ע"י הפור שהיפל המן נתגלגל נס של פורים

Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת שושן פורים no. ⁨8⁩ Pocket Guide p. 25 תשס"ב (2001–02) Yiddish 1 hr 18 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 1 hr 18 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that Purim is named for Haman's lot because Haman's casting of the goral aroused the world of the goral, where Klal Yisrael is judged by its hidden inner point, and so it was Haman himself who brought about the miracle.

The Rav asks why Purim carries the name of Haman's lot rather than of the salvation. Citing the Siddur of the Ba'al HaTanya, he explains that a goral is above reason and reveals the inner point of a Jew that only Hashem understands, as on Yom Kippur. Angels, as pure intellect, cannot grasp it, which is why Menashe's teshuvah came through a hidden tunnel. He then asks how the decree of the Purim era was annulled, and answers with the Ba'al Shem Tov's teaching of several courts: the heavenly court ruled against Klal Yisrael, but Haman's casting of a lot aroused the world of the goral, where Jews are judged by their hidden love. This is a taste of the days of Moshiach, so Haman caused the miracle. After a break he shows that Jews, like terumah, can never be redeemed or exchanged, which is what Haman sought to deny.

Topics: Purim · The Pintele Yid: The Inner Point of Every Jew · Hashem's Love for Klal Yisroel

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Opening of the recording, untranscribed (Unclear audio)

  2. 8:18 Why Purim is named after a lot listed in the guide

    The Rav asks why Purim is named after Haman's lot when every festival is named for the salvation. Citing the Siddur of the Ba'al HaTanya, he explains that a goral is above reason and reveals the inner point of a Jew, as on Yom Kippur, and that angels, being pure intellect, could not accept Menashe's teshuvah.

  3. 12:35 Teshuvah above wisdom and Torah

    The Rav explains that Menashe's teshuvah came through a hidden tunnel because the inner point of a Jew cannot be explained to the angels. He brings the Yerushalmi where wisdom, Torah and Hashem give different answers about the sinner, and explains from the Tanya that Hashem's answer reaches a root above wisdom, the world called 'Kol Yisrael' where no sin reaches.

  4. 15:53 The decree, the courts above, and Haman's lot listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Gemara in Megillah on why the Jews of that generation deserved destruction, and asks how the decree could be annulled. He answers with the Ba'al Shem Tov's teaching of several courts above, and explains that Haman's lot aroused the world of the goral, where the Jews were judged by their hidden inner root.

  5. 21:32 Mordechai, Moshiach, and Haman as cause of the miracle listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that in the days of Mordechai and Esther the hidden root of every Jew was revealed, as it will be in the days of Moshiach, and that the nachalos of Eretz Yisrael were also given by lot. He concludes that Haman himself caused the miracle, since without his lot the first verdict would have stood, and that this 'v'nahafoch hu' is the point of the whole Megillah.

  6. 26:07 Ad d'lo yada, the circle of tzaddikim, and Purim's permanence listed in the guide

    The Rav explains 'ad d'lo yada' through the inner point where all Jews are equal, like the future circle dance of the tzaddikim, and ties the goral to the fiftieth gate where the other side is subdued to holiness. He brings that Haman too had a spark, as his descendants learned Torah, and concludes that Purim is a festival of the world to come that will never be nullified.

  7. 29:15 Untranscribed break (Unclear audio)

  8. 35:22 Jews as terumah that cannot be redeemed

    The Rav brings Rashi, who calls the opinion that terumah can be redeemed a mistake, and asks why Rashi speaks so sharply here. He answers from the verse 'Kodesh Yisrael laHashem reishis tevuaso': Jews are Hashem's terumah and can never be exchanged, and Haman's offer of ten thousand talents of silver was an attempt to redeem them, which is the opening of the Megillah's theme.

  9. 40:24 Tarshish, Amalek, and the eternal bond

    The Rav asks why the Gemara singles out the stone tarshish, the stone of Asher, and explains that what has holiness in its very being cannot be redeemed; Haman, 'reishis goyim Amalek', the same gematria as tarshish, wanted the holiness to pass to him. He concludes that the Jews are betrothed to Hashem forever, an everlasting building that Haman could not undo.

  10. 47:08 A badchan's Purim rhymes (Another speaker)

The shiur, written up

Why Purim is named after a lot

8:49

The Rav asks why Purim is named after Haman's lot, when every festival is named for the salvation. He brings the Siddur of the Ba'al HaTanya that Purim and Yom Kippur both come through a goral, which is above reason: wealth from business or an inheritance has a cause one understands, but a win by lot does not. The lot reaches the inner point of a Jew that only Hashem understands. b

Teshuvah above wisdom and Torah

12:35

Angels, being pure intellect, are right by their own logic, so Menashe's teshuvah came through a hidden tunnel. The Rav then brings the Yerushalmi: wisdom says the sinner dies, the Torah says he brings a korban, Hashem says he does teshuvah. Through the Tanya and the Rambam he explains that Hashem's answer reaches a root above wisdom, the world called 'Kol Yisrael', where no sin ever reached. d,e,f

The decree, the courts above, and Haman's lot

15:53

The Rav brings the Gemara in Megillah 12a on why that generation deserved destruction and how it was answered that they acted only outwardly. He asks: if the decree was just, how was it annulled, and if the defense was valid, why was it not raised before? He answers with the Ba'al Shem Tov's teaching of several courts: angels, the souls of tzaddikim, and Hashem Himself, as Dovid HaMelech asks in Tehillim 17:2. i,j

18:20

The decree passed before the heavenly court, but Haman cast a lot, and what happens below stirs above. The case reached the world of the goral, where no externality reaches; there the Jews were judged by their hidden love, which never wanted to sin.

Haman caused the miracle

21:42

In the days of Mordechai and Esther the hidden root of every Jew was revealed, as it will be in the days of Moshiach; the Rav cites the Likutei Torah of Rabbi Mordechai of Chernobyl that Mordechai is an aspect of Moshiach, and notes that 'hipil pur hu hagoral' equals 'Moshiach ben David' in gematria. k,a

23:54

So it was Haman who made the miracle: the decree came from the Jews' own sins, and without his lot the first verdict would have stood. This 'v'nahafoch hu' is the point of the whole Megillah. m

Ad d'lo yada and Purim's permanence

26:15

Through 'ad d'lo yada' the Rav explains that 'arur Haman' and 'baruch Mordechai' share a gematria, since at the inner point all Jews are equal, like the future circle dance of the tzaddikim. Even Haman held a spark: his descendants taught Torah in Bnei Brak. Therefore, though the festivals will one day be nullified, Purim, a festival of the world to come, will not. o

Jews as terumah that cannot be redeemed

36:55

The Rav brings Rashi, who calls the view that terumah can be redeemed a mistake, though elsewhere he rejects opinions without such language. He explains from Yirmiyahu 2:3 that Jews are Hashem's terumah, and a claim that terumah can be exchanged echoes the view that the Jews can be replaced by another nation. v,w

39:04

Haman's ten thousand talents of silver were an attempt to redeem the Jews and move their holiness to the nations. That is why the Megillah's theme opens with 'v'ilu la'avadim v'lishfachos nimkarnu': Jews cannot be sold. x,u

Tarshish, Amalek, and the eternal bond

40:49

The Rav asks why the Gemara singles out tarshish, a stone of the last row. It is the stone of Asher, and what is holy in its very being cannot be redeemed; as the Torah says, its substitute too becomes holy. Haman, 'reishis goyim Amalek', which equals tarshish in gematria, wanted the holiness to pass to him. z,ab,ac

43:02

The Rav concludes that the Jews are betrothed to Hashem forever, as Hoshea says, an everlasting building that cannot be undone, and Haman's attempt to deny it was a lie. ad

Sources

Torah

  1. l Bamidbar 26:56 23:32 text index
  2. r Devarim 23:6 28:10 text index
  3. ab apparently Vayikra 27:10 index In the write-up: 40:49
  4. ac Bamidbar 24:20 text index In the write-up: 40:49

Nevi'im

  1. n Zechariah 14:9 25:44 text index
  2. t Ovadiah 1:21 29:01 text index
  3. w Yirmiyahu 2:3 text index In the write-up: 36:55
  4. ad Hoshea 2:21 text index In the write-up: 43:02

Kesuvim

  1. a Esther 9:24 text index In the write-up: 21:42
  2. j Tehillim 17:2 text index In the write-up: 15:53
  3. m Esther 9:1 text index In the write-up: 23:54
  4. u Esther 7:4 text index In the write-up: 39:04
  5. x Esther 3:9 text index In the write-up: 39:04

Mishnah

  1. g Mishnah Sanhedrin 10:1 14:28 text index
  2. h apparently Mishnah Yoma 6:1 14:40 index

Talmud Bavli

  1. c apparently Sanhedrin 103a 11:10 index
  2. i Megillah 12a text index In the write-up: 15:53
  3. o Megillah 7b text index In the write-up: 26:15
  4. p apparently Taanis 31a 26:37 index
  5. q Gittin 57b 27:54 text index
  6. z Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 40:49

Talmud Yerushalmi

  1. d apparently Yerushalmi Makkos 2:6 index In the write-up: 12:35

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. aa Zohar (place not identified) 41:13 index

Rishonim

  1. f Rambam (place not identified) index In the write-up: 12:35
  2. v Rashi (place not identified) index In the write-up: 36:55
  3. y Tosafos (place not identified) 39:14 index

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. e Tanya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 12:35
  2. k Likutei Torah (R. Mordechai of Chernobyl) (place not identified) index In the write-up: 21:42

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. b Siddur of the Ba'al HaTanya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 8:49

Other

  1. s apparently Midrash Mishlei 9 28:40 index

Key points

  1. 9:27 A goral is above reason: it reveals the inner point of a Jew that only Hashem understands, which is why both Yom Kippur and Purim are tied to a lot.
  2. 11:16 Angels are pure intellect and judge correctly by reason, but the point of a Jew that is above reason cannot be explained to them, so Hashem accepted Menashe's teshuvah through a hidden tunnel.
  3. 17:16 Following the Ba'al Shem Tov, there are several courts above: the decree of destruction passed in the heavenly court of angels, but before Hashem Himself the Jews are judged by their hidden love, which never wanted to sin.
  4. 19:54 When Haman cast a lot to destroy the Jews, it aroused the world of the goral above, where no externality reaches, and there the Jews were judged by their hidden root, so the decree was annulled.
  5. 23:51 The whole salvation came through Haman's lot, since the decree itself came from the Jews' own sins; therefore the day is called Purim, after the pur.
  6. 28:33 Purim is a taste of the world to come and will not be nullified even when the other festivals are, because the inner point it reveals belongs to the days of Moshiach.
  7. 38:00 Jews are Hashem's terumah, holy in their very being, and can never be redeemed, sold or exchanged for another nation; Haman sought to deny this.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 8:49 Every festival is named for the salvation; why is Purim named after Haman's lot?

    Answer: 23:59 Because the whole salvation came through his lot: it aroused the world of the goral, and without it the original decree would have stood.

  2. Question: 11:36 Why did Hashem need a hidden tunnel for Menashe's teshuvah instead of explaining to the angels or listening to them?

    Answer: 12:01 Because the inner point of a Jew is above intellect; only Hashem understands it, and it cannot be explained to angels, who by reason are correct.

  3. Question: 13:24 In the Yerushalmi, why is Hashem's answer that the sinner should do teshuvah higher than the Torah's answer, when the Torah is Hashem's own wisdom?

    Answer: 13:42 Because there is a level above wisdom, the root of His essence, which is the inner point of every Jew, where no blemish reaches.

  4. Question: 16:54 If the Jews deserved the decree, how was it annulled; and if their defense was valid, why was it not raised before the decree?

    Answer: 17:16 There are several courts: in the heavenly court the decree passed, but Haman's lot brought the case to Hashem Himself and the world of the goral, where Jews are judged by their hidden love.

  5. Question: 37:15 Why does Rashi call the view that terumah can be redeemed a mistake, when elsewhere he does not speak that way about opinions he rejects?

    Answer: 37:52 Because Jews are 'Kodesh Yisrael laHashem reishis tevuaso', Hashem's terumah, and a view that terumah can be exchanged is like the view that Jews can be replaced.

  6. Question: 40:49 Why does the Gemara mention specifically tarshish, a stone of the last row?

    Answer: 41:08 Tarshish is the stone of Asher and has the gematria of 'reishis goyim Amalek', the one who sought to redeem what cannot be redeemed.

Insights

  1. 10:02 The Rav explains why a goral reveals what reason cannot: wealth from business or an inheritance has an understandable cause, but winning by lot has none, so the lot reaches the root that only Hashem knows.
  2. 11:36 By the angels' own logic they were right to oppose Menashe's teshuvah; Hashem did not overrule them openly but made a hidden tunnel, because the inner point of a Jew cannot be explained to pure intellect.
  3. 20:01 Haman's lot, meant for destruction, registered above as a judgment 'by lot', and so it moved the case to the one court where the Jews could only be found meritorious: what Haman did below aroused its counterpart above.
  4. 22:20 The Rav notes that 'hipil pur hu hagoral' has the gematria of 'Moshiach ben David': Haman's lot aroused the world of Moshiach, when the inner purpose of creation, that Yisrael rose first in Hashem's thought, will be revealed.
  5. 26:15 'Arur Haman' and 'baruch Mordechai' share a gematria because at the inner point all Jews are equal, like the future circle dance of the tzaddikim, where no one stands nearer or farther.
  6. 37:15 Rashi's unusually sharp word 'mistake' against those who say terumah can be redeemed reflects that Jews are Hashem's terumah; a view that terumah can be exchanged echoes the claim that the Jews can be replaced by another nation.
  7. 41:08 Tarshish, the stone of Asher, has the same gematria as 'reishis goyim Amalek': Haman wanted the title 'first', which belongs to Yisrael as 'reishis tevuaso', to pass to Amalek.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Bilaam, Dovid HaMelech, Esther HaMalkah, Haman, Menashe, Mordechai HaTzaddik, Rabbi Mordechai (Mottel) of Chernobyl, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Rashi, Rav Shmuel bar Shilas, the Arizal, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Baal Shem Tov, the Rambam

Terms אהבה מסותרת, גורל, ונהפוך הוא, נקודה הפנימית, סטרא אחרא, עד דלא ידע, שורש הנעלם, שכל נבדל, שער החמישים, תרומה

Report an error on this page