#2 Lighting the Candle of השם
Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) חנוכה no. 4 Pocket Guide p. 63 תשס"ד (2003–04) English 20 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that the empty receptacles of the Chanukah menorah stand for Jewish souls still waiting to be kindled, which will all be lit when Moshiach comes.
The Rav asks why the menorah has eight receptacles, most of them empty in the first nights, when a brachah should rest on fullness, as with a full cup for Kiddush and clearing empty dishes before bentching. To answer, he explains that Chanukah, unlike other Yamim Tovim, is by its very character a weekday. He then speaks of neshamos: the Satan snatches the finer souls away from their roots, and before Moshiach many return through teshuvah, as in the time of the Chashmona'im, who fought the Hellenized Jews and brought them back. Chanukah is a taste of Moshiach, which is why it has eight lights, eight being the number of Moshiach. Its candles belong in the reshus harabim, the Satan's territory, because a candle is a neshamah; each night another captive soul is kindled, and the empty receptacles are souls still waiting, until all are lit when Moshiach comes.
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 Why light over empty receptacles? listed in the guide
The Rav opens on Kislev, the month of light, and asks why the menorah has eight receptacles that stand empty, when the Shechinah dwells in fullness and a brachah is said over a full cup and a cleared table. He adds that a mitzvah's depth is beyond us, but he will offer some insight into Chanukah.
-
3:55 A weekday Yom Tov and snatched neshamos listed in the guide
The Rav contrasts Yamim Tovim, with special clothing and no work, with Chanukah, which is by its character a weekday. He then explains that the Satan snatches the finer neshamos in galus, that Moshiach will force him to return them, and that the present teshuvah movement already shows those who return to be especially devoted.
-
9:08 The Chashmona'im and eight as Moshiach listed in the guide
The Rav describes the Hellenistic movement that drew away great souls, and the Chashmona'im's war against the Hellenized Jews, who were defeated and did teshuvah. Chanukah is therefore a taste of Moshiach, and he brings the Gemara that the Beis HaMikdash harp of seven strings will have eight in the days of Moshiach, so the menorah has eight lights.
-
12:21 Kindling captive souls in the reshus harabim listed in the guide
The Rav explains that the reshus harabim is foreign territory, yet the Chanukah lights were meant to be lit there to bring kedushah into it. A candle is a neshamah, so each light rescues a captive soul; the empty receptacles are souls still begging to be lit, until all are kindled when Moshiach comes. He closes with the prayer for a new light in the brachah of Yotzer.
The shiur, written up
Why light over empty receptacles?
The Rav asks why the menorah has eight receptacles, most standing empty on the early nights, when adding a candlestick each night would seem more fitting. The Shechinah dwells where there is fullness: Kiddush is made on a full cup, and the poskim say to clear empty dishes before bentching, since emptiness is the mark of tumah. Why, then, is the brachah on so beloved a mitzvah, as the Rambam calls it, said over empty receptacles? a
A weekday Yom Tov and snatched neshamos
On other Yamim Tovim one wears special clothing and does no work, but Chanukah is a weekday: one comes from work, lights, and returns to work. The Rav stresses that this is not because Chanukah is inferior; being a weekday is its very character.
He then speaks of neshamos. In galus the Satan seeks to snatch souls from their roots, and he prefers the finer ones. When Moshiach comes he must surrender them all, and already now, in a great movement of teshuvah, those who return are often more devoted than those raised in Yiddishkeit.
The Chashmona'im and eight as Moshiach
Chanukah tells a similar story: Hellenism drew away great souls, and the Chashmona'im fought the Jews who had joined the Greeks, won, and they did teshuvah. Chanukah is thus a taste of Moshiach. The Gemara says the Beis HaMikdash harp had seven strings and will have eight with Moshiach, and the Rav notes that the Maharal explains this at length. So the Chanukah menorah has eight lights, not seven. b
Kindling captive souls in the reshus harabim
The reshus harabim is foreign territory, opposite the oneness of the Yachid shel Olam, yet the Chanukah lights were originally lit there, and today stand by the door or window facing it, to bring kedushah into tumah's domain. There, the Rav says, Jewish souls are held captive by the Satan.
Sources
Talmud Bavli
Rishonim
Tefillah and Piyut
Key points
- 1:19 A brachah rests on fullness, so the Rav asks why the brachah on the Chanukah lights is said over a menorah with empty receptacles.
- 4:23 Chanukah is a weekday not because it is inferior, but because that is its very character.
- 6:26 The Satan snatches the finer neshamos, and those who return in teshuvah are often more devoted than those raised in Yiddishkeit.
- 10:48 Chanukah is a sampling of Moshiach, and its eight lights reflect that eight stands for Moshiach.
- 14:09 A candle is a neshamah; the Chanukah lights are kindled in the reshus harabim to rescue souls held captive in the Satan's territory.
- 17:16 The empty receptacles are souls still waiting to be lit; on the 'eighth night', when Moshiach comes, all will be kindled.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 1:19 Why is the brachah on the Chanukah lights said over a menorah with empty receptacles, when a brachah should rest on fullness?
Answer: 17:16 The empty receptacles stand for extinguished souls waiting to be kindled; each night another is lit, and when Moshiach comes all will be bright.
-
Question: 10:58 Why does the Chanukah menorah have eight lights, unlike the seven of the Beis HaMikdash?
Answer: 10:48 Chanukah is a taste of Moshiach, and eight stands for Moshiach, as the harp of seven strings will have eight then.
Insights
- 17:13 The empty receptacles of the menorah, which seem to contradict the rule that a brachah rests on fullness, are themselves the message: they are souls still waiting to be kindled.
- 12:30 The reshus harabim, whose very name means 'the many', stands opposite the oneness of the Yachid shel Olam, yet the Chanukah lights were meant to be lit there to bring kedushah into the territory of tumah.
- 7:26 The Satan targets the finer souls, which is why returnees are often more devoted than those born into observance.
- 11:47 Unlike the seven-branched menorah of the Beis HaMikdash, the Chanukah menorah's eight lights show what the menorah will be like when Moshiach comes.
- 16:32 Each night's added light is another soul retrieved from the Satan's captivity, and the eighth night corresponds to Moshiach, when no receptacle will remain empty.
Mentioned in this shiur
People the Chashmonaim, the Maharal of Prague, the Rambam
Terms בית המקדש, חשמונאים, טומאה, מהדרין, נר חנוכה, קדושה, רשות היחיד, רשות הרבים