פרשה זו קשה להבין אבל בו נטמן אורו של מלך המשיח
Catalog entry: פרשת השבוע וישב no. 3 Pocket Guide p. 7 תשל"ט (1978–79) Yiddish 1 hr 27 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that Parshas Vayeshev, a parsha full of troubling questions on the Shevatim and on Hashem's ways, is exactly where the hidden light of Moshiach is concealed, as in the Chanukah lights that shine in the darkest time of the year.
The Rav opens by calling Vayeshev a hard parsha that hides the light of Moshiach, always read before Chanukah, when the final sealing of judgment ends. Having finished the Avos, the Torah turns to their children, and the plain reading raises hard questions: Yosef's talebearing, the brothers' hatred and sale, Yehuda and Tamar, and Yosef imprisoned after withstanding his test. A Jew with emunah knows the Shevatim were awesome tzaddikim; questions on tzaddikim lead to questions on Hashem, so the parsha is a drill in emunah. Bringing the Maharal, he explains that Torah mirrors the state of Klal Yisrael: this is the parsha of galus and hester panim, falling in Teves, and therefore the greatest light is hidden in it. Yosef reached his perfection in Mitzrayim, on Nittel, the darkest day. The Rav then shows that Zos Chanukah completes the Days of Awe, alluded to in the 122nd passuk from Nitzavim, and closes with preparing for Chanukah.
Topics: Yosef and His Brothers · The Hidden Roots of Moshiach · Hester Panim and Suffering · The Miracle of Chanukah and the Greeks
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 A hard parsha that hides Moshiach's light listed in the guide
The Rav calls Vayeshev a hard parsha that hides the light of Moshiach and prepares for Chanukah, when the gmar chasimah ends. He brings a teaching that 'about three months' after Rosh Hashanah Tamar, Knesses Yisrael, is judged and shows her signs, and describes Teves as the darkest month, whose head Chanukah crushes.
-
7:19 From the Avos to the troubling story of their children listed in the guide
After the Avos, the Torah begins the toldos of Yaakov, and one expects to learn how worthy the children were. Instead the plain reading shows Yosef at seventeen fixing his hair and speaking lashon hara, the brothers' hatred and plot, and the story of Yehuda, which would shock a simple reader.
-
15:00 How great the Shevatim truly were listed in the guide
The Rav tells, as heard from the Ruzhiner, how the Maggid of Mezritch trembled after touching the Ba'al Shem Tov's kittel, to show how much greater the holiness of the Shevatim was. He brings the Torah's refusal to break the passuk after Reuven's deed and the Ramban on Yaakov's strength coming from yiras shamayim, and admits that no smooth explanation of the Shevatim's deeds is found.
-
21:25 Yosef's test and the question on Hashem listed in the guide
Questions on tzaddikim lead to questions on Hashem, and the parsha turns there: Yosef, who constantly whispered his trust in Hashem, withstood the daily test of Potiphar's wife for a year, and was then thrown into prison. The Rav concludes that the whole parsha is a drill in emunah.
-
29:17 Torah mirrors Klal Yisrael: a parsha of galus listed in the guide
Bringing the Maharal on the Gemara that halachos would be scattered, the Rav explains that the Torah, the soul of Klal Yisrael, goes into galus with them, and today's collections of seforim mirror the beginning of the ingathering. Vayeshev falls in Teves, the time of the sitra achra, and begins galus Mitzrayim, so it is a parsha of hester panim, when tzaddikim are not seen.
-
36:33 The hidden light of Moshiach and Chanukah listed in the guide
Where impurity is greatest, holiness is strongest, so the ohr haganuz is hidden in Vayeshev like a diamond in a garbage can. The Rav brings the Midrash that while the Shevatim, Reuven, Yaakov and Yehuda were each occupied, Hashem was creating the light of Moshiach, and ties it to the Chanukah lights lit outside, below ten tefachim, as a weekday yom tov of galus.
-
45:05 Yosef's perfection on the darkest day listed in the guide
Yosef is the mashpia of Klal Yisrael: seventeen years his father supported him and seventeen years he supported his father. The Rav explains that Mitzrayim is the lowest place and that the calendar also has a lowest day, Nittel, and following Rashi on 'vayehi kehayom hazeh' he says Yosef won his test and became Yosef hatzaddik on exactly that day.
-
55:30 Every Jew's part in Moshiach listed in the guide
The Rav says a Jew in hard trials should consider that perhaps now he can bring Moshiach, as Yosef became Moshiach ben Yosef only through his trials. In this sedra one must believe the ohr haganuz is hidden in the parsha and in oneself; one spark of the soul can overcome all darkness, and Chanukah's eight days shine into the darkness of the nations' season.
-
1:00:12 Zos Chanukah: renewal above time listed in the guide
Zos Chanukah is the end of the gmar chasimah, a tradition from the Ba'al Shem Tov's students with no source in the written Torah. The Rav explains Chanukah as renewal, like the chanukas hamizbe'ach and Yehuda's marriage after the sale, and shows that unlike Shabbos and Rosh Chodesh its date is fixed by 'eight', above time, so it can still complete Rosh Hashanah.
-
1:05:48 From Elul to Zos Chanukah: 122 pesukim listed in the guide
The Rav describes the stages of judgment: forty days to Yom Kippur, then Sukkos and Ha'azinu for those who build on emunah, and Zos Chanukah for those with only a little emunah. Counting the 122 pesukim of Nitzavim, Vayelech and Ha'azinu against the days to Zos Chanukah, he finds that day's passuk speaks of seeing the land from afar, like the Chanukah lights that may only be looked at.
-
1:15:01 Asking Hashem for Chanukah gelt listed in the guide
Zos Chanukah is a time of teshuvah and of praying for Moshiach. Chanukah is from the word chen, a free gift, so as children ask for Chanukah gelt a Jew should ask Hashem for Torah, yiras shamayim and emunah, and learn Torah as G-dliness, not as wisdom. Standing between the mezuzah and the Chanukah lights leaves its mark for the whole year.
-
1:19:30 Mesiras nefesh for Torah, not fighting in galus
The Chashmonaim fought with mesiras nefesh, and a Jew should likewise give himself for Torah, but the Rav brings the Chofetz Chaim and Rabbeinu Bachya that in galus one does not fight the nations unless they interfere with avodas Hashem, and questions a recent demonstration. No land of galus is safe, and he notes the hidden miracles of every day, citing Targum Yonasan on Esav's return to Seir.
-
1:23:48 The mezuzah story and preparing for Chanukah
The Rav tells a story he heard in Yerushalayim of a man who reads people's situation from their mezuzos, to show that the mezuzah at the door shapes the whole year, and Chanukah is a partner in this. He closes by urging real preparation for Chanukah through its halachos, chassidus and mussar seforim and teshuvah, to uncover the hidden light in one's heart, with a brachah for Moshiach.
The shiur, written up
A hard parsha that hides Moshiach's light
The Rav opens by calling Vayeshev a hard parsha to explain, yet one in which the light of Moshiach is hidden: from Yehuda comes the kingship of David, and from Yosef, Moshiach ben Yosef. The parsha is a preparation for Chanukah, and the ohr haganuz, the hidden light that the Rokeach, the Bnei Yissaschar and other seforim connect with Chanukah, is concealed in it. He adds the tradition from the Ba'al Shem Tov's students that the gmar chasimah, the final sealing of judgment, lasts until Chanukah. a
He brings a teaching on the passuk 'about three months' said of Tamar: Tamar is Knesses Yisrael, judged three months after Rosh Hashanah, at Chanukah. In so long a galus she seems to deserve a harsh sentence, yet a Jew at Chanukah shows that he is still bound to Hashem. The Rav then describes Teves as the darkest month, with the longest nights, and says Chanukah, falling on Rosh Chodesh Teves, crushes its head. b
From the Avos to the troubling story of their children
Until now Sefer Bereishis spoke of the Avos, whose greatness is our greatest pride; the praise of Hashem itself begins with 'the G-d of Avraham, Yitzchak and Yaakov'. Vayeshev turns to the toldos of Yaakov, and one expects to hear how worthy the children were of such holy fathers.
Instead, the Rav points out, the Torah tells of Yosef at seventeen standing at the mirror fixing his hair, as Rashi brings, and bringing reports about his brothers that look like lashon hara. The brothers hate him, sit down to plan how to kill a brother, and sell him, and then comes the episode of Yehuda and Tamar. Were such a story told about an ordinary Jew in a Boro Park shtibel, he would be ashamed to show his face, and someone not raised with emunah in tzaddikim and in the Torah could read the parsha very wrongly. c,d
How great the Shevatim truly were
To show who the Shevatim were, the Rav tells, as received from the Ruzhiner, that the Maggid of Mezritch once straightened the Ba'al Shem Tov's kittel and was seized with such trembling that he grabbed a shtender, which shook with him, and had to be put to bed. Whoever touched one of the Shevatim, he says, would have been burned.
Even after Reuven's deed the Torah does not break the passuk, continuing at once that the sons of Yaakov were twelve. The Ramban explains that Yaakov's strength in rolling the stone came from his yiras Hashem, and the Shevatim were awesomely strong. A believing Jew needs no proofs, yet the Rav admits he has not found a smooth explanation of all their deeds. e,f
Yosef's test and the question on Hashem
The Rav notes, following the Rambam, that one who speaks against tzaddikim ends up speaking against Hashem Himself, and this is where the parsha turns. g
In Potiphar's house Hashem was with Yosef and everything succeeded in his hands. The Midrash relates that he constantly whispered, 'Ribono shel Olam, You are my trust.' Potiphar's wife pressed him day after day for a whole year, and he held firm. h,i,j
A person is meant to keep far from such tests, the Rav says; Yosef, placed into one, did all a human can, and when his strength ran out help came from Heaven, earning him the unique title Yosef hatzaddik. Yet instead of reward he is thrown into prison, which seems a terrible question on Hashem. The whole parsha, he concludes, is a drill in emunah: it starts with questions on tzaddikim and reaches questions on Hashem.
Torah mirrors Klal Yisrael: a parsha of galus
The Gemara in Shabbos says a time would come when no clear halachah is found in one place. The Maharal explains that the Torah is the soul of Klal Yisrael, so when they are in galus and not in their place, its halachos too are scattered. From here the Rav suggests why the important seforim of our time are collections: Jews are beginning to gather in Eretz Yisrael, millions where a century ago there were few, and the Torah is gathered with them. k
So too the parsha reflects its time: it falls in Teves, the season when the sitra achra rules, and it is a parsha of hester panim, when tzaddikim are not openly seen; the Chozeh of Lublin said that from his day until Moshiach there would be no more such open wonders. As the Targum tells, Yosef was informed that galus Mitzrayim begins from that day. m
The hidden light of Moshiach and Chanukah
A rule in the seforim says that where impurity is greatest, holiness is strongest, as in Yerushalayim. Therefore the greatest light lies in this parsha. Just as one hides a diamond in a garbage can where no thief would look, Hashem hid the light of Moshiach among the hardest stories of the Shevatim.
The Midrash says that the Shevatim were busy with the sale of Yosef, Reuven and Yaakov with their sackcloth and fasting, Yehuda with taking a wife, and Hashem was creating the light of Moshiach. Every detail of the parsha prepares Moshiach: from Yehuda and Tamar came Peretz, the line of David. o
So too Chanukah comes in the darkest time, and its lights are lit outside, in the public domain, below ten tefachim. The Bnei Yissaschar brings that in the Chanukah light one can see the light of Moshiach. Chanukah means preparation and dedication, and it is a weekday yom tov made in galus, lit after coming home from work. a
Yosef's perfection on the darkest day
Yosef, the Rav explains, reached his perfection specifically in a low place, and became the mashpia, the channel through which good flows to Klal Yisrael. The Torah stresses that he was seventeen: for seventeen years his father supported him, but Yosef is not a receiver, so later he supported Yaakov for seventeen years in return. c,t
He did not reach it sitting at a Shabbos table making kiddush. The world, the seforim say, is arranged like a human body, and Mitzrayim is its lowest part, a place like one where words of Torah may not be said. The calendar too has such a day: the tekufah of Teves, Nittel, the longest night of the year, when Jews do not learn.
The passuk 'vayehi kehayom hazeh' does not say which day it was; Rashi brings that it was their festival, and the Rav says it was Nittel. On that day, when the power of the yetzer hara is strongest, Yosef, a seventeen-year-old, fought beyond human strength and reached the greatest perfection, being crowned Yosef hatzaddik. The lesson, he says, is that in hard times of hester panim one can reach a greater perfection than in good times. r,s
Every Jew's part in Moshiach
When a Jew goes through hard tests, the Rav says, he should think that perhaps now he can bring Moshiach: Yosef became Moshiach ben Yosef only after his trials. Perhaps he was brought into the world for this, since every Jew must contribute his share to Moshiach.
Zos Chanukah: renewal above time
Zos Chanukah is the end of the gmar chasimah, a matter with no hint in the written Torah that the Ba'al Shem Tov's students made known. The Bnei Yissaschar ties Chanukah to Rosh Hashanah, and the Rav explains Chanukah as renewal, like the dedication of the mizbe'ach. a
Shabbos is fixed and set by Hashem, and Rosh Chodesh is set by Klal Yisrael. Chanukah's place in the week shifts with the length of the months before it; what fixes it is the eighth day, and eight is above time. Therefore Rosh Hashanah can still be completed then.
From Elul to Zos Chanukah: 122 pesukim
The forty days from Rosh Chodesh Elul to Yom Kippur, the Rav says, set the whole year, which is why Nitzavim, with its forty pesukim, is read before Rosh Hashanah. A small minority are already finished at the first moment of Rosh Hashanah.
Chavakuk based the whole Torah on emunah. For those not finished by Yom Kippur comes Sukkos, whose avodah is emunah, sitting in the shade of faith, as the Zohar calls it; Ha'azinu, a parsha of emunah, has 52 pesukim, matching the days until Shemini Atzeres. For those with only a little emunah, who believe even when it is hard, there is Zos Chanukah. w,x
Nitzavim has 40 pesukim, Vayelech 30 and Ha'azinu 52, together 122, matching the days through Zos Chanukah. The 122nd passuk speaks of seeing the land from afar without entering it. This, says the Rav, is the ohr haganuz revealed on Zos Chanukah: as with the Chanukah lights, we may only look at it, not use it. When Moshiach comes, Moshe Rabbeinu will enter. y,z
Asking Hashem for Chanukah gelt
Mesiras nefesh for Torah, not fighting in galus
As the Chashmonaim fought with mesiras nefesh, a Jew should give himself for Torah. But the Chofetz Chaim and Rabbeinu Bachya teach that in galus one does not fight the nations unless they hinder avodas Hashem. The Rav questions a demonstration held two weeks earlier, and warns that America is no different from Germany or Spain. ac
The mezuzah story and preparing for Chanukah
The Rav tells of a man in Yerushalayim who reads people's situation from their mezuzos; from one he discerned that its owner was a melamed in difficulty. The mezuzah at the door shapes the year, and Chanukah is a partner in this.
He urges preparing through Chanukah's halachos, chassidus and mussar seforim and teshuvah, to uncover the hidden light in one's heart.
Sources
Torah
- b Bereishis 38:24 text index In the write-up: 2:43
- c Bereishis 37:2 text index In the write-up: 10:49, 45:12
- e Bereishis 35:22 text index In the write-up: 17:12
- h Bereishis 39:2-3 text index In the write-up: 22:43
- j Bereishis 39:10 text index In the write-up: 22:43
- n Bereishis 38:1 37:57 text index
- r Bereishis 39:11 text index In the write-up: 51:46
- t apparently Bereishis 47:28 index In the write-up: 45:12
- y Devarim 32:52 text index In the write-up: 1:11:59
- ad Bereishis 33:16 text index In the write-up: 1:21:40
Nevi'im
Targum
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
- d apparently Rashi on Bereishis 37:2 index In the write-up: 10:49
- f apparently Ramban on Bereishis 29:10 index In the write-up: 17:12
- g Rambam (place not identified) index In the write-up: 21:42
- s apparently Rashi on Bereishis 39:11 index In the write-up: 51:46
- u apparently Rashi on Bereishis 37:1 index In the write-up: 56:58
- ac Rabbeinu Bachya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 1:19:56
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 0:05 Vayeshev, always read before Chanukah, is a hard parsha to explain, yet in it the hidden light of Moshiach is concealed.
- 20:17 Read plainly without emunah, the parsha raises questions on the holy Shevatim, and questions on tzaddikim lead to questions on Hashem Himself; the parsha is a test of emunah.
- 30:51 Following the Maharal, what happens to Klal Yisrael is reflected in the Torah, so Vayeshev, where galus begins and in the month of Teves, is a parsha of hester panim.
- 36:39 Where the impurity is greatest the holiness is strongest, so the greatest light, the light of Moshiach from Yehuda and Yosef, is hidden in this parsha, like the Chanukah lights lit outside and low.
- 47:43 Yosef reached his perfection not at his father's table but in Mitzrayim, on Nittel, the darkest day, by fighting his test with all his strength.
- 1:00:14 Zos Chanukah is the end of the gmar chasimah, alluded to in the 122nd passuk counted from Nitzavim, which speaks of seeing the land from afar.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 9:12 After the Torah praised the holy Avos, why does it introduce their children with stories of lashon hara, hatred, a sale and the episode of Yehuda?
Answer: 36:21 Vayeshev is the parsha where galus begins, a parsha of hester panim, and precisely there Hashem hid the greatest light, the light of Moshiach.
-
Question: 18:22 Why does the Torah praise Yaakov's strength in rolling the stone, when the Greeks and even a horse are strong?
Answer: 18:55 Bringing the Ramban, the Rav explains that Yaakov's strength came from his yiras Hashem, and true strength requires a great level of fear of Heaven.
-
Question: 28:04 Why is Yosef, after withstanding so great a test, thrown into prison instead of being rewarded?
Answer: 28:44 The Rav does not resolve it directly; he says this is the point of the parsha: it starts with questions on tzaddikim and arrives at questions on Hashem, a drill in emunah.
-
Question: 51:46 Why does the passuk 'vayehi kehayom hazeh' not say which day it was?
Answer: 51:56 As Rashi brings, it was a festival of their idolatry; the Rav says it was Nittel, when people did not stay home, and on that darkest day Yosef reached his perfection.
-
Question: 1:12:31 If Zos Chanukah is the end of the gmar chasimah but has no hint in the Torah, where is it alluded to?
Answer: 1:13:20 In the period of Rosh Hashanah itself: the 122 pesukim of Nitzavim, Vayelech and Ha'azinu correspond to the days through Zos Chanukah, whose passuk speaks of seeing the land but not entering, the ohr haganuz that is seen but not used.
Stories
-
15:05 The Maggid touches the Ba'al Shem Tov's kittel
The Rav relates, as received from the Ruzhiner, that once the Ba'al Shem Tov left his kittel for a few minutes. The Maggid of Mezritch saw it was not lying properly and went to straighten it. When he touched it, he was seized with such trembling from fear of Heaven that he grabbed a shtender, which shook with him, and he had to be put to bed. The Rav uses it to show how much greater the holiness of the Shevatim must have been.
In the story: Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), the Maggid of Mezritch, the Baal Shem Tov
-
23:39 Potiphar hears Yosef's whispered prayer
Following the Midrash, the Rav tells that whatever Potiphar asked of Yosef succeeded in his hands: if he wanted hot water it was hot, and if cold, it was cold. Potiphar suspected Yosef of witchcraft because he was always murmuring to himself, and asked what he was saying. Listening closely, he heard that Yosef was constantly praying to Hashem and declaring his trust in Him.
In the story: Yosef HaTzaddik, Potiphar
-
50:56 A tzaddik's Nittel-night custom
The Rav tells of an earlier tzaddik whose name is not clear in the recording: on Nittel night he did not learn, but instead tore the paper he would need for the whole year, although others could easily have done it for him. The Rav says he wanted to do it himself precisely at that time, and hints that there is inner meaning in it which he does not explain.
-
1:23:57 The mezuzah checker in Yerushalayim
The Rav tells a story he heard in Yerushalayim from his mechutan: a man there checks mezuzos once a week, and people from all over Eretz Yisrael bring theirs, because from a mezuzah he can tell what is happening with the person. A son once brought his father's mezuzos, and the checker asked if he was a melamed. The son said no, but his father was, a top melamed in the Etz Chaim yeshiva who lately had been having difficulties, and the checker showed him where the mezuzah reflected it.
Insights
- 38:04 The greater the light, the more deeply it must be hidden: Hashem hid the light of Moshiach inside the most troubling stories of Vayeshev, as one hides a diamond in a garbage can where no thief would look.
- 21:55 The parsha moves from questions on the Shevatim to Yosef being imprisoned for his righteousness, mirroring the Rambam's point that speaking against tzaddikim leads to speaking against Hashem; this makes Vayeshev a drill in emunah.
- 30:44 Because the Torah is the soul of Klal Yisrael, its scattered halachos reflect the people's exile, and the many collections of seforim in our time reflect the beginning of their ingathering.
- 46:19 Yosef supported Yaakov for seventeen years to repay the seventeen years Yaakov supported him, because Yosef's nature is to be a giver, not a receiver.
- 47:48 Just as the world and the calendar have the structure of a body, Mitzrayim is the lowest land and Nittel the lowest day, and Yosef won his greatest perfection precisely in that place and on that day.
- 1:11:59 Nitzavim, Vayelech and Ha'azinu together have 122 pesukim, matching the days from Rosh Chodesh Elul to Zos Chanukah, and the last passuk, about seeing the land from afar without entering, matches the Chanukah lights, which may be looked at but not used.
- 1:04:42 Chanukah's date is fixed by neither Shabbos nor Rosh Chodesh but by the number eight, which is above time, so on Chanukah a Jew can still complete what belongs to Rosh Hashanah.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 54:33 The Rav says that in hard times of hester panim and questions, a Jew can reach a greater perfection than in good times.
- 55:54 The Rav says a Jew going through hard trials should think that perhaps he was brought into the world to contribute his part to Moshiach, as every Jew must.
- 1:15:56 The Rav says one should ask Hashem for 'Chanukah gelt': Torah, yiras shamayim and complete emunah.
- 1:16:49 The Rav says Torah must be learned as G-dliness and not as a branch of wisdom.
- 1:25:52 The Rav says preparing for Chanukah means learning its halachos and the chassidus and mussar seforim on it, and doing teshuvah, not only buying oil after work.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Chavakuk, Esav, Moshe Rabbeinu, Potiphar, Rabbeinu Bachya, Rabbi Mordechai of Lechovitch, Rabbi Yisrael of Ruzhin (the Ruzhiner), Rashi, Reuven, Tamar, the Baal Shem Tov, the Beis Yisrael of Ger, the Chofetz Chaim, the Chozeh of Lublin, the Maggid of Mezritch, the Maharal of Prague, the Rambam, the Ramban, the Yismach Moshe, Yaakov Avinu, Yehudah (son of Yaakov), Yosef HaTzaddik
Terms אור הגנוז, אורו של משיח, גמר חתימה, הסתר פנים, זאת חנוכה, מסירות נפש, משפיע ומקבל, נסיון, ערות הארץ, צילא דמהימנותא, קושיא, תקופת טבת