כשמדליקין הנרות נעשה ככהן וביתו כביהמ"ק
Catalog entry: זמנים חנוכה no. 8 Pocket Guide p. 19 תשנ"ז (1996–97) Yiddish 43 min
Listen
About this shiur
The Rav explains that when a Jew lights the Chanukah candles his home becomes a Beis Hamikdash and he himself becomes like a kohen, and that the light of Chanukah, the hidden light of the days of Moshiach, comes down into the darkness of exile and brings blessing in Torah and the habit of thanking Hashem.
The Rav opens with the passuk 'Ashrei kol yerei Hashem' as Rav Hirsch reads it: the warmth of the Jewish home, which needs nothing from outside, and the shul and beis medrash, from which Torah's warmth is brought home. On Chanukah, he says, 'Yevarechecha Hashem mi-Tziyon' comes true even on a weekday: lighting the candles is a remembrance of the Mikdash, so the home becomes a Beis Hamikdash and every Jew becomes a kohen. He ties this to the hidden light of Moshiach's days, to the Rambam's ruling that lighting the menorah needs no kohen, and to the name Chashmonaim. He explains Chanukah as a family mitzvah like the Shabbos candles, and why one may not benefit from its light: it comes down into the weekday darkness of exile. He closes with Chanukah as a time of blessing for the barren in body and in Torah, chiddushim that give rise to chiddushim, and hallel and thanks.
Topics: The Chanukah Lights · The Jewish Home and Shalom Bayis · Thanks and Praise to Hashem · The Hidden Light
Order of the shiur
-
0:00 The warmth of the Jewish home
Following Rav Hirsch on 'Ashrei kol yerei Hashem', the Rav contrasts the content, warm Jewish home with the gentile search for excitement outside, and adds the shul and beis medrash as the community's home from which the fire of Torah is brought back. Every passuk, he says, speaks anew to every generation and every soul.
-
4:43 The home becomes a Beis Hamikdash listed in the guide
The Rav notes that the main miracle of the day was the victory in the war, and explains that lighting Chanukah candles is a remembrance of the menorah in the Mikdash, so that for the half hour they burn each home becomes a Beis Hamikdash. Yerushalayim visits every Jew on Shabbos; the chiddush of Chanukah is that it comes on a weekday.
-
8:55 Matisyahu, and every Jew a kohen listed in the guide
Using the triad of time, place and soul, the Rav calls Matisyahu the soul of Chanukah and notes that his name equals 'Beis Hamikdash' in gematria. Whoever lights does a Mikdash service and becomes a kohen, a glimpse of the hidden light of Moshiach's days when all Jews will be kohanim; he explains through this the Rambam's ruling that lighting the menorah needs no kohen.
-
15:10 The name Chashmonaim listed in the guide
The Rav brings the Chasam Sofer that Chashmon hints at oil for eight days, then offers his own reading: as Haman resented the Jewish festivals and Purim was added, so the Greeks tried to abolish chodesh, Shabbos and milah and the mitzvah of ner Chanukah was added, all four hinted in the letters of Chashmon. He adds that the name also hints at 'kohen' for eight days.
-
18:47 A mitzvah of the family
The Rav explains that ner Chanukah, 'ner ish u-veiso', is a mitzvah on the household, not on the individual like tefillin, and so it fits the passuk about the Jewish family. Ner Shabbos is also a family obligation and Shabbos is itself a Mikdash; the chiddush of Chanukah is that this comes on a weekday.
-
22:01 Why one may not use the Chanukah light
The Rav asks why one may not benefit from the Chanukah light, the hidden light kept for the tzaddikim, when the Shabbos light is also hidden light and one may enjoy it, learning by it with a special Shabbos sweetness. He answers that on Shabbos a Jew is raised to a higher world, while on Chanukah the higher world comes down into exile, in the darkest time of the year.
-
27:02 Lighting inside as the street invades
The Rav explains that the candles were once lit facing the public domain, but as Moshiach's time nears the public domain pushes into the Jewish home, today through television, radio and the internet, so one must at least light up the home. Even in such darkness, through ner Shabbos and ner Chanukah a Jew can see 'the good of Yerushalayim' at home.
-
30:18 Remembering the barren, and blessing as increase
The Rav brings the Bnei Yissaschar that Chanukah, like Rosh Hashanah, is a time when the barren are remembered, in body and in spirit: unanswered tefillos and Torah without blessing. With the Maharal he explains that bracha means increase, and he cites the Bnei Yissaschar that one who says chiddushei Torah fulfils the mitzvah of having children.
-
35:31 Chiddushim from chiddushim; hallel and thanks
The Rav brings the Ba'al Shem Tov on why David called Achitofel his rebbe for two things: a chiddush from kedushah gives rise to further chiddushim, and that is 'banim l'vanecha'. He then says the root of Chanukah is hallel and hoda'ah, as in the days of Moshiach only the korban todah will remain, and one must accustom oneself to thank Hashem for every small thing; he shows this from the Rambam's placement of the laws of hallel in hilchos Chanukah.
The shiur, written up
The warmth of the Jewish home
Following Rav Hirsch on 'Ashrei kol yerei Hashem', the Rav describes the warm, content Jewish home. Gentiles seek excitement outside, in stores and restaurants; a Jew content with what he has finds warmth at his family table. Beyond the home stands the shul and beis medrash, the community's home, from which the fire of Torah is carried back into every house. Every passuk, he adds, speaks anew to each generation and each soul. a,b
The home becomes a Beis Hamikdash
The Rav notes that the main miracle of the day was the victory in the war. Lighting the Chanukah candles is a remembrance of the menorah in the Mikdash, so for the half hour they burn every Jew's home becomes a Beis Hamikdash, and 'Yevarechecha Hashem mi-Tziyon' comes true there. Yerushalayim visits every Jew on Shabbos; the chiddush of Chanukah is that it comes on a weekday. a
Matisyahu, and every Jew a kohen
Everything, the Rav says from Sefer Yetzirah, exists in time, place and soul, and the soul of Chanukah is Matisyahu, named in Al HaNissim; Matisyahu equals 'Beis Hamikdash' in gematria. Whoever lights does a service of the Mikdash and becomes a kohen, and the words 'kohanecha hakedoshim' in Haneiros Halalu apply to him. d,e,f
The Bnei Yissaschar brings that through the Chanukah lights the hidden light of Moshiach's days is revealed, when, as the Ba'al HaTurim says on 'mamleches kohanim', every Jew will again be a kohen. This explains the Rambam's ruling that lighting the menorah needs no kohen while preparing it does: the lighting already belongs to that future light, 'arachti ner limshichi'. g,h,i,j,k
The name Chashmonaim
The Chasam Sofer reads 'Chashmon' as oil for eight days. The Rav adds his own reading: as Haman resented the Jewish festivals, as the Gemara in Megillah tells, and Purim was added, so the Greeks sought to abolish chodesh, Shabbos and milah, and ner Chanukah was added. Chashmon hints at all four, and also at 'kohen' for eight days. l,m
A mitzvah of the family
Why one may not use the Chanukah light
The Rav asks why one may not use the Chanukah light, which the Bnei Yissaschar calls the hidden light kept for the tzaddikim. The Shabbos light is also hidden light, yet one may enjoy it, and he describes the sweetness of learning by the Shabbos candles. He answers that on Shabbos a Jew rises to a higher world, while on Chanukah that world comes down into exile, on a weekday, in the darkest time of the year. o
Lighting inside as the street invades
As Moshiach approaches, the Rav explains, the public domain pushes into the Jewish home, today through television, radio and the internet, so one must at least light up the home. Through ner Shabbos and ner Chanukah, which Rashi says the Gemara in Shabbos means by 'one accustomed to lights', a Jew sees 'the good of Yerushalayim' even in exile. p,c,a
Remembering the barren, and blessing as increase
Chiddushim from chiddushim; hallel and thanks
The Rav brings the Ba'al Shem Tov on the mishnah in Avos that David called one from whom he learned two things his rebbe. That teacher was a rasha whose Torah bore no fruit; but a chiddush of kedushah is accepted above, and another Jew builds a further chiddush on it. David did so, and this is 'banim l'vanecha'. The Rav mentions the chassidim's custom to learn after lighting. t
The essence of Chanukah, the Gemara says, is hallel and hoda'ah. A Midrash says that in Moshiach's days only the korban todah will remain, and the Rav says one must accustom oneself to thank Hashem for every small thing. Hence the Rambam puts the laws of hallel in hilchos Chanukah: its root is Chanukah. u,v,w
Sources
Torah
Kesuvim
Mishnah
Talmud Bavli
Midrash
Zohar and Kabbalah
Rishonim
Acharonim and Chassidus
Tefillah and Piyut
Other
- b apparently Rav S.R. Hirsch on Tehillim 128 In the write-up: 1:16
Key points
- 6:33 Lighting the Chanukah candles is a remembrance of the Mikdash, so for the half hour they burn every Jew's home becomes a Beis Hamikdash.
- 10:38 Since he performs a service of the Mikdash, every Jew who lights becomes like a kohen, a foretaste of the days of Moshiach when all Jews will be kohanim.
- 18:55 Ner Chanukah is a mitzvah on the family, like ner Shabbos, and through both a Jew can see 'the good of Yerushalayim' in his own home even in exile.
- 22:10 The Chanukah light is the hidden light kept for the future; on Shabbos a Jew rises to a higher world, while on Chanukah that higher world comes down into weekday exile.
- 30:25 Chanukah is a time of blessing for those 'barren' in body or spirit: for tefillos that went unanswered and for Torah learning that bore no chiddushim.
- 40:24 The heart of Chanukah is hallel and hoda'ah, and the Rav says one must accustom oneself to thank Hashem for every small thing.
Questions and answers
-
Question: 22:01 Why may one not benefit from the Chanukah light when one may benefit from the Shabbos light, which is also the hidden light?
Answer: 25:35 On Shabbos a Jew rises to a higher world, a semblance of Moshiach's days; on Chanukah the higher world comes down into weekday exile, which is not yet its time.
-
Question: 13:31 Why does lighting the menorah not need a kohen, while preparing it does?
Answer: 14:35 Because the lighting belongs to the light of the future, when all Jews will be kohanim, while the preparation does not yet.
-
Question: 17:00 Why did the Greeks want to abolish precisely chodesh, Shabbos and milah?
Answer: 17:02 They are the foundations of Judaism; and as with Purim, Hashem answered by adding a mitzvah, ner Chanukah, hinted together with them in the name Chashmon.
-
Question: 36:49 Why did David call Achitofel his rebbe for only two things, when Achitofel was a rasha whose Torah bore no fruit?
Answer: 37:35 Following the Ba'al Shem Tov, David made further chiddushim from those two things, and a chiddush that gives rise to chiddushim is the mark of a true rebbe.
-
Question: 42:12 Why does the Rambam include the laws of hallel in hilchos Chanukah?
Answer: 42:23 Because the root of Chanukah is thanking and praising Hashem, so hallel has its root in Chanukah.
Insights
- 9:34 Matisyahu, the 'soul' of Chanukah, is in gematria 'Beis Hamikdash': in the days of Matisyahu every Jew merits a Beis Hamikdash in his own home.
- 13:31 Lighting the menorah needs no kohen while preparing it does, because the lighting already belongs to the light of the future, when every Jew will be a kohen.
- 15:51 The letters of Chashmon hint at chodesh, Shabbos, milah and ner: the three mitzvos the Greeks tried to abolish and the mitzvah of ner Chanukah that was added in response, as Purim was added when Haman resented the Jewish festivals.
- 22:32 One may enjoy the Shabbos light but not the Chanukah light, though both are the hidden light, because on Shabbos a Jew is raised to a higher world, whereas on Chanukah that world comes down into weekday exile, where it is not yet the time to use it.
- 27:31 The order of lighting inside the home reflects the approach of Moshiach's days, when the public domain pushes into the Jewish home, as it does today through television, radio and the internet.
- 37:31 Following the Ba'al Shem Tov, the sign that a chiddush comes from kedushah is that another Jew builds a further chiddush on it; this is 'banim l'vanecha', grandchildren in Torah.
- 42:12 The Rambam places the laws of hallel in hilchos Chanukah, which shows that the root of hallel is Chanukah.
What the Rav says to take from it
- 41:41 The Rav says one must accustom oneself to thank Hashem for every small thing, and that this is the lesson of Chanukah.
- 39:20 The Rav cites the custom of chassidim to sit down and learn after lighting the Chanukah candles.
- 27:54 Since the street pushes into the home, the Rav says one must at least make the home itself bright.
Mentioned in this shiur
People Achitofel, Dovid HaMelech, Haman, Matisyahu ben Yochanan Kohen Gadol, Rabbi Pinchas of Koretz, Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch, Rashi, the Baal HaTurim, the Baal Shem Tov, the Bnei Yissaschar (Rabbi Tzvi Elimelech of Dinov), the Chasam Sofer, the Maharal of Prague, the Rambam, Yaakov Avinu
Terms אור הגנוז, הודאה, זכר למקדש, חידושי תורה, לעתיד לבוא, נר חנוכה, פקידת עקרות, קרבן תודה, רשות היחיד, רשות הרבים