' He answered from the Midrash that Agag fathered a child that night, from whom Haman came; Shaul intended this so that the Jews would have Purim and accept the Torah anew. Asked what was wrong then, he said a king may not bring his people into danger. j,k,l

26:34

The Rav suggests this is why Shmuel cried all night: that Shaul's plan should succeed, and Haman come and bring Purim.

Shushan Purim opens and closes the Megillah

28:24

Returning to the kings, the Rav explains that Belshazzar, who erred in counting the seventy years as the Gemara says, also counted from Tishrei, yet made his party on Pesach. He knew the Beis Hamikdash could come only after the war on Amalek on the fourteenth of Nisan; when the first day of Pesach passed unchanged, he celebrated. d

31:47

Achashverosh calculated the same way, timing his feast's climax, the seventh day, for the first day of Pesach. When Vashti defied him he wondered whether it was her father's yahrzeit and asked the wise men. They answered that today is not Pesach but Shushan Purim.

33:30

So the Megillah opens with Vashti's death on Shushan Purim and closes with Haman's fall and Shushan Purim. Its first miracle, the end of Nebuchadnezzar's house, fulfils the verse about cutting off Babylon's name, and the Rav calls it the main miracle of the Megillah. y

'Vaya'avor Mordechai' and the Akeidah

36:11

Esther asked Mordechai to gather the Jews to fast. On 'vaya'avor Mordechai' the Gemara says he crossed water; the Rav asks why that matters. He brings the Midrash that the Satan became a river to stop Avraham on the way to the Akeidah; Avraham went in up to his neck and cried 'hoshi'eini Elokim', and the river vanished. m,n,o,p,q

38:26

The Satan fights what decides Israel's future. Rashi tells of Yishmael boasting that his milah was greater, and the Akeidah answered him. Mordechai faced the same 'water' and crossed it with the same cry, making a Purim for all generations. r

Ikvesa deMeshicha and the wine of Purim

42:27

Bringing the Chiddushei HaRim that Purim sustains Jews in the trials before Moshiach, the Rav calls today's exile, with its politics, parties and elections, a great 'water' meant to keep Jews from serving Hashem. The Ruzhiner said serving Hashem then would be like climbing a smooth wall. Mordechai's mesiras nefesh gives erliche Jews strength to fight for emunah.

44:55

Esther's 'I have not been called these thirty days' reflects the smallness of that time; the next verse is 'vaya'avor Mordechai', tefillah. One stands to daven with a dulled mind and hardened heart, and the only counsel is to cry 'hoshi'eini Elokim'. t,n,q

47:16

The Midrash reads 'oil for the light' as Moshiach. The Satan of Yishmael hates wine, knowing his fall will come when Jews drink wine on Purim. u

Esther's plea and the Purim 'breaking news'

50:11

Recalling a Slonimer custom of singing 'Vatosef Esther', the Rav says this verse holds the strategy against Yishmael: plead again and again, with more davening, learning and tzedakah. w

51:08

At two minutes to eight he announces 'breaking news': Yishmael has been struck down by the tzedakah, the Megillah reading, the wine and the gifts of Jews everywhere, which are 'missiles'. He cites 'no weapon formed against you shall prosper' and calls these mitzvos the final victory and the end of exile. x

Sources

Nevi'im

  1. g apparently I Samuel 15:4 index In the write-up: 19:54
  2. i I Samuel 15:11 text index In the write-up: 22:52
  3. j I Samuel 15:13 text index In the write-up: 24:21
  4. x apparently Isaiah 54:17 index In the write-up: 51:08
  5. y apparently Isaiah 14:22 index In the write-up: 33:30

Kesuvim

  1. l apparently Esther 9:27 index In the write-up: 24:21
  2. m Esther 4:16 text index In the write-up: 36:11
  3. n Esther 4:17 text index In the write-up: 36:11, 44:55
  4. q Psalms 69:2 text index In the write-up: 36:11, 44:55
  5. t apparently Esther 4:11 index In the write-up: 44:55
  6. v apparently Esther 5:6 49:12 index
  7. w Esther 8:3 text index In the write-up: 50:11

Targum

  1. h apparently Targum Yonasan on I Samuel 15:4 index In the write-up: 19:54

Talmud Bavli

  1. c apparently Rosh Hashanah 3a-3b index In the write-up: 14:01
  2. d apparently Megillah 11b index In the write-up: 28:24
  3. e apparently Sukkah 41a index In the write-up: 16:38
  4. f Sanhedrin 20b text index In the write-up: 16:38
  5. o apparently Megillah 15a index In the write-up: 36:11

Midrash

  1. k Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 24:21
  2. p Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 36:11
  3. u Midrash (place not identified) In the write-up: 47:16

Rishonim

  1. r apparently Rashi on Bereishis 22:1 index In the write-up: 38:26
  2. s Iggeres Teiman (place not identified) 40:27 index

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a Ya'aros Devash (place not identified) index In the write-up: 10:30, 14:01

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. b apparently Pesach Haggadah, piyut Az Rov Nissim index In the write-up: 10:30

Key points

  1. 12:36 According to the Ya'aros Devash, Achashverosh's feast was timed so that its climax fell on Pesach, the night Belshazzar was killed.
  2. 18:33 Following the Chasam Sofer, the war on Amalek is to be on erev Pesach and the Beis Hamikdash could be built that same night, so the kings waited until Pesach passed before celebrating.
  3. 33:07 The wise men told Achashverosh that the day Vashti was killed was not Pesach but Shushan Purim, so the Megillah begins and ends with Shushan Purim.
  4. 34:12 The first miracle of the Megillah is the downfall of Nebuchadnezzar's house, and the Rav calls it the main miracle of the Megillah.
  5. 37:44 Like Avraham on the way to the Akeidah, Mordechai crossed the Satan's 'water' with the cry 'hoshi'eini Elokim', and this gives Jews the strength to pass the barriers of the final exile.
  6. 51:52 The Rav says the Purim mitzvos of tzedakah, reading the Megillah, the feast with wine and the gifts are the weapons that defeat Yishmael.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 15:43 If kings counted their years from Tishrei, why was the feast celebrating that the Beis Hamikdash would not be rebuilt held only after Pesach?

    Answer: 29:49 They knew the Beis Hamikdash could come only after the war on Amalek on erev Pesach, so once the first day of Pesach passed with no change they felt safe to celebrate.

  2. Question: 17:33 Why did Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakai forbid new grain for the whole day of the omer waving, when the Beis Hamikdash being rebuilt exactly then seems so unlikely?

    Answer: 17:57 Following the Chasam Sofer, the war on Amalek is to be on erev Pesach and the Beis Hamikdash can be built right after it, so the concern is well-founded every Pesach.

  3. Question: 20:01 Why did Shaul count the people with sheep before the war on Amalek?

    Answer: 20:16 The war was on erev Pesach, so he counted them by the Pesach lambs they would offer right after it.

  4. Question: 24:41 How could Shaul say 'I have fulfilled the word of Hashem' after leaving Agag alive?

    Answer: 24:52 The Ruzhiner answered that Agag fathered a child that night from whom Haman came, and Shaul intended this so that the Jews would have Purim and accept the Torah anew.

  5. Question: 24:02 What did Shmuel cry to Hashem about all night?

    Answer: 26:34 That Shaul's plan should succeed: that Agag, left alive, should father a child, so that Haman would come and the Jews would have Purim.

  6. Question: 37:04 Why does the Gemara mention that Mordechai crossed water?

    Answer: 37:40 As at the Akeidah, the Satan turned himself into water to stop something on which Israel's eternity depended, and Mordechai crossed it with the same cry Avraham did.

Stories

  1. 0:10 The Lubavitcher Rebbe's 'hurrah' and Stalin's fall

    Fifty years earlier, Stalin had made a libel against the Jewish doctors of Moscow and prepared trains to take Jews to Siberia, and Jews were very worried. At a Purim seudah the Lubavitcher Rebbe told a story from the time of the Rebbe Rashab: an old chassid who knew nothing of politics went to the mikvah, put on his gartel, voted as the Rebbe wished, and when the crowd shouted 'hurrah' for their candidate he shouted it three times with great kavanah. The Lubavitcher Rebbe shouted 'hurrah' three times together with the crowd, and people whispered that the Rebbe was now bringing Stalin down. Two days later it was announced that Stalin was ill, and soon after that he had died; the Rav says he remembers it.

    In the story: the Lubavitcher Rebbe, the Rebbe Rashab, Stalin

  2. 6:01 Rabbi Elazar of Amsterdam and the queen of Holland

    In the days of Rabbi Elazar of Amsterdam, the queen knew that in times of trouble one should go to the Jews to pray to the Jewish G-d. When a dike broke and the sea threatened the city, which lies below sea level, she sent to him to pray, and the danger passed and the dike was repaired. She came herself to thank him, expecting to find him saying Tehillim with his students, and found them sitting, drinking and singing. He told her that it was Purim, and that on this day drinking accomplishes more than Tehillim does all year.

    In the story: Rabbi Elazar of Amsterdam

    told in 3 other shiurim →

Insights

  1. 33:00 Achashverosh thought Vashti was killed on Pesach, but the wise men told him the day was Shushan Purim, so the Megillah's miracle both begins and ends on Shushan Purim.
  2. 18:54 The Chasam Sofer's reading of the decree on the day of the omer waving (the war on Amalek on erev Pesach, the Beis Hamikdash that night) explains why the kings who feared its rebuilding celebrated only after Pesach passed.
  3. 20:16 Shaul counted the people with sheep because they were the Pesach lambs to be offered right after the war on erev Pesach.
  4. 26:34 Building on the Ruzhiner, the Rav explains that Shmuel's night-long cry was a tefillah that Shaul's plan, sparing Agag so Haman and Purim would come, should succeed.
  5. 38:26 The Satan blocks with 'water' precisely what decides the eternity of Israel: he did so at the Akeidah, which answered Yishmael, and again when Mordechai went to gather the Jews.
  6. 42:50 Today's exile, with its politics, parties and elections, is itself the Satan's great 'water', and the mesiras nefesh of Mordechai's cry is what lets Jews pass through it.
  7. 48:35 The Satan of Yishmael hates wine because he knows his downfall will come when Jews drink wine on Purim.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 50:52 The Rav says that from 'Vatosef Esther' one learns to plead again and again: once is not enough; more davening, more learning, more tzedakah.
  2. 46:32 The Rav says that when one stands to daven or learn with a dulled mind and a hardened heart, the only counsel is to cry out 'hoshi'eini Elokim'.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Achashverosh, Agag, Avraham Avinu, Belshatzar, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Nevuchadnetzar, Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rabbi Elazar of Amsterdam, Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), Shaul HaMelech, Stalin, the Chasam Sofer, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Lubavitcher Rebbe, the Rambam, the Rebbe Rashab (Rabbi Sholom Dovber of Lubavitch), Vashti, Yishmael, Yitzchak Avinu

Terms מחיית עמלק, עקבתא דמשיחא, עקידה, קימו וקבלו, קרבן פסח, שושן פורים, שטן, שנה מעוברת

Report an error on this page