8 Days Ruled by the Timeless Light of משיח (connection to פרשת וישלח)

Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) חנוכה no. ⁨6⁩ Pocket Guide p. 64 תשס"ו (2005–06) English 40 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 40 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that the eight days of the Chanukah miracle were one long day in the Mikdash, a glow of the light of Yemos HaMashiach that stands above the seven-day order of time.

The Rav opens with the Gemara that wicks and oils unfit for Shabbos may be used for Chanukah, and explains that the light of Chanukah reaches souls that Shabbos cannot ignite. Chanukah is a foretaste of Yemos HaMashiach, when the seven-stringed harp of the Mikdash will have eight strings. Time is built of seven days, while Moshiach will be above time. He notes the strange wording of the Beraisa and the Mechaber, 'on the 25th of Kislev the days of Chanukah are eight', which the Rama corrects with 'begin'. He asks how the Kohanim could fulfil the mitzvah with miraculous oil, and answers that in the Mikdash the eight days were one long day, so the first lighting stretched over all eight. This explains why Chanukah is named for the 25th, why the Kohanim cried and then stopped, the word 'mitzvah' in Haneiros Halalu, and how Hashem moved the nature of the future into that time. He closes that Chanukah is a time of thanking Hashem, above all for being a Jew.

Topics: The Miracle of Chanukah and the Greeks · Seven and Eight: Nature and Above · Moshiach and the Days of Moshiach · The Chanukah Lights

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Chanukah light for souls Shabbos cannot ignite listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Gemara that wicks and oils unfit for Shabbos may be used for Chanukah, and explains that the Shechinah comes down on Chanukah to souls that Shabbos cannot ignite. He then calls Chanukah a foretaste of Yemos HaMashiach, when the seven-stringed harp will have eight strings.

  2. 7:59 Above time: 'the days of Chanukah are eight' listed in the guide

    The Rav says time is built of seven days while Moshiach will be above time, and Chanukah too is not bound by the order of time. He points to the difficult wording of the Beraisa and the Mechaber, 'on the 25th of Kislev the days of Chanukah are eight', which the Rama corrects by adding 'begin'.

  3. 11:22 Can a mitzvah be done with miracle oil? listed in the guide

    The Rav asks how the Menorah could be lit with oil that refilled miraculously, since such oil is not olive oil squeezed from olives. He brings the Derech Pikudecha that a mitzvah cannot be done through a miracle, and describes the Kohanim crying over it.

  4. 17:05 Time in Yemos HaMashiach and the eighth note listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that in Yemos HaMashiach the order of time will change and days will be like years, comparing it to the year of the Mabul when the constellations did not function. Creation follows seven notes, as the seven days and the seven mizmorim of Kabbalas Shabbos show; Moshiach will bring an eighth, Binah, and the Chanukah miracle was a glow of that light above time.

  5. 23:32 One day eight days long in the Mikdash listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that Hashem gave the Mikdash one day that lasted eight days, so the Kohanim's first lighting continued and they did not need to relight; the Chashmonaim's mizmor ending 'orech yamim' alludes to this. This answers the Beis Yosef's question why all eight days are called by the name of the 25th, and the wording without 'begin'. He then asks why the Kohanim stopped crying if the stretched day were not so.

  6. 27:13 The Menorah above and the stretched mitzvah listed in the guide

    With the parable of two pianos, the Rav explains that whatever is done below registers above: the Menorah burning in the Mikdash below meant the Menorah above was burning, and the Kohanim cried for fear of darkness in the world. The miracle was that the single lighting remained a mitzvah, which explains the word 'mitzvah' in Haneiros Halalu, kept by the Ba'al HaTanya, and he concludes that Hashem moved the nature of Yemos HaMashiach into the time of the Chashmonaim.

  7. 34:07 Chanukah's blessing: thanking Hashem

    The Rav says each Yom Tov has its own blessing to take along, and that of Chanukah is hallel and hoda'ah; the Rambam waits until the laws of Chanukah to give the laws of Hallel. He calls for a cheshbon hanefesh of all Hashem's kindnesses, and above all thanks for being a Jew, since on Chanukah the Jews fought for Torah, Shabbos, Rosh Chodesh and milah.

The shiur, written up

Chanukah light for souls Shabbos cannot ignite

0:37

The Rav opens with a teaching he attributes to the Maor VaShemesh and others, built on the Gemara that wicks and oils which may not be used for Shabbos may be used for Chanukah. Those wicks and oils do not burn well, and he explains that they stand for souls, as the passuk calls the soul 'the candle of Hashem'. Shabbos cannot ignite such souls, but on Chanukah the Shechinah comes down to visit them and help them. b,c,d

7:02

From here he calls Chanukah a foretaste of Yemos HaMashiach. The Gemara says the harp of the Mikdash had seven strings, and in the days of Moshiach it will have eight. Music now is limited to seven notes; that eighth string, he says, plays for us on Chanukah. e

Above time: 'the days of Chanukah are eight'

7:59

Time, the Rav explains, is built of seven days, while Moshiach will be above time, and Chanukah too is not bound by the order of time. He then points to the difficult wording of Megillas Taanis, also used by the Mechaber: 'on the 25th of Kislev the days of Chanukah are eight', as if they were one day. The Rama corrects it by adding 'begin'. h,i,j

Can a mitzvah be done with miracle oil?

11:32

Next the Rav raises a difficulty. The Menorah requires olive oil, oil squeezed from the olive, but oil that burned partway and was miraculously refilled is oil of a miracle, not olive oil. He cites the Derech Pikudecha, who has a whole drush that a mitzvah cannot be done through a miracle; a mitzvah must be done naturally. k

14:04

He adds that the Kohanim cried over this, since the Menorah was burning through a miracle.

Time in Yemos HaMashiach and the eighth note

17:05

The Rav explains that in Yemos HaMashiach the order of time will be different: a day will be as long as a year. He compares it to the year of the Mabul, when the constellations did not function and day and night did not follow their order. l

20:00

Creation, he says, follows seven notes, one for each of the seven days, which is why Kabbalas Shabbos has seven mizmorim leading to the mizmor of the Shabbos day. Moshiach will bring an eighth string, a different conduct altogether that cannot be imagined now. As known from Tanya, counting up from Malchus the seventh is Chesed and the eighth is Binah, and that is Chanukah. The miracle was a glow of that light, above time. m,n

One day eight days long in the Mikdash

23:44

Because the miracle came from the eighth light, the Rav explains, Hashem gave the Mikdash one day that lasted eight days, while outside things were normal. The Kohanim lit on the first night and were not obligated to light again, because it was still the same night. The mizmor the Chashmonaim said ends with 'orech yamim', a long day, and that is what they received. o

25:21

This answers the Beis Yosef's question: if Chanukah means they rested on the 25th, why are all eight days called so? All eight were one day, the 25th, which is why the Mechaber omits 'begin'. The Rav then asks: if not so, why did the Kohanim stop crying once they saw the Menorah burning? g,i

The Menorah above and the stretched mitzvah

27:35

The Rav answers with a parable: two pianos placed side by side, where striking a key on one makes the other play. Whatever is done below registers above. There is a Kohen Gadol below, Aharon, and one above, Michael, and when the Menorah burned in the Mikdash below, the Menorah above burned too. The Kohanim cried for fear that the Menorah above had gone out, which means galus and darkness; seeing it burn, they knew it was sending light and blessing. p

31:24

The miracle, then, was that their single lighting remained a mitzvah. This explains the words 'all eight days of Chanukah' with 'mitzvah' in Haneiros Halalu, which some omit but the Ba'al HaTanya keeps. The Kohanim lit naturally; Hashem, who prepared at creation the nature for later, moved the nature of Yemos HaMashiach into that time. q,r

Chanukah's blessing: thanking Hashem

34:36

Each Yom Tov, the Rav says, has a blessing to pack and take along for the year, and Chanukah's is hallel and thanks. The Rambam, in Sefer Zmanim, waits until the laws of Chanukah to give the laws of Hallel, because thanks is Chanukah's blessing. t

38:42

He says a Jew should make a cheshbon hanefesh and see that, despite his complaints, he has much to thank for, above all being a Jew. On Chanukah the Jews fought against the decree to write that they have no share in the G-d of Israel, for Torah, Shabbos, Rosh Chodesh and milah. u

Sources

Kesuvim

  1. d Mishlei 20:27 text index In the write-up: 0:37
  2. f apparently Tehillim 16:11 7:10 index
  3. m apparently Tehillim 92:1 index In the write-up: 20:00
  4. o apparently Tehillim 91:16 index In the write-up: 23:44

Talmud Bavli

  1. c Shabbos 21a text index In the write-up: 0:37
  2. e apparently Arachin 13b index In the write-up: 7:02
  3. p apparently Chagigah 12b index In the write-up: 27:35
  4. s apparently Shabbos 21b 35:48 index

Midrash

  1. h apparently Shabbos 21b index In the write-up: 7:59
  2. u apparently Bereishis Rabbah 2:4 index In the write-up: 38:42

Rishonim

  1. l apparently Rashi, Bereishis 8:22 index In the write-up: 17:05
  2. t apparently Rambam, Hilchos Megillah v'Chanukah ch. 3 index In the write-up: 34:36

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. a Me'or Einayim (place not identified) 0:24 index
  2. b Maor VaShemesh (place not identified) index In the write-up: 0:37
  3. g Beis Yosef (place not identified) index In the write-up: 25:21
  4. i apparently Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 670:1 index In the write-up: 7:59, 25:21
  5. j apparently Rama, Orach Chaim 670:1 index In the write-up: 7:59
  6. k Derech Pikudecha (place not identified) index In the write-up: 11:32
  7. n Tanya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 20:00

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. q Haneiros Halalu (place not identified) index In the write-up: 31:24
  2. r Siddur of the Ba'al HaTanya (place not identified) index In the write-up: 31:24

Key points

  1. 0:48 Wicks and oils that do not burn well on Shabbos may be used on Chanukah, because the light of Chanukah reaches souls that Shabbos cannot ignite.
  2. 7:15 Chanukah is a foretaste of Yemos HaMashiach, the eighth string beyond the seven notes of the present world.
  3. 7:59 Time is built of seven days, while the light of Moshiach, from which the Chanukah miracle came, is above time.
  4. 23:44 In the Mikdash the eight days of the miracle were one day eight days long, so the Kohanim did not have to light again.
  5. 36:41 Chanukah is a time of thanking Hashem, and above all for being a Jew, which is what the Chanukah war was fought for.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 10:00 Why does the Beraisa, and the Mechaber after it, say 'on the 25th of Kislev the days of Chanukah are eight', as if all were one day?

    Answer: 25:56 Because in the Mikdash the eight days were one day stretched to eight days' length.

  2. Question: 11:32 How could the Kohanim fulfil the mitzvah with oil that came from a miracle, which is not olive oil?

    Answer: 24:57 They lit only once, naturally; the night stretched over eight days, so the first lighting remained the mitzvah.

  3. Question: 25:21 Why is the whole Yom Tov called Chanukah, if the Beis Yosef explains the name as 'they rested on the 25th', which fits only the first day?

    Answer: 25:56 All eight days were one day, the 25th.

  4. Question: 26:57 If the later nights had no mitzvah of their own, why did the Kohanim stop crying once they saw the Menorah still burning?

    Answer: 30:34 Because the Menorah below keeps the Menorah above burning, bringing light and blessing to the world rather than darkness.

Insights

  1. 1:45 The wicks and oils that burn poorly stand for souls that Shabbos cannot ignite; on Chanukah the Shechinah comes down to them, so they are fit for Chanukah lights.
  2. 25:47 The Beraisa says 'on the 25th of Kislev the days of Chanukah are eight' without 'begin', because in the Mikdash all eight days were literally one day, the 25th.
  3. 30:09 The Kohanim's crying was not over a lost mitzvah but over the Menorah above: as long as the Menorah below burns, the Menorah above glows and sends light and blessing; if it goes out there is galus and darkness.
  4. 33:14 The Kohanim lit naturally, not by a miracle: Hashem, who prepared at creation the nature for now and the nature for later, moved the nature of Yemos HaMashiach into the time of the Chashmonaim.
  5. 37:37 The Rambam holds back the laws of Hallel until the end of Sefer Zmanim, in the laws of Chanukah, because hallel and thanks are the particular blessing of Chanukah.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 38:42 The Rav says a Jew should make a cheshbon hanefesh on Chanukah and see that, despite his complaints, he has much to thank Hashem for.
  2. 38:59 He says to thank Hashem for every small and big thing, but above all not to forget to thank Him for being a Jew.
  3. 34:22 He says one should take the blessing of each Yom Tov along for the whole year, like packing it in a suitcase.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Aharon HaKohen, Dovid HaMelech, Rabbi Yosef Karo (the Beis Yosef), the angel Michael, the Baal HaTanya (Rabbi Shneur Zalman of Liadi), the Rambam, the Rema

Terms בינה, הודאה, חשבון הנפש, חשמונאים, טבע, ימות המשיח, למעלה מן הזמן, נר חנוכה, פרסומי ניסא, פתילות ושמנים, רבונו של עולם

Report an error on this page