The Greek War Against Faithfulness

Catalog entry: ZMANIM (English) חנוכה no. ⁨10⁩ Pocket Guide p. 64 תשס"ט (2008–09) English 39 min

Listen

  1. Download · Length 39 min

Open in the listening app

Notes Notes prepared by AI from the recording; not reviewed, and not the Rav's words. The recording is the source.

About this shiur

The Rav explains that the Greek war against Klal Yisrael was a war against emunah, which is faithfulness, the bond of Klal Yisrael to Hashem like a wife to her husband, and that tumah is what breaks that bond.

The Rav opens with the principle that what happened to the Avos is a sign for their children: the episode of Dina and Shechem foreshadows the Greek decrees, and Levi, not Shimon, led the fight, as the Kohanim and Yehudis did at Chanukah. He asks why, according to the Rashbam, the women were the main part of the miracle. Greek philosophy accepts only what the mind understands; emunah is faithfulness, an instinctive bond like that of a wife to her husband, which the Avnei Nezer uses to explain why a woman is trusted to remarry on one witness. The name Yisrael expresses that bond, and tumah is a barrier that destroys it, so the Greeks set out to defile. The pach shemen came from the place where the dust for the sotah was taken. Yaakov needed the name Yisrael before facing Shechem. The Rav ends with today's war of tumah brought in through electronic devices.

Topics: The Miracle of Chanukah and the Greeks · Simple Emunah, Above Reason · Tumah, Taharah and Mikveh

Order of the shiur

  1. 0:00 Dina, Levi and the women of Chanukah listed in the guide

    The Rav brings the Ramban's principle that what happened to the Avos is a sign for their children: the episode of Dina foreshadows the Greek decrees, and Levi, not Shimon, carried the fight, as the Kohanim and Yehudis did later. He brings the Rashbam that the women were the main part of the miracle and asks why.

  2. 5:06 Greek philosophy versus emunah as faithfulness listed in the guide

    The Rav describes the Greek idea of accepting only what the mind understands, shows its illogic with an example from medicine, and defines emunah as faithfulness, an instinctive bond like a wife's to her husband. He brings the Avnei Nezer on why a woman may remarry on one witness, and explains that Levi felt this bond more, rallying to 'Mi laShem elai' with Moshe and later with Matisyahu.

  3. 12:59 The name Yisrael and tumah as a barrier listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that Klal Yisrael carries the name Yisrael as a wife takes her husband's name, joining 'yashar' with Hashem's Name. Since Hashem is pure, the bond exists only with taharah; tumah is a barrier that destroys emunah, which is why so many mitzvos require taharah.

  4. 17:00 The Chazon Ish and the dentist's hands Story listed in the guide

    The Rav tells how the Chazon Ish, treated at night by a dentist who rushed over before washing his hands, felt the tumah of his fingers affect his learning. He adds that Torah must be learned in purity, and concludes that the war of Yavan was emunah against kefirah, tumah against taharah.

  5. 20:15 The Greeks in the Heichal and the hidden pach shemen listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that the Greeks entered the Heichal not to destroy but to defile, and that what is said of a woman applies to Klal Yisrael, who is pure. He asks how the pach shemen could be hidden under the Heichal floor without breaking its stones, answers from the Gemara in Sotah about a loose marble slab with a ring, from where the dust for the sotah was taken, and concludes that the pach symbolizes the purity of Knesses Yisrael.

  6. 26:56 Why Yaakov wanted the name Yisrael from the angel listed in the guide

    The Rav asks why Yaakov wanted the angel of Esav to call him Yisrael rather than wait for Hashem at Beis El. He brings Rav Tzadok HaKohen that emunah includes knowing one is a Yisrael, the Radbaz that one may not even say he is a Yishmaeli in a time of persecution, and explains that Yaakov knew he would first face Shechem, which stands for the battle of Yehudis.

  7. 31:49 Shechem, Yavan and the separateness of Yisrael listed in the guide

    The Rav explains that Shechem's idea, like Yavan's, was that the Jews are not separate, and that the Greeks forced Jews to write that they have no portion in the G-d of Yisrael. He brings 'ki nevalah asah b'Yisrael', the breaches the Greeks made in the barrier of the Temple Mount, and connects Chanukah to the twenty-five letters of Shema Yisrael and to the mezuzah.

  8. 35:26 The war of tumah today listed in the guide

    The Rav concludes that Yaakov needed the name Yisrael for his fight with Shechem, which stands for Yavan. He then says the war of Yavan is being replayed in the times before Moshiach through tumah brought into Jewish homes by electronic devices, mentions his shul's rule about cell phones, and calls for mesirus nefesh for taharah.

The shiur, written up

Dina, Levi and the women of Chanukah

0:02

The Rav opens with the principle the Ramban brings, that what happened to the Avos is a sign for their children. The violation of Dina by Shechem was a sign of the Greek decrees, and the war of Yaakov's sons against Shechem foreshadowed the war of the Chashmonaim. Levi, not Shimon, carried the victory, since Shimon was not perfect in this, as Zimri shows; so too the Kohanim and Yehudis saved Klal Yisrael from Yavan. a

3:16

The Gemara says the women too were part of the miracle, and the Rashbam, brought by Tosafos, explains that they were its main part. The Rav asks why: the war, the lights and Yehudis's deed were each only one item in the fight against Yavan. b,c,d

Greek philosophy versus emunah as faithfulness

5:13

To answer, the Rav describes Greek philosophy, still accepted in the scientific world: accept only what the mind can understand and prove. He calls this illogical, since every generation discovers what the previous one did not know. Its print remains even in medicine, where a suspected drug is used until years later it is found to have killed many. Emunah is the opposite, believing what the mind cannot grasp, and that is logical, since we understand only a tiny bit of what exists. The war of Yavan was against emunah.

8:41

Emunah, the Rav explains, is faithfulness, an instinctive bond with Hashem like a child's to a parent, and Shir HaShirim describes it as the bond of chassan and kallah. The Avnei Nezer explains that a woman may remarry on one witness because of the instinctive bond between husband and wife: were he alive, her heart would not let her marry another. e,f

11:21

Shevet Levi feels this bond more, since Levi's birth itself expressed the bond of husband and wife. So at the Golden Calf Levi rallied to Moshe's call 'Mi laShem elai', and again when Matisyahu used the same words. g,h

The name Yisrael and tumah as a barrier

13:12

A wife takes her husband's name, as the first woman was called 'ishah' because she was taken from 'ish'. So Klal Yisrael bears the name Yisrael: Yaakov, called 'yashar', joined with Hashem's Name. The Rav points to the words 'ushmeinu karasa bishmecha' said before Kedushah. i,j

15:43

Hashem is pure, so the bond exists only with taharah. Tumah is a barrier that destroys emunah, which is why so many mitzvos require taharah.

The Chazon Ish and the dentist's hands

17:08

The Rav tells that the Chazon Ish suffered toothaches, and a neighboring dentist in Bnei Brak treated his gums. Woken one night, the dentist rushed over before washing negel vasser, and the Chazon Ish felt the tumah of his fingers affect his learning, so he made a request for next time. The Rav adds that one who scratches his head while learning should wash his hands, since the words of Hashem are pure. The war of Yavan was emunah against kefirah, tumah against taharah. k

The Greeks in the Heichal and the hidden pach shemen

20:31

The worst thing the Greeks could do, the Rav says, was not to destroy the Beis HaMikdash but to defile it; they entered the Heichal to make things tamei. What is said of a woman applies to Klal Yisrael, who is pure.

23:11

The Gemara says the Greeks defiled all the oils in the Heichal, and one pach was found hidden in the ground, as Rabbi Akiva Eiger discusses. The Rav asks how its hiders could lift the Heichal's floor stones, when removing a stone of the Mikdash is forbidden. He answers from the Gemara in Sotah: a square amah of marble lay there uncemented, with a ring to lift it, and from there the dust for the sotah was taken. Lifting it is not breaking, as with a well's lid on Shabbos. The pach that symbolized taharah's victory came from the place that testifies to a wife's purity. l,m,n

Why Yaakov wanted the name Yisrael from the angel

27:49

The angel of Esav told Yaakov that Hashem would name him Yisrael at Beis El, yet Yaakov insisted on hearing it now. The Rav asks why he did not wait.

28:49

Rav Tzadok HaKohen writes that emunah includes knowing that one is a Yisrael. In a time of persecution a Jew asked if he is Jewish may not deny it, and the Radbaz rules one may not even claim to be a Yishmaeli. Yaakov knew that before Beis El he would face Shechem, which stands for the battle of Yehudis for the holiness of the daughters of Yisrael. o,p

Shechem, Yavan and the separateness of Yisrael

31:58

A Jew calls himself Yisrael, as the passuk says, since Klal Yisrael is to Hashem as Chava, the rib, is to Adam. Shechem claimed the Jews are not separate, and Yavan forced Jews to write that they have no portion in the G-d of Yisrael. The brothers answered that defiling their daughters is 'nevalah' in Yisrael. The Greeks breached the Chel, the barrier between Yisrael and the nations, and Chanukah corresponds to the twenty-five letters of Shema Yisrael. q,r,s

The war of tumah today

35:36

This answers the question: Yaakov needed the name Yisrael for Shechem, which, like Yavan, sought to rip it out. Today, the Rav says, in the times before Moshiach, as seen in Daniel, the war of Yavan is replayed through tumah carried into Jewish homes by electronic devices. His shul resolved to have no phones with text messages, and the same applies to the internet; as the Chashmonaim had mesirus nefesh for taharah, so must Jews today. t

Sources

Torah

  1. g apparently Bereishis 29:34 index In the write-up: 11:21
  2. h Shemos 32:26 text index In the write-up: 11:21
  3. i Bereishis 2:23 text index In the write-up: 13:12
  4. r Bereishis 34:7 text index In the write-up: 31:58

Nevi'im

  1. q Yeshayahu 44:5 text index In the write-up: 31:58

Kesuvim

  1. e Shir HaShirim (place not identified) index In the write-up: 8:41
  2. k Tehillim 12:7 text index In the write-up: 17:08
  3. t Daniel (place not identified) index In the write-up: 35:36

Mishnah

  1. s apparently Middos 2:3 index In the write-up: 31:58

Talmud Bavli

  1. b apparently Shabbos 23a index In the write-up: 3:16
  2. l Shabbos 21b text index In the write-up: 23:11
  3. n apparently Sotah 15b index In the write-up: 23:11

Rishonim

  1. a Ramban on Torah (place not identified) index In the write-up: 0:02
  2. c apparently Tosafos Megillah 4a index In the write-up: 3:16
  3. d apparently Rashbam Pesachim 108b index In the write-up: 3:16

Acharonim and Chassidus

  1. f Avnei Nezer (place not identified) index In the write-up: 8:41
  2. o Tzidkas HaTzaddik (place not identified) index In the write-up: 28:49
  3. p Shu"t Radbaz (place not identified) index In the write-up: 28:49

Tefillah and Piyut

  1. j Siddur (place not identified) index In the write-up: 13:12

Other

  1. m apparently Gilyon HaShas, Shabbos 21b index In the write-up: 23:11

Key points

  1. 1:51 The episode of Dina and Shechem was a sign for the Greek decrees, and Levi and the Kohanim, not Shimon, were the ones who won that war.
  2. 5:13 Greek philosophy accepts only what the mind can understand and prove, which is the opposite of emunah.
  3. 8:41 Emunah is faithfulness: an instinctive bond between Klal Yisrael and Hashem, like that of a wife to her husband.
  4. 16:01 Tumah is a barrier that destroys that bond, so the Greek war against emunah was a war of tumah against taharah.
  5. 32:53 The Greeks tried to erase the name Yisrael, which expresses Klal Yisrael's bond with Hashem, and Yaakov needed that name before his encounter with Shechem.
  6. 36:32 The Rav says the war of Yavan is being replayed today through tumah that enters Jewish homes, and calls for mesirus nefesh against it.

Questions and answers

  1. Question: 4:08 According to the Rashbam, why were the women the main part of the Chanukah miracle?

    Answer: 8:16 Because the war of Yavan was against the emunah and taharah of Klal Yisrael, whose bond with Hashem is that of a wife, and Yehudis gave her life for the holiness of the daughters of Yisrael.

  2. Question: 23:47 How could the pach shemen be hidden in the ground under the Heichal, when removing a stone of the Mikdash is forbidden?

    Answer: 24:55 The Gemara in Sotah describes a marble slab, a square amah, not cemented to the floor and with a ring to lift it, from where the dust for the sotah was taken; lifting it is not considered breaking, as with a well's lid on Shabbos.

  3. Question: 28:25 Why did Yaakov want the angel of Esav to call him Yisrael, rather than wait for Hashem to do so at Beis El?

    Answer: 31:05 Because before Beis El he would face Shechem, which stands for Yavan's attempt to erase the name Yisrael, and he needed the name Yisrael to help him against it.

  4. Question: 2:18 Why was the victory over the Greeks brought through Levi and the Kohanim and not through Shimon, who also fought Shechem?

    Answer: 2:30 Shimon alone was not perfect in this, as seen from Zimri of his tribe, while Levi felt the bond with Hashem more strongly.

Stories

  1. 17:00 The Chazon Ish and the dentist

    The Rav relates from a biography of the Chazon Ish that he once suffered excruciating toothaches and needed a dentist in Bnei Brak, a neighbor, to massage his gums. One night, while the Chazon Ish was learning, he had such an attack, and the dentist was woken and gladly came to help. Afterwards the Chazon Ish made a request of him for the next time, since the dentist, woken in the night, had rushed over before washing negel vasser, and the Chazon Ish felt the tumah of his fingers affecting his learning.

    In the story: the Chazon Ish

    told in 1 other shiur →

Insights

  1. 5:20 The Rav argues that the Greek rule of accepting only what one understands is itself illogical, since the mind grasps only a tiny part of what exists; it is emunah that is logical.
  2. 8:41 Emunah is not only belief but faithfulness, the instinctive loyalty of a wife to her husband; the Avnei Nezer shows such an instinct is reliable enough that a woman may remarry on one witness.
  3. 11:21 Levi felt the bond with Hashem more strongly because Levi's very name came from the bond of husband and wife, which is why Levi answered 'Mi laShem elai' both with Moshe and with Matisyahu.
  4. 13:12 Klal Yisrael bears the name Yisrael as a wife bears her husband's name: 'yashar' joined with Hashem's Name.
  5. 16:01 Because tumah is a barrier in the bond with the pure G-d, a war against emunah is in essence a war of tumah; the Greeks entered the Heichal to defile rather than to destroy.
  6. 25:22 The pach shemen, the symbol of taharah's victory, was hidden under the very marble slab from which the dust for the sotah was taken, the place that testifies to the purity of a wife and of Knesses Yisrael.
  7. 31:05 Yaakov needed the name Yisrael from the angel before Beis El because he would first face Shechem, which, like Yavan, sought to rip out the name Yisrael.

What the Rav says to take from it

  1. 37:25 The Rav says that just as the Chashmonaim had mesirus nefesh for the war of taharah against tumah, so must one today.
  2. 37:38 The Rav relates that his shul resolved not to have cell phones with text messages, which bring in tumah, and says the same applies to the internet in Jewish homes.
  3. 19:10 The Rav remarks that people learning who scratch their head should wash their hands, or at least rub them.

Mentioned in this shiur

People Dinah, Ezra HaSofer, Leah Imeinu, Levi (son of Yaakov), Matisyahu ben Yochanan Kohen Gadol, Moshe Rabbeinu, Rabbi Akiva Eiger, Rabbi Tzadok HaKohen of Lublin, Shechem ben Chamor, Shimon (son of Yaakov), the Avnei Nezer of Sochatchov, the Chazon Ish, the Radbaz, the Ramban, the Rashbam, Yaakov Avinu, Yehudis, Zimri ben Salu

Terms אמונה, היכל, חציצה, חשמונאים, טהרה, טומאה, יוונים, מסירות נפש, מעשה אבות סימן לבנים, עקבתא דמשיחא, פך השמן, רבונו של עולם

Report an error on this page