צד א: יום של אמונה בדברים שהם למעלה מהשגתינו.

Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת זאת חנוכה no. ⁨2⁩ Pocket Guide p. 20 תשמ"ה (1984–85) Yiddish 46 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 46 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that Chanukah, and above all Zos Chanukah, comes from a realm above human understanding, so its light and its good sealing for the Jewish people rest on their simple emunah in what they cannot grasp.

The Rav opens with the Gemara's question 'Mai Chanukah', asked of no other Yom Tov, and explains that the answer, eight days, is itself the point: eight is above the seven days of nature, and Chanukah comes from a world one may ask about but cannot know. He finds this in the name Chashmonaim, made of shemen, the letter ches and 'mai', and in oil, which always rises. With a mashal of a king who jumps into the mud for his child, he explains why this light still descends below ten handbreadths, the one Chanukah law hinted in the Mishnah. The miracle broke the Greek demand to understand everything. Through the Ramban, the Chiddushei HaRim and the Bnei Yissaschar he shows that the hidden light of Chanukah never goes out, like Shemini Atzeres. Zos Chanukah completes the Rosh Hashanah judgment, and Hashem then finds hidden merits in every Jew, as the Imrei Emes teaches from Parshas Mikeitz.

Topics: Zos Chanukah · Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Seven and Eight: Nature and Above

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Why the Gemara asks 'Mai Chanukah' listed in the guide

    The Rav asks why the Gemara asks 'what is Chanukah' about no other Yom Tov, and explains that its answer, eight days, shows Chanukah comes from a realm above nature that one may ask about but cannot know. This is why Jews are sealed for good on Zos Chanukah without a reason one can explain.

  2. 7:46 Chashmonaim, oil, and the king's child

    The Rav reads the name Chashmonaim as shemen, ches and 'mai', and explains that oil always rises above, belonging to the realm of eight. With a mashal of a king who jumps into the mud to save his child, he explains why the Shechinah nevertheless descends below ten handbreadths on Chanukah.

  3. 12:16 The one Chanukah law in the Mishnah listed in the guide

    The Rav notes that the Mishnah contains no Chanukah laws except one deduced from it, that the Chanukah light belongs below ten handbreadths, and connects this to Rebbi, of the house of Dovid and the aspect of Moshiach. He then explains that Greek wisdom demanded understanding everything, and the miracle from the realm above reason broke that impurity.

  4. 18:22 Zos Chanukah and the eternal menorah

    The Rav says the eighth day is the answer to 'Mai Chanukah', and in it lies Hashem's love for the Jewish people and the secret of their eternity. He brings Rashi and the Ramban on Beha'alosecha, that Aharon was told his share is forever, and the Chiddushei HaRim, that Aharon's menorah was hidden still burning.

  5. 22:00 The eighth is never nullified

    Bringing the Bnei Yissaschar that the Chanukah lights shine with the hidden light, the Rav compares Chanukah to Shemini Atzeres, whose blessing stays because the eighth is above this world. He then connects Chanukah to Rosh Hashanah through the verse 'beyond the river your fathers dwelt from olam', reading olam as the hidden world.

  6. 27:06 'Lo chen haresha'im': belief in the hidden listed in the guide

    From 'kein asah es hamenorah' and the Midrash on 'lo chen haresha'im', the Rav explains that the wicked, followers of Greek wisdom, deny what they cannot see, while Jews believe in Hashem, the Torah and the Chanukah miracle. For that emunah alone they are sealed for good, and the wicked have no standing in that judgment.

  7. 32:05 Hashem finds merits: the Imrei Emes on Mikeitz

    The Rav brings the Imrei Emes on 'HaElokim matza es avon avadecha': the shevatim were so pure that even their fault had to be searched for and 'found'. Through Rashi's kal vachomer in that parshah he explains that if this is so for judgment, how much more Hashem searches out and finds hidden merits in every Jew in the week of Chanukah.

  8. 37:55 The hidden light in every Jew; rejoicing and thanks listed in the guide

    The Rav concludes that on Zos Chanukah the hidden light in every Jew comes out and by its light his merit is written for good. He calls for joy in Zos Chanukah and in emunah, and asks everyone to come on time to daven the next morning and say Hallel together, thanking Hashem for all the mitzvos and minhagim of Chanukah.

  9. 42:28 Blessing: the seal of the Kohen Gadol (Brachah)

The shiur, written up

Why the Gemara asks 'Mai Chanukah'

0:02

The Rav opens with the Gemara's question 'Mai Chanukah', what is Chanukah, a question it never asks about Pesach, Shavuos or Sukkos. The Gemara answers only that the days of Chanukah are eight. Eight, he explains, stands above the seven days of nature, so the answer itself shows that Chanukah is above nature and that its reason cannot be known. a

3:52

Chanukah comes from a realm, as the Zohar alludes, that one may ask about but cannot know. The Rav applies this to Zos Chanukah, the final sealing: Jews have not improved since Rosh Hashanah, yet they are sealed for good without a reason one can grasp. Half an answer is all that can be given, and that is the answer. c

Chashmonaim, oil, and the king's child

8:37

The miracle came with oil because oil always rises above other liquids and has no bond with the earth; the word shemen is related to shmoneh, eight. The name Chashmonaim holds shemen and ches, eight, with 'mai' added to hint at the Gemara's question.

10:21

Why then does the Shechinah descend below ten handbreadths? A king sends a servant for a fallen ring, but jumps into the mud himself for his child. The bond of father and child is above reason, and so is Hashem's descent for His children.

The one Chanukah law in the Mishnah

12:19

The Mishnah has no Chanukah laws, and seforim explain that Rebbi resented the Chashmonaim for taking the kingship. The Rav adds that one law is deduced from the Mishnah of a spark that caused damage, where Rabbi Yehudah exempts for a Chanukah light: the light belongs below ten handbreadths, as the Shulchan Aruch rules, though the Gemara calls the proof inconclusive. g,h,i

15:10

Rebbi, of the house of Dovid, is the aspect of Moshiach, so specifically in his Mishnah the light that comes down below ten is hinted. Greek wisdom believed only what it understood; the miracle from the realm of eight broke that impurity through simple emunah received from fathers and Rebbes.

Zos Chanukah and the eternal menorah

18:30

The eighth day is the answer to 'Mai Chanukah', holding Hashem's love for Israel and the secret of its eternity. The Rav brings Rashi and the Ramban, that Aharon's share is forever, meaning Chanukah, and the Chiddushei HaRim, that Aharon's menorah was hidden still burning. Both, he says, mean the hidden light. j,k,l

The eighth is never nullified

22:06

The Bnei Yissaschar brings that the Chanukah lights shine with the hidden light, so it is never nullified. On Shemini Atzeres Hashem says 'your parting is hard for Me'; the extra day passes, but its blessing stays, since death was decreed only on this world. So too Chanukah lasts forever. m

24:32

This begins on Rosh Hashanah with the verse 'beyond the river your fathers dwelt from olam'. Olam, written as hidden, is the source of Israel beyond this world; the judgment from there is completed on Zos Chanukah. o

'Lo chen haresha'im': belief in the hidden

27:07

The Rav reads 'kein asah es hamenorah' with the Midrash on 'lo chen haresha'im': the menorah carries a light from the hidden world, and the wicked, the Greek wisdom, deny miracles and Israel's eternity. Jews believe in Hashem, the Torah and the Chanukah miracle. q,r

30:03

Only for this emunah are they sealed for good. As the psalm says, the wicked will not stand in judgment; those who deny what eyes cannot see have no standing on Zos Chanukah. s

Hashem finds merits: the Imrei Emes on Mikeitz

32:05

The Imrei Emes asks about 'HaElokim matza es avon avadecha' in Parshas Mikeitz: the shevatim were so pure that their fault had to be searched for and 'found'. Rashi interrupts the dramatic story with a kal vachomer to teach the greater one: if Hashem searched thus for a fault, how much more, since the measure of good is greater, does He search for merit. t,u,v

36:20

This parshah falls in Chanukah week, the Rav says, because then Hashem finds merits no angel could find, merits hidden like the hidden light, to make the good sealing.

The hidden light in every Jew

38:21

On Zos Chanukah the hidden light in every Jew comes out; each Jew is a small light before Hashem, and by that light his merit is written for good. The Rav says one must rejoice in Zos Chanukah and in emunah, believing that one has a good point that keeps growing.

40:08

He asks everyone to come on time for davening in the morning, the last day of Hallel, and to thank Hashem together for all the mitzvos and minhagim of Chanukah.

Blessing: the seal of the Kohen Gadol

42:28

The Rav blesses the gathering with a good sealing from Hashem, the Kohen Gadol, whose seal the Greeks could not reach. On Zos Chanukah every Jew is sealed with a seal of oil.

Sources

Torah

  1. q Bamidbar 8:3-4 text index In the write-up: 27:07
  2. u Bereishis 44:16 text index In the write-up: 32:05

Nevi'im

  1. o Yehoshua 24:2 text index In the write-up: 24:32

Kesuvim

  1. s Tehillim 1:1-6 text index In the write-up: 30:03
  2. w Mishlei 20:27 38:26 text index

Mishnah

  1. g Mishnah Bava Kamma 6:6 text index In the write-up: 12:19

Talmud Bavli

  1. a Shabbos 21b text index In the write-up: 0:02
  2. d apparently Makkos 24a 4:19 index
  3. h apparently Bava Kamma 62b index In the write-up: 12:19
  4. p apparently Pesachim 50a 25:54 index
  5. x apparently Sanhedrin 39a 42:34 index

Midrash

  1. f Midrash (place not identified) 8:18
  2. r apparently Midrash Tehillim 1 index In the write-up: 27:07

Zohar and Kabbalah

  1. c apparently Zohar I:1b index In the write-up: 3:52

Rishonim

  1. j Rashi on Bamidbar 8:2 text index In the write-up: 18:30
  2. k Ramban on Bamidbar 8:2 text index In the write-up: 18:30
  3. n apparently Rashi on Vayikra 23:36 22:34 index
  4. v Rashi on Bereishis 44:8 text index In the write-up: 32:05

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. e Chasam Sofer (place not identified) 7:46 index
  2. i apparently Shulchan Aruch OC 671 index In the write-up: 12:19
  3. l Chiddushei HaRim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 18:30
  4. m Bnei Yissaschar (place not identified) index In the write-up: 22:06
  5. t Imrei Emes (place not identified) index In the write-up: 32:05

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. b apparently Ma'oz Tzur, stanza 'Yevanim nikbetzu' 2:15 index

Key points

  1. 1:33 Chanukah lasts eight days, and eight stands above the seven days of nature, so Chanukah comes from a realm one cannot understand.
  2. 16:49 Greek wisdom held that one believes only what one understands, and the Chanukah miracle broke that impurity through simple emunah.
  3. 18:58 The light of Chanukah is the hidden light that is never extinguished, and in it lies the eternity of the Jewish people.
  4. 26:08 The judgment that begins on Rosh Hashanah comes from the hidden world and is completed on Zos Chanukah.
  5. 29:38 Jews merit a good sealing on Zos Chanukah because they believe in Hashem and in things they cannot understand.
  6. 36:41 On Zos Chanukah Hashem finds hidden merits in every Jew, merits even the greatest angels could not find.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 0:11 Why does the Gemara ask 'what is Chanukah' when it asks this about no other Yom Tov?

    Answer: 1:45 Because Chanukah comes from a realm one may only ask about; the answer 'eight days' shows it is above nature and cannot be fully explained.

  2. Question: 8:37 Why was the Chanukah miracle done specifically with oil?

    Answer: 8:40 Because oil always rises above other liquids and has no bond with the earth, belonging to the realm of eight; the word shemen is related to shmoneh.

  3. Question: 10:17 If Chanukah is so lofty, why does its light belong below ten handbreadths?

    Answer: 10:53 Like a king who jumps into the mud to save his own child, the bond of Hashem with His children is above reason, and descending for them is His honor.

  4. Question: 5:35 Why do Jews deserve a good sealing on Zos Chanukah when they have not improved since Yom Kippur and Sukkos?

    Answer: 5:40 There is no reason one can grasp; it comes from the hidden realm, and in the merit of Chanukah and of their emunah Hashem finds hidden merits in them.

  5. Question: 34:25 Why does Rashi interrupt the dramatic story of Binyamin and the goblet to note a kal vachomer?

    Answer: 35:08 Because the great kal vachomer there is that if Hashem searched to find a fault in the holy shevatim, how much more does He search to find merits, since the measure of good is greater.

Insights

  1. 7:11 The Gemara's answer to 'Mai Chanukah' is not an explanation but the eight days themselves: since Chanukah is above reason, the full answer cannot be given, and that is itself the answer.
  2. 9:25 The name Chashmonaim holds the letters of shemen and ches (eight), with the remaining letters spelling 'mai', the Gemara's question.
  3. 14:57 The only Chanukah law hinted in the Mishnah, placing the light below ten handbreadths, comes through Rebbi of the house of Dovid, because the aspect of Moshiach is to bring the highest light down to the lowest place.
  4. 21:21 The Ramban's reading, that Aharon's eternal share is Chanukah, and the Chiddushei HaRim's, that his menorah was hidden still burning, are one: both mean the hidden light of Chanukah.
  5. 22:52 Like the blessing of Shemini Atzeres, which does not leave when the day leaves because death was decreed only on this-worldly things, Chanukah's eighth day is never nullified.
  6. 35:01 Rashi's kal vachomer in the middle of the Yosef story teaches that the Torah's 'Hashem found the sin' about the pure shevatim exists so one can reason that He searches even more for merit.
  7. 30:38 The 'lo chen' of the wicked is their denial of the hidden, and for that reason they have no standing in the judgment completed on Zos Chanukah.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 38:58 The Rav says one should rejoice in Chanukah, in Zos Chanukah and in the emunah one has.
  2. 39:11 The Rav says every Jew must believe that before Hashem he is a tzaddik, with a good point in him that keeps growing and never ends.
  3. 40:08 The Rav asks that everyone come on time to daven the next morning and say Hallel together with joy, thanking Hashem for all the mitzvos and minhagim of Chanukah.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Aharon HaKohen, Avraham Avinu, Binyamin, Chavakuk, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Yehuda (bar Ilai), Rabbi Yehudah HaNasi (Rebbi), Rashi, the Baal Shem Tov, the Chashmonaim, the Chiddushei HaRim, the Imrei Emes (Rabbi Avraham Mordechai of Ger), the Ramban, Yehoshua bin Nun, Yosef HaTzaddik

Terms אור הגנוז, גמר חתימה, זאת חנוכה, חשמונאים, יוונים, למטה מעשרה, למעלה מן הטבע, נצח, נקודה הפנימית, קל וחומר, שמיני עצרת

Report an error on this page