מעלת החתימה של זאת חנוכה
Catalog entry: זמנים סעודת זאת חנוכה no. 17 Pocket Guide p. 21 תשע"ב (2011–12) Yiddish 56 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that Zos Chanukah, the eighth day, belongs to a world above measure, and is a later time of sealing in which Hashem judges even the Jews who remained outside by their hidden inner light.
The Rav opens the meal of Zos Chanukah by explaining that because Chanukah was established for praise and thanksgiving, singing praises makes its meal a seudas mitzvah. He then asks why the Chashmonaim, who were holy, took kingship, and answers that, like Moshe Rabbeinu, they rose through extraordinary mesirus nefesh to the 'eighth world' above measure, where one person can be both king and kohen. He shows the same idea in the Masorah's counting of words in Mikeitz. Through the dispute of Beis Shammai and Beis Hillel and the two orders of the tribes, he explains why for Beis Hillel the last day, falling in Teves, is the main day. Zos Chanukah is a later sealing after Yom Kippur, for later generations who did not finish their teshuvah. On that day the Shechina descends to the Jews outside and judges each by the hidden light within him, as a story of the Lubliner shows.
Topics: Zos Chanukah · The Hidden Light · Seven and Eight: Nature and Above
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Opening, and singing that makes a seudas mitzvah
After garbled opening words about the month of Teves, the long exile and a call for all Jews to be united, the Rav brings the Magen Avraham that singing praises turns the Chanukah meal into a seudas mitzvah, since Chanukah was established for hallel and thanksgiving.
-
11:50 Untranscribed stretch (Unclear audio)
-
15:50 Why the Chashmonaim could be kings listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Ramban that the Chashmonaim were punished for taking the kingship from Yehudah, and the parsha of the king followed by the kohanim's portion. He asks how Moshe Rabbeinu was king, navi and kohen, and answers that he belonged to the eighth world above measure; the first Chashmonaim rose there through extraordinary mesirus nefesh, so they alone could be both kohen and king.
-
22:12 Mikeitz: counting words, not verses listed in the guide
The Rav notes that the Masorah counts the words of Parshas Mikeitz, unlike every other parsha where it counts verses. He explains that a verse joins words into a thought, while a word joins letters, which are above comprehension and through which the world was created; Mikeitz, read on Chanukah, belongs to that higher level.
-
25:43 Beis Shammai, Beis Hillel and the last mitzvah listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the eight lights show the miracle came from the eighth world, and presents the dispute of Beis Shammai and Beis Hillel: Beis Shammai belongs to the world of tikkun, while in a world still struggling with the yetzer hara the halachah follows Beis Hillel. He adds that Chanukah is the last yom tov and the last rabbinic mitzvah, and that the Torah has two orders of the tribes, the banners and the stones of the choshen.
-
29:18 Binyamin or Dan: who is last listed in the guide
The Rav contrasts the order of the banners, headed by Yehudah and fitting this world after the sin, with the stones on the kohen gadol's choshen. For Beis Shammai the last mitzvah belongs to Binyamin, the last stone, in whose portion the Beis Hamikdash stood; for Beis Hillel the last is the camp of Dan, which Rashi calls the gatherer of all the camps, who returned what the other tribes lost.
-
32:59 A later sealing after Yom Kippur listed in the guide
The Rav explains that for Beis Shammai the main day falls in Kislev, while for Beis Hillel, as the halachah follows, it falls in Teves. Beis Shammai's view matches the plain Torah she'be'al peh, where Yom Kippur is the final sealing; for Beis Hillel there is a later tikkun, Hoshana Rabbah and Zos Chanukah, revealed in later generations through the Zohar and the Arizal for Jews who did not finish their teshuvah.
-
36:41 Judged by the hidden light listed in the guide
The Rav explains that on Zos Chanukah the Shechina descends to the lowly Jews who stayed outside, hinted in the week's parsha by 'Yaakov Yaakov', an expression of affection as Yaakov went down to Mitzrayim. Every Jew is judged by his hidden inner point, not by his outward sins, and he tells of a kvitel about an informer given to the Lubliner while the man was lighting Chanukah lights.
-
40:58 The eighth day holds everything listed in the guide
The Rav explains that on each day of Chanukah one nasi brought his offering for the dedication of the altar, but the eighth day includes several nesi'im and all the middos, because above measure the little holds the much. He closes with a prayer that Hashem see the inner light of every Jew in the time before Moshiach and help all Jews together.
-
44:14 Niggun (Singing)
The shiur, written up
Singing that makes a seudas mitzvah
The Rav brings the Magen Avraham that singing songs of praise turns a meal into a seudas mitzvah. Plain zemiros alone would not do this, he explains, but Chanukah was established for hallel and thanksgiving, so praise is the very mitzvah of the day, and singing it at the Chanukah meal makes the meal a mitzvah. a
Why the Chashmonaim could be kings
The Rav brings the Ramban that the Chashmonaim, though they were holy, were punished for taking the kingship and not handing it to Yehudah. He notes that the Torah's parsha of the king is followed at once by the portion of the kohanim, who must remain kohanim and not take up kingship. b,c
He then asks how Moshe Rabbeinu, called king as Rashi explains, could also be navi and kohen. The division of roles, he answers, belongs to this world, built on measure. Moshe belonged to the eighth world, above time, place and measure, where one can be everything. The first Chashmonaim, fighting a mighty army with no natural hope, rose there through extraordinary mesirus nefesh, so they alone could be both kohen and king. d
Mikeitz: counting words
The Rav points out that only for Mikeitz, the Chanukah parsha, does the Masorah count words rather than verses. A verse joins words into a thought that people can speak, but a word joins letters, and letters are above speech and comprehension; through them the world was created. Mikeitz belongs to that higher level. e
Beis Shammai, Beis Hillel and the last mitzvah
The eight lights, the Rav explains, show that the miracle came from the eighth world, which the Chashmonaim merited through their mesirus nefesh. He then turns to the dispute of Beis Shammai and Beis Hillel. Following the Arizal, Beis Shammai belongs to the world of tikkun; while the world still struggles with the yetzer hara and darkness, the halachah follows Beis Hillel. f
He adds, as sefarim say, that Chanukah is the last yom tov and the last of the rabbinic mitzvos, and that the Torah has two orders of the tribes: the banners, and the stones of the choshen.
Binyamin or Dan
The order of the banners, headed by Yehudah, fits this world after the sin, the Rav explains, while the choshen belongs to the kohen gadol and the Holy of Holies. For Beis Shammai the main day is the first, and Chanukah, the last mitzvah, belongs to Binyamin, the last stone of the choshen, in whose portion the Beis Hamikdash stood.
A later sealing after Yom Kippur
For Beis Shammai the main day of Chanukah falls in Kislev; for Beis Hillel, as the poskim rule, it falls in Teves. The Rav explains that Beis Shammai follows the plain Torah she'be'al peh, where Yom Kippur is the final sealing and nothing later is mentioned.
Judged by the hidden light
On Zos Chanukah, the Rav explains, the Shechina descends to the lowly Jews who stayed outside. He finds this in the week's parsha: Hashem calls 'Yaakov Yaakov' as Yaakov goes down to Mitzrayim, an expression of affection for Jews in exile. Every Jew has a point of Jewishness that cannot be extinguished, and on this day he is judged by that hidden or haganuz, not by his outward sins. h
He tells of Chassidim who gave the Lubliner a kvitel about an informer, and the Rebbe saw the man shining in all the worlds. Later the kvitel came again and the informer was removed. The Rebbe explained that the first time, the man had been lighting Chanukah lights. Chanukah lights, the Rav concludes, are measured by the hidden light.
The eighth day holds everything
Each day of Chanukah, the Rav explains, corresponds to one nasi's offering for the dedication of the altar, and one middah. The eighth day holds several nesi'im and all the middos, because above measure the little holds the much, like the small cruse of oil. j
He closes with a prayer that Hashem see the inner light of the Jews before Moshiach, and help all Jews together.
Sources
Torah
Talmud Bavli
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Other
- e apparently Masoretic note at the end of Parshas Mikeitz In the write-up: 22:28
Key points
- 10:28 Since Chanukah was established for hallel and thanksgiving, singing praises at its meal makes it a seudas mitzvah.
- 19:47 In the 'eighth world', above time, place and measure, one person can be king, kohen and navi together, as Moshe Rabbeinu was and as the Chashmonaim were permitted to be.
- 30:19 For Beis Hillel the main day of Chanukah is the last, when eight lights are lit, and it falls in Teves; for Beis Shammai it is the first day, in Kislev.
- 34:28 Zos Chanukah is a later time of sealing, after Yom Kippur and Hoshana Rabbah, for Jews who did teshuvah but did not complete it.
- 36:56 On Zos Chanukah the Shechina descends to the lowly Jews who stayed outside, and judges each by his hidden or haganuz rather than by his outward deeds.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 15:54 If the Chashmonaim were punished for taking the kingship from Yehudah, and they were holy people, how did they take it at all?
Answer: 20:41 The first Chashmonaim, through extraordinary mesirus nefesh, rose to the eighth world above measure, where one may be both kohen and king; the later generations, no longer on that level, should have handed the kingship to Yehudah.
-
Question: 18:16 How could Moshe Rabbeinu be king, navi and kohen together, when the Torah separates these roles?
Answer: 19:09 The separation belongs to this world, built on measure; Moshe belonged to the eighth world above time, place and measure, where he could be everything.
-
Question: 22:28 Why does the Masorah count the words of Mikeitz, when for every other parsha it counts verses?
Answer: 24:10 A word is a joining of letters, which are above speech and comprehension, and Mikeitz, the Chanukah parsha, belongs to that higher level.
Stories
-
39:48 The kvitel about the informer
Chassidim gave the Lubliner a kvitel about an informer from whom they were suffering. He took it and said that the man shines in all the worlds, and that he does not understand what is happening. Later they gave the kvitel again; the next morning he saw it, cursed the man, and the informer was removed from the world. When they asked, the Rebbe explained that the first time they had handed him the kvitel just when the informer was lighting Chanukah lights, and then he shone in all the worlds.
In the story: the Lubliner (the Chozeh of Lublin)
Insights
- 11:03 Ordinary singing does not make a meal a seudas mitzvah, but at the Chanukah meal it does, because praise and thanksgiving are the very mitzvah for which Chanukah was established.
- 18:51 The division of roles, that a kohen may not be king and the king must come from Yehudah, belongs to this measured world; in the eighth world above measure one person can hold them all, which is why the first Chashmonaim were permitted both.
- 22:28 The Masorah counts words, not verses, only in Mikeitz, the Chanukah parsha, because a word joins letters, which stand above speech and comprehension.
- 31:19 The two orders of the tribes match the two views: for Beis Shammai the last is Binyamin, the last stone of the choshen and the place of the Beis Hamikdash; for Beis Hillel it is Dan, the gatherer who brings back what the others lost.
- 36:01 As the generations descend, they need more time for teshuvah, so a later sealing on Zos Chanukah was revealed only in later generations.
- 42:06 On the eighth day several nesi'im are included in one day, because above measure the little holds the much, like the small cruse of oil.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Avraham Avinu, Binyamin, Dan, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rashi, the Arizal, the Chashmonaim, the Chozeh of Lublin, the Ramban, Yaakov Avinu
Terms אור הגנוז, בית שמאי, גמר חתימה, הודאה, זאת חנוכה, חושן, מאסף לכל המחנות, מועט המחזיק את המרובה, מסירות נפש, עולם השמיני, עקבתא דמשיחא