בחינת שמיני עצרת' הקב"ה רוצה להיות אצלינו עוד יום אחד
Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת זאת חנוכה no. 11 Pocket Guide p. 20 תשס"ו (2005–06) Yiddish 31 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav contrasts Shemini Atzeres, when Jews come up to Hashem and He holds them back one more day, with Zos Chanukah, when Hashem Himself comes down to the lowest Jews to stay with them and light them up.
The Rav opens with Shemini Atzeres: Sukkos has a reason, but Shemini Atzeres has none except that Hashem wants to be with His children, as a father needs no reason to come to his child's simcha. Chanukah goes further. On Shemini Atzeres the Jews come up to Hashem; on Chanukah Hashem comes down to the extinguished souls in the street, and on Zos Chanukah He says He will stay below with them, like a king who comes to a lowly place because his bride is there. From this the Rav speaks of drawing close the distant Jews. He brings the Targum Yonasan that the korbanos of the twelve nesiim, read on Zos Chanukah, nullify the twelve princes of Yishmael, and tells how Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky explained why religious children honor their parents. He closes that Zos Chanukah sums up all of Chanukah, nullifying Esav and Yishmael, and blesses the listeners with a good year.
Topics: Zos Chanukah · Shemini Atzeres and Simchas Torah · Hashem's Love for Klal Yisroel
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Untranscribed opening (Unclear audio)
-
8:21 Shemini Atzeres and Zos Chanukah listed in the guide
The Rav explains that Shemini Atzeres has no reason except Hashem's wish to be with His children, like a father at his child's simcha. On Chanukah, he says, Hashem goes further and comes down to the lowest souls, and on Zos Chanukah He stays with them below, like a king who comes to a lowly place for his bride.
-
13:40 Drawing close the distant; the twelve nesiim listed in the guide
The Rav says that on a day when Hashem comes down, one must let oneself be drawn close and draw close distant Jews. He then turns to tomorrow's reading of the nesiim and brings the Targum Yonasan that their korbanos nullified the twelve princes of Yishmael.
-
19:05 Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky on the airplane Story
The Rav tells how a non-religious man asked Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky why his children honor him while his own do not, and how Rav Yaakov answered that for us the earlier generations are the greater ones.
-
22:53 Nullifying Esav and Yishmael; the sum of Chanukah
The Rav explains that the twelve princes of Yishmael and of Esav are leaders of the sitra achra, and the korbanos of the nesiim nullify them. He then says Zos Chanukah sums up the whole Chanukah: one counts what one gained, and the day is greater than Chanukah itself.
-
27:05 Zos Chanukah against Amalek; a good year
The Rav says that on Zos Chanukah one must nullify Esav and Yishmael and the dominion of Amalek. He closes by contrasting how the nations celebrate their new year with how Jews keep Rosh Hashanah, and blesses the listeners with a good year, mentioning the Bnei Yissaschar.
The shiur, written up
Shemini Atzeres and Zos Chanukah
The Rav asks what Shemini Atzeres is about, since Sukkos already has its own reason. He answers that it has none: Hashem simply wants to be with the Jews. A distant cousin needs a reason to come to a simcha; a father coming to his child's simcha is never asked why he came.
Chanukah, he says, is more. On Shemini Atzeres the Jews come up to Hashem; on Chanukah Hashem comes down to the extinguished souls wandering in the street, to light them up. On Zos Chanukah He does not ask them to stay with Him above; He says He will stay below with them, like a king in the parable on Bamidbar 7:1 who comes to a lowly place because his bride, Knesses Yisroel, is there. a
Drawing close the distant; the twelve nesiim
Since Hashem comes down on such a day, the Rav says one must let oneself be drawn close, and draw close Jews so far away that they do not even know Shema Yisroel.
Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky on the airplane
The Rav tells that on a flight from Eretz Yisroel a non-religious man asked Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky why his children honor him while his own want nothing to do with him. Rav Yaakov answered that in the man's world each generation sees itself as more advanced, with better computers, so children look down on parents. With us the generations reach back through the Neviim, the Tannaim and Amoraim, the Rishonim and Acharonim, each earlier one greater, so children honor parents as closer to Avraham Avinu.
Nullifying Esav and Yishmael; the sum of Chanukah
The Rav explains that Esav and Yishmael each have twelve princes who lead the sitra achra, and the korbanos of the nesiim nullify them. Zos Chanukah, named for the verse in Bamidbar 7:84, he says is the sum of the whole Chanukah: one counts what one gained in its days, and it is even greater than Chanukah itself. c
Zos Chanukah against Amalek; a good year
The Rav says that on Zos Chanukah one must nullify Esav and Yishmael, and that the day nullifies the dominion of Amalek. He contrasts the nations' drunken new year with Jews' Rosh Hashanah of teshuvah, shofar and tzedakah, blesses all with a good year, and mentions the Bnei Yissaschar connecting Chanukah with Rosh Hashanah. d
Sources
Torah
Targum
Acharonim and Chassidus
Key points
- 9:35 Shemini Atzeres has no reason of its own; Hashem simply wants to be together with the Jews, as a father comes to his child's simcha without needing a reason.
- 11:04 On Shemini Atzeres the Jews come up to Hashem, while on Chanukah Hashem comes down to the lowest levels, to the extinguished souls in the street, to light them up.
- 14:38 Zos Chanukah is a day for drawing close distant Jews who do not even know Shema Yisroel, and for letting oneself be drawn close.
- 16:08 Following the Targum Yonasan, the korbanos of the twelve nesiim nullify the twelve princes of Yishmael.
- 26:13 Zos Chanukah is the sum of all the days of Chanukah, when one takes stock of what one gained, and it is even greater than Chanukah itself.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 9:21 What is the reason for Shemini Atzeres, when Sukkos has its own reason?
Answer: 9:40 There is none: Hashem simply wants to be with the Jews, as a father needs no reason to come to his child's simcha.
-
Question: 11:46 Why is Chanukah more than Shemini Atzeres, when on Chanukah the Jews do not come to Hashem?
Answer: 11:51 Because on Chanukah Hashem comes down to the low places to see what is happening with His scattered children.
Stories
-
19:05 Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky and the non-religious father
On an airplane from Eretz Yisroel, a non-religious man saw how Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky's children treated him with respect, and asked why: his own children want nothing to do with him. Rav Yaakov answered that in the man's world every generation counts itself more advanced than the one before, with better computers and the like, so the children look down on their parents. With us, the generations go back to the Avos, the Neviim, the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah, the Tannaim and Amoraim, the Rishonim and Acharonim, each earlier one greater. So children honor their parents as closer to Avraham Avinu.
In the story: Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky
Insights
- 10:19 Precisely because Shemini Atzeres has no reason of its own, it shows Hashem's love: a distant relative needs a reason to attend a simcha, a father does not.
- 11:21 Chanukah is greater than Shemini Atzeres in closeness: there the Jews come up to Hashem, here Hashem comes down to the souls scattered in the street.
- 12:06 On Zos Chanukah Hashem does not ask the Jews to stay with Him above, as on Shemini Atzeres; He says that He will stay below with them.
- 23:49 Twelve nesiim of Israel stand against twelve princes of Yishmael and of Esav who lead the sitra achra, and the korbanos of the nesiim read on Zos Chanukah nullify them.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 14:34 The Rav says that when Hashem comes to draw a person close, one must let oneself be drawn close.
- 14:47 The Rav says one must draw close Jews who are far away, even those who do not know Shema Yisroel.
- 27:25 The Rav says that on Zos Chanukah one must work to nullify the forces of Esav and Yishmael.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Esav, Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky, Yishmael
Terms זאת חנוכה, מקרב רחוקים, נשיאים, סטרא אחרא, עשו, רבונו של עולם, שמיני עצרת