A Time for הודאה

Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) חנוכה no. ⁨9⁩ Pocket Guide p. 64 תשס"ט (2008–09) English 42 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 42 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that Chanukah, the time of hoda'ah, is a time of bracha in the sense of increase, tied to Yosef, to the number six and to Parshas Toldos, and he calls for real thanks and tefillah for Klal Yisrael in dangerous times.

Continuing from Mizmor l'Todah, the Rav calls Chanukah the zman of hoda'ah, set for Hallel and thanks, and defines hoda'ah as awareness of receiving more than one deserves, as Leah felt at Yehuda's birth. After the story of the Maggid of Mezritch and the Ba'al HaTanya on how each sedra fits its week, he explains that Chanukah's mitzvah grows from night to night, which is bracha: increase, as the letters of the word bracha show. Yosef, whose name means addition, is the sixth and embodies bracha; Toldos is the sixth sedra, full of bracha, and Yavan is addition in tumah. The Rav then speaks about the daily miracles behind Modim and Mizmor l'Todah, Kayin's and Hevel's offerings, the danger facing Jews in Eretz Yisrael and everywhere, and the need for tefillah, zechusim and teshuvah, since Chanukah is a time for yeshuos.

Topics: Thanks and Praise to Hashem · The Miracle of Chanukah and the Greeks · Yosef and His Brothers

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Chanukah, the time of hoda'ah listed in the guide

    Continuing from Mizmor l'Todah, the Rav calls Chanukah the zman of thanks, notes that the Rambam puts the laws of Hallel in the laws of Chanukah, and explains that each Yom Tov leaves a gift for the year. Chanukah's gift is hoda'ah, the awareness of receiving more than one deserves, as Leah felt at Yehuda's birth.

  2. 5:47 The Maggid's ba'al korei Story

    The Rav says each sedra is woven into the events of its week, and tells how the Maggid of Mezritch chose the future Ba'al HaTanya as his ba'al korei because he knew why each aliyah belongs to its day and to the person called up. He adds that Toldos is the first Shabbos of Kislev, the month of hoda'ah.

  3. 9:07 Bracha means increase; Yosef the sixth listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that the mitzvah and the brachos of Chanukah are mosif v'holech, ever increasing, and that this is the meaning of bracha, shown by the letters of the word, each a doubling. Yosef, the sixth, became two shevatim, and his name means addition, so he embodies bracha, with the word bracha appearing six times in Yaakov's blessing of him.

  4. 14:58 All of Kislev is Chanukah; Toldos the sixth sedra listed in the guide

    The Rav says the whole month of Kislev, the month of bracha, is Chanukah, which came from the mesiras nefesh of the Kohanim, like the readiness to give one's life in Shema. He then shows that Toldos is the sixth sedra, the sedra of bracha, with the word bracha in every aliyah, and ties Yosef to the sixth aliyah.

  5. 19:42 Yosef against Yavan listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Shelah that the strength of Yosef earned the Chanukah miracle, and explains that Yosef is addition in kedushah while Yavan is addition in tumah, invading what is not theirs, as the letters of the name Yavan show. On Chanukah Jews in turn go into the domain of tumah, lighting at night on the left side of the door; Toldos and the sixth aliyah carry the quality of Yosef.

  6. 23:41 Sixes of bracha listed in the guide

    The Rav shows the number six in Toldos: Yitzchak was sixty at the twins' birth and reaped a hundredfold in a year of hunger, and 666 is six in every place, the bracha of increase. Chanukah's thirty-six lights are six times six, the sixth aliyah holds the greatest bracha, Rosh Chodesh Kislev is the sixtieth day of the year, and the sixth middle bracha of Shemoneh Esrei is the one called bracha.

  7. 27:00 Daily miracles and the korban todah listed in the guide

    The Rav says Hashem makes miracles every day, so whoever thanks in Modim without believing it says something false. He explains why 'evening, morning and afternoon' was placed after 'Your miracles', that saying Mizmor l'Todah with thought takes the place of a korban todah, and contrasts Hevel's offering with Kayin's, which lacked a pure heart.

  8. 32:04 Caring about Jews in danger

    Bringing in his rebbe Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, who rebuked people for not caring what happens to Jews everywhere, the Rav describes the danger to Jews in Eretz Yisrael, surrounded by enemies arming themselves, and in New York too. He recalls how in the war a German general's advance was turned back through miracles, and says that Hashem will make miracles but Jews must daven and not sit in apathy.

  9. 37:41 Chanukah, a time of yeshuos listed in the guide

    The Rav says Chanukah is a time of yeshuos: the reading of the twelve Nesi'im on Chanukah is a zechus against the twelve princes of Yishmael. He calls for tefillah, zechusim and teshuvah, tells of a relative who wanted to leave Eretz Yisrael for America just before the Twin Towers fell, and brings the Gemara that a plague in Eretz Yisrael obligates Jews outside it too.

The shiur, written up

Chanukah, the time of hoda'ah

0:00

Continuing from Mizmor l'Todah, the Rav calls Chanukah the zman of thanks. The Rambam teaches the laws of Hallel only in the laws of Chanukah, because, as the Gemara in Shabbos says, Chanukah was set for Hallel and hoda'ah. a,b

3:34

Every Yom Tov leaves a gift for the whole year: geulah from Pesach, Torah from Shavuos, simchah from Sukkos. Chanukah's gift is hoda'ah, a person's awareness that Hashem gives him more than he deserves, as Leah felt when her fourth son, Yehuda, was more than her share. c

The Maggid's ba'al korei

5:57

Each sedra, the Rav says, is woven into the events of its week. The Maggid of Mezritch chose Zalman, later the Ba'al HaTanya, as his ba'al korei once he knew why each aliyah belongs to its day and to the person called up. Toldos is the first Shabbos of Kislev, the month of hoda'ah.

Bracha means increase

9:16

The mitzvah and the brachos of Chanukah are mosif v'holech, more light each day, and growth in quality or quantity is what bracha means, as in the passuk in Devarim 1:11. The letters of the word show it: beis is one become two, chaf is ten become twenty, reish is a hundred become two hundred. d

12:28

Yosef, the sixth, is bracha: he became two shevatim, and Rachel named him with 'Yosef Hashem li ben acher', an addition. In Yaakov's blessing of Yosef, the Rav says, the word bracha appears six times. e,f

All of Kislev is Chanukah

14:58

The whole of Kislev, the month of bracha, is Chanukah. Chanukah came from the mesiras nefesh of the Kohanim, a few against the Greek hordes, like the readiness to give one's life when saying Shema; the oil for one day that burned eight shows the same increase. g

18:17

Toldos is the sixth sedra, the sedra of bracha, and every aliyah in it contains the word bracha. Yosef is the sixth aliyah.

Yosef against Yavan

19:42

The Shelah says the strength of Yosef earned the Chanukah miracle. Yosef is addition in kedushah; Yavan, its counterpart, is addition in tumah, invading territory not its own, even the Beis HaMikdash. The letters yud, vav, nun, each an extension of the last, show it. i

21:41

On Chanukah, Jews enter the domain of tumah, lighting in the dark of night on the left side of the door.

Sixes of bracha

23:55

In Toldos, Yitzchak was sixty, ten times six, when the twins were born, and in a year of hunger he alone had bracha, a hundredfold. Six in units, tens and hundreds, 666, is the bracha of increase, and Chanukah's thirty-six lights are six times six. The Rav cites the Tzvi LaTzaddik that Rosh Chodesh Kislev is the sixtieth day of the year, and notes that the sixth middle bracha of Shemoneh Esrei is the only one with the word bracha. j,k,l,m

Daily miracles and the korban todah

27:26

Hashem makes miracles every day, so one who thanks in Modim without believing it says something false. The Rav asks why 'evening, morning and afternoon' stands after 'Your miracles' instead of at the beginning of Modim, and answers that it carries a second intention: miracles three times every day. o

29:16

Since a korban todah cannot be brought today, saying Mizmor l'Todah takes its place, and saying it with one's mind on the stock market is a flawed offering. Kayin and Hevel both brought thanks, but Kayin's lacked purity of heart. n,p

Caring about Jews in danger

32:30

The Rav recalls his rebbe, Reb Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, who rebuked people for not caring what happens to Jews everywhere. Jews in Eretz Yisrael are in great danger, a few million against hundreds of millions of enemies arming themselves, and New York is not safe either.

36:29

In the war a German general in Alexandria boasted of coffee in Tel Aviv, and that night became the turning point. Hashem will make miracles, the Rav says, but Jews must daven and not sit in apathy.

Chanukah, a time of yeshuos

37:43

Chanukah is a time of yeshuos: the reading of the twelve Nesi'im on Chanukah is a zechus against the twelve princes of Yishmael. So, he says, tefillah, zechusim and teshuvah are needed, and thought about how to become better. q

40:00

A relative who feared the intifada wanted to move to America; two days after the Rav returned there, the Twin Towers fell. The Gemara says a plague in Eretz Yisrael obligates even those outside it, and he closes with a call to contribute tefillah and zechusim. r

Sources

Torah

  1. c Bereishis 29:35 text index In the write-up: 3:34
  2. d Devarim 1:11 text index In the write-up: 9:16
  3. e Bereishis 30:24 text index In the write-up: 12:28
  4. f apparently Bereishis 49:25-26 index In the write-up: 12:28
  5. g Devarim 6:4 text index In the write-up: 14:58
  6. j Bereishis 25:26 text index In the write-up: 23:55
  7. k apparently Bereishis 26:12 index In the write-up: 23:55
  8. p Bereishis 4:3-5 text index In the write-up: 29:16
  9. q apparently Bamidbar 7 index In the write-up: 37:43

Kesuvim

  1. n Tehillim 100:1 text index In the write-up: 29:16

Talmud Bavli

  1. b Shabbos 21b text index In the write-up: 0:00
  2. r Gemara (place not identified) index In the write-up: 40:00

Rishonim

  1. a apparently Hilchos Megillah vaChanukah ch. 3 index In the write-up: 0:00
  2. h Rashi (place not identified) 16:07 index

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. i Shelah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 19:42
  2. l Tzvi LaTzaddik (place not identified) index In the write-up: 23:55

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. m apparently Shemoneh Esrei, Birkas HaShanim index In the write-up: 23:55
  2. o apparently Shemoneh Esrei, Modim index In the write-up: 27:26

Key points

  1. 2:13 Chanukah is the zman of hoda'ah, set by Chazal for Hallel and thanks, and its gift for the year is thankfulness.
  2. 4:44 Hoda'ah is a person's awareness that Hashem gives him more than he deserves, as Leah said at the birth of her fourth son.
  3. 9:16 Bracha means increase, and Chanukah, whose lights and blessings grow each day, is entirely bracha.
  4. 12:28 Yosef, the sixth, is the embodiment of bracha, and the strength of Yosef is what earned the miracle of Chanukah.
  5. 29:16 Saying Mizmor l'Todah with thought is like bringing a korban todah, and saying it with one's mind elsewhere is like a flawed korban.
  6. 33:35 Jews in Eretz Yisrael and everywhere are in danger, and the Rav says one must daven, gather zechusim and do teshuvah, since Chanukah is a time for yeshuos.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 2:35 Why does the Rambam teach the laws of Hallel only in the laws of Chanukah, near the end of the book of Zmanim?

    Answer: 3:04 Because Chanukah was established for Hallel and hoda'ah, as the Gemara in Shabbos says.

  2. Question: 28:00 Why did the Anshei Knesses HaGedolah not put 'evening, morning and afternoon' at the beginning of Modim, where it seems to belong?

    Answer: 28:26 They intended a second meaning as well: that Hashem makes miracles three times every day.

  3. Question: 30:42 Kayin and Hevel both brought a thanksgiving offering; why was only Hevel's accepted?

    Answer: 31:19 Kayin's offering lacked the proper purity of heart.

Stories

  1. 6:33 The Maggid chooses a ba'al korei

    The Maggid of Mezritch needed a new ba'al korei, and was told that Zalman, later the Ba'al HaTanya, was a good one. The Maggid asked him whether he knew how the sedra relates to the events of each week, why each of the seven aliyos belongs to its day, and why the person the gabbai calls up belongs to his aliyah. He answered that he knew each time, and the Maggid made him his ba'al korei.

    In the story: the Maggid of Mezritch, the Ba'al HaTanya

    told in 5 other shiurim →

  2. 36:12 The general who was turned back

    In the war a German general was already in Alexandria, conquering one country after another, and said he would drink coffee in Tel Aviv the next morning. That night was the turning point of the entire war; he could not enter Eretz Yisrael, and through miracles the British army pushed them back.

    told in 5 other shiurim →

  3. 39:49 The relative who wanted to move to America

    About five years earlier, a relative of the Rav in Eretz Yisrael told him during his summer visit that she could not sleep for fear of the intifada and wanted to move to America. He answered that he was more afraid to be in America. Two days after he arrived back in America the Twin Towers fell, with about three thousand victims.

    told in 1 other shiur →

Insights

  1. 10:38 The letters of the word bracha each show a doubling: beis is one become two, chaf is ten become twenty, and reish is a hundred become two hundred.
  2. 20:00 Yavan is the opposite of Yosef: Yosef is addition in kedushah, Yavan is addition in tumah that invades what is not its own, and the letters yud, vav, nun, each an extension of the one before, show this.
  3. 21:36 On Chanukah the Jews in turn enter the domain of tumah: the lights are lit in the darkness of night, at the left side of the door, which represents the sitra achra and the public domain.
  4. 28:13 Placing 'evening, morning and afternoon' after 'Your miracles that are with us every day' carries a second intention: that there are miracles three times every day.
  5. 15:12 The whole month of Kislev is Chanukah: the twenty-four days before it belong to the twenty-fifth, which the Rav links to Shema Yisrael and mesiras nefesh.
  6. 38:00 Reading the offerings of the twelve Nesi'im on Chanukah is a zechus against the twelve princes of Yishmael.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 29:32 The Rav says Mizmor l'Todah should be said with awareness of what one is saying, since it stands in place of a korban todah.
  2. 32:36 Following his rebbe, the Rav says one should want to know what is happening to Jews wherever they are.
  3. 37:15 The Rav says Jews must daven for the Jews in danger and not sit in apathy, busy with foolishness.
  4. 39:20 He calls for tefillah, zechusim and teshuvah, and for each person to think what he can do to become better and contribute.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Hevel, Kayin, Leah Imeinu, Matisyahu ben Yochanan Kohen Gadol, Menashe, Rachel Imeinu, Rav Shraga Feivel Mendlowitz, Rivka Imeinu, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Maggid of Mezritch, the Rambam, the Shelah HaKadosh, Yaakov Avinu, Yehudah (son of Yaakov), Yitzchak Avinu, Yosef HaTzaddik

Terms אנשי כנסת הגדולה, בעל קורא, ברכה, הודאה, מוסיף והולך, מסירות נפש, נשיאים, סטרא אחרא, קרבן תודה, רשות היחיד, רשות הרבים

Report an error on this page