האש של חנוכה מעורר התפשטות הקדושה ע"י עבודת ה' בהתלהבות
Catalog entry: זמנים זאת חנוכה no. 14 Pocket Guide p. 21 תשס"ח (2007–08) Yiddish 58 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that the ner Chanukah, unlike the mezuzah, carries the fire of kedushah outward, and that Zos Chanukah should carry that fire of zerizus and hislahavus into the whole year.
The Rav contrasts two paired mitzvos. The mezuzah, on the right as one enters, is a guard that keeps the outside forces from coming in; the ner Chanukah, on the left, is for the one going out, so that the kedushah spreads into the public domain. Milah and priah form the same pair. Gehinnom has a fire for sins and snow for mitzvos done coldly, and the eight Chanukah lights, above nature, are the fire of zerizus that answers the snow. On Zos Chanukah he calls for davening tomorrow early and loudly. Like Shemini Atzeres for Sukkos, the eighth day is hard to leave and carries the fire into the year; chinuch means constant renewal, and the kedushah left after Chanukah is greater than after Sukkos. Hallel and hoda'ah, not the lights, are what remain fixed, and they should be said with fire, together with friends.
Topics: Zerizus and the Value of Time · Zos Chanukah · The Chanukah Lights
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Untranscribed opening (Unclear audio)
-
12:50 Mezuzah guards, ner Chanukah goes out listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the mezuzah is a guard at the door so outside forces do not enter, while the ner Chanukah lets the inner kedushah break out into the public domain. That is why the mezuzah is on the right of one entering and the ner Chanukah on the right of one leaving; they are one of several paired mitzvos.
-
16:00 Fire and snow; milah and priah listed in the guide
The Rav brings that Gehinnom is half fire, for sins of desire, and half snow, for mitzvos done coldly without hislahavus. He then explains that a lo sa'aseh is a guard while a mitzvas aseh spreads the glory of Hashem, and that milah, removing the orlah, is like the mezuzah, while priah, which reveals, is like the ner Chanukah.
-
20:55 Eight lights, the fire of zerizus listed in the guide
The Rav says the ner Chanukah is the fire of zerizus that publicizes the mitzvos outward and burns away the fire of sin. The eight lights lift a Jew above nature, and on Zos Chanukah this fire stands against the snow of Gehinnom.
-
24:20 Davening tomorrow with fire listed in the guide
The Rav explains that eight is above nature, as the eighth pasuk of a mizmor turns from nature to the Torah, and appeals to come early tomorrow to say Hallel and Pesukei d'Zimra loudly. He answers someone who asked why they shout in davening: it is not planned, it shouts by itself, as at Neilah.
-
27:45 Zos Chanukah as Shemini Atzeres listed in the guide
The Rav brings that Chanukah completes Sukkos: seven days with an eighth, which is like Shemini Atzeres, a day of 'it is hard for Me to part from you'. Shemini Atzeres has no special mitzvah, only the wish to stay with the Ribono shel Olam, and it carries the sukkah into the year; Zos Chanukah carries the fire of Chanukah the same way.
-
31:20 Above time: chinuch as renewal listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the eighth is above time and stretches over the whole year, as the Torah reading of the dedication of the mizbe'ach continues 'after it was anointed'. Chinuch means renewal, a gate opened must not be let close, the light must never go out, and the kedushah left after Chanukah, as its leftovers must be burned separately, is greater than after Sukkos.
-
34:53 Hallel and hoda'ah remain; brachos listed in the guide
The Rav asks why the Beraisa and Al Hanisim fix Chanukah with Hallel and hoda'ah and do not mention the lights, and answers that the lights end but Hallel and hoda'ah must remain all year. Hallel lends its kedushah to all of Shacharis and should be said with fire, among friends, as the angels sing together in love; he brings the Radbaz on davening with friends and closes with brachos.
-
40:25 Untranscribed ending (Unclear audio)
The shiur, written up
Mezuzah guards, ner Chanukah goes out
The Rav explains that the mezuzah is a guard at the door, keeping the outside forces from entering, like a king sitting inside with guards outside. The ner Chanukah is the opposite: the innermost kedushah breaks out to light up the public domain. Since the mezuzah serves the one entering and the ner Chanukah the one leaving, each stands on that person's right, as the Gemara in Shabbos places them. b
Fire and snow; milah and priah
The Rav brings that the judgment of Gehinnom lasts twelve months, six of fire and six of snow. The fire is for sins of desire, as the passuk in Bamidbar says that what absorbed through fire is purged through fire. The snow is for a mitzvah done coldly, without hislahavus, when nothing burned inside the person. d
In the same way, he explains, a lo sa'aseh is a guard, while a mitzvas aseh spreads the glory of Hashem. Milah, removing the orlah, guards like the mezuzah; priah reveals, like the ner Chanukah.
Eight lights, the fire of zerizus
The ner Chanukah, the Rav says, is the fire of zerizus, which publicizes the mitzvos outward and burns away the fire of sin. Its eight lights lift a Jew above nature. Tonight, Zos Chanukah, the eighth fire was lit, and it stands against the Gehinnom of snow.
Davening tomorrow with fire
Eight is above nature, the Rav explains: in Tehillim 19 the opening pesukim speak of the heavens and the sun, and the eighth turns to the Torah. He asks that tomorrow people come early to say Hallel and Pesukei d'Zimra aloud. To someone who asked why they shout, he answered that at Neilah one does not plan to shout; it shouts by itself. e
Zos Chanukah as Shemini Atzeres
The Rav brings the Rokeach that Chanukah completes Sukkos: seven days with an eighth, like Shemini Atzeres, of which Rashi says 'it is hard for Me to part from you'. Shemini Atzeres has no mitzvah of its own; one simply wants to stay with the Ribono shel Olam. As it carries the sukkah into the year, Zos Chanukah carries the fire of Chanukah. h,i
Above time: chinuch as renewal
Being the eighth, the day is above time, the Rav explains, and stretches over the year, as tomorrow's reading of the dedication of the mizbe'ach continues 'after it was anointed'. Chinuch means renewal: 'Mizmor shir chanukas habayis' is said daily as if for the first time, and a gate once opened must not be let close. The kedushah left after Chanukah, whose leftovers are burned separately, exceeds that after Sukkos. j,k
Hallel and hoda'ah remain
The lighting is finished, the Rav notes, but Hallel and hoda'ah remain. He asks why the Beraisa in Shabbos 21b and the nusach of Al Hanisim fix Chanukah with Hallel and hoda'ah and do not mention the lights, and answers that the lights end while Hallel and hoda'ah must last all year. Since Chanukah's Hallel is a full obligation, it lends its kedushah to all of Shacharis. m,n
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 13:01 The mezuzah guards the home from outside forces, while the ner Chanukah brings the kedushah out to the public domain.
- 17:09 The snow of Gehinnom is for mitzvos done coldly, without hislahavus, and the fire of Chanukah is the fire of zerizus that counters it.
- 18:44 Milah and priah are a pair like mezuzah and ner Chanukah: one guards, the other reveals the glory of Hashem.
- 30:43 Like Shemini Atzeres for Sukkos, the eighth day of Chanukah is above time and carries the fire of Chanukah into the whole year.
- 35:15 What stays fixed after Chanukah is Hallel and hoda'ah, and they should continue all year with fire.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 14:40 Why is the mezuzah on the right and the ner Chanukah on the left?
Answer: 14:46 The mezuzah is for the one coming in and the ner Chanukah for the one going out, so for each it is on the right.
-
Question: 26:25 Why shout during davening?
Answer: 27:00 It is not arranged; as at Neilah or the tekios, it shouts by itself.
-
Question: 35:26 Why do the Beraisa and Al Hanisim mention only Hallel and hoda'ah, and not the lights?
Answer: 35:58 The lights end on the eighth night, but Hallel and hoda'ah must remain fixed all year.
Stories
-
26:25 Why do we shout in davening?
Someone once asked the Rav why they shout during davening. The Rav notes it was the custom in places like Karlin, Stolin and Slonim in earlier times. He asked the questioner in return whether he does not shout at Neilah, explaining that one does not decide to shout; it shouts by itself.
Insights
- 14:46 The mezuzah and the ner Chanukah face opposite directions: the mezuzah, on the right of one entering, guards the inside; the ner Chanukah, on the right of one leaving, sends the kedushah outward.
- 18:18 The same pairing runs through milah and priah, and through lo sa'aseh and mitzvas aseh: one keeps the outside forces away, the other reveals the glory of Hashem.
- 17:35 The cold of a mitzvah done without feeling is purified by snow, and the eight lights of Zos Chanukah are the fire that stands against that snow.
- 31:20 Because the eighth day is above time, it is not confined to its days and can stretch the light of Chanukah over the whole year.
- 35:26 The Beraisa fixes Chanukah through Hallel and hoda'ah rather than the lights because these are what remain after the lighting ends.
- 36:39 Since Hallel on Chanukah is a full obligation, it gives its kedushah to the whole of Shacharis, as a day with Mussaf gives Shacharis the kedushah of Mussaf.
What the Rav says to take from it
Mentioned in this shiur
People the Maharal of Prague, the Radbaz, the Ramban, the Rokeach
Terms גיהנום, הודאה, התחדשות, התלהבות, זאת חנוכה, זריזות, חיצונים, מזוזה, נר חנוכה, פריעה, שמיני עצרת